CHEENI KUM
Ilayaraja marries his new sound to his old tunes in a charming trifle of a soundtrack.
MAY 20, 2007 – LISTENING TO US Ilayaraja fans whining about his of-late overdependence on artificial sound – synth drums, synth flutes, synth everything – you’d think we’d like nothing better than to have the maestro and his MIDI interfaces separated by the space roughly occupied by the erstwhile USSR. But that’s far from it, really. We are the same people who swooned over, for instance, the portion of the second interlude of Oru Poongavanam (Agni Natchatiram) where a cushion of sinusoidal violins enveloped the discrete notes being punched out on a… synthesiser. But the synth sound there was pickle, and now it’s become the main course – and that’s our problem. We are, after all, talking about a genius of orchestral arrangement – those majestic cascades of real violins, the sharply-etched patterns of real percussion – and to see him move on from the magnificence of those man-made sounds to mere approximations facilitated by machinery is to see a lion grazing on grass. And grass, however green, is just… grass. And if that’s how we feel about the new songs, you can only imagine the levels of apprehension when the old ones get the synth treatment, which is the case with the soundtrack for Cheeni Kum. Manram vantha thendralukku from Mouna Raagam, Kuzhaloodhum kannanukku from Mella Thirandhadhu Kadhavu, Vizhiyile mani vizhiyile from Nooravadhu Naal – each one a glistening diamond of the maestro’s inexhaustible eighties’ oeuvre. Will they now be reduced to zircon imitations?
Not exactly. It does take a while – four or five listens – for your head to wrap itself around familiar songs dressed up in an unfamiliar style. But once you’ve freed yourself of earlier associations – to the extent that such a thing is possible – you begin to see interesting things. In Jaane do na, Shreya Ghoshal (in exquisite form) reproduces the melody lines of Vizhiyile mani vizhiyile note for note, but everything else is different – and it’s not just the arrangements. The original number begins with the male voice launching into the first line of the song, and that’s there in this new version too (except, of course, that it’s no longer a male voice) – but there, this was followed by the female voice humming the latter part of the line, the two-note motif at the lower end of the octave that would make its rather sinister presence felt through the remainder of the piece (especially at the close of the first stanza, where this motif is underlined thrice, first by the male, then the female, then picked by the strings before they soar into the higher notes to form the rest of the interlude). But in the retooled number, after Shreya launches into the first line, the keyboard reiterates the first part of the line, the lighter part – and this doesn’t translate into a discernible motif either. Jaane do na, therefore, is just a fresh song, one that skips along with a spring in its step where its predecessor proceeded with a statelier gait.
And listening to this, a thought suddenly struck me. Could the pep in the new version be the result of Ilayaraja wanting to escape his classical associations – his associations not just with classical music, but his reputation as a classical composer? Without the rooting motif in Jaane do na, the segues are less clean, more unpredictable (and even frustrating sometimes) – but maybe that’s what he’s going for now. The one thing that’s been remarkable about Ilayaraja’s (early) music for me is that once a song begins, the way he’s structured it would seem the only way for it to be structured. Everything would fall into place with such a satisfying click, you could not imagine a single additional notation on the music sheet. It was the classical way of going about it, taken to the extreme that was humanly possible. But maybe that phase of his life is over – the court composer phase – and maybe now he just wants to be a swinging pop star. In Jaane do na, the first interlude has a lovely bit with strings (synth strings maybe, for they sound a bit too sharp) but it’s just… a lovely bit with strings, with no past, no future. It plays its part and pretty much disappears – perhaps echoed a little in another bit with strings in the second interlude, but nothing more. And there are flourishes throughout – odd pauses, jerky transitions with percussion rolls – that accentuate the anything-goes nature of the reworking.
I guess I’m saying that these remixed versions aren’t going to make me walk away from their parents anytime soon, but the tracks in Cheeni Kum do possess a charm of their own. As to why this sudden affinity for Ilayaraja in his synth mode, it could be that he’s chosen tunes that sit well within the confines of a present-day Hindi film album (as opposed to, say, Saara yeh aalam in Shiva, which was a reworking of Aananda raagam from Panneer Pushpangal; the latter’s high pitches and gamaka-rich phrasings from the Carnatic raga Simhendramadhyamam didn’t exactly lend themselves to casual listening or humming along with). The wistful Manram vantha thendralukku gets transformed into Cheeni Kum (Shreya Ghoshal), which begins on a bouncy note, with synth bursts drenching the opening lines like summer showers and with a faster-paced first interlude (that retains the saxophone as a nod to the earlier song). But there’s no way to make the stanzas any lighter, for the melody lines in these parts are practically a wail – so while the original is an all-out cry from the soul, this one keeps flitting between happiness and heartbreak. (Another interesting tweak comes towards the end of the stanzas, where you keep waiting for Shreya to hit that high note of the original and she makes a startling U-turn to the lower registers. However, Sooni Sooni – a melancholic spin on Cheeni Kum, sung by Vijay Prakash – traverses all the way up to that high note.)
One track, though, manages to stand on its own – successfully dispelling the looming shadows of its predecessor – and that’s the delightful Baatein hawa hain saare (Shreya Ghoshal again; in a repeat of this number, Amitabh Bachchan chips in with a few spoken lines). While Kuzhaloodhum kannanukku – whose Version 2.0 this is – was entirely one of a piece (the genre would be rustic solo, perhaps?), Baatein has been reimagined entirely as a stunning compendium of musical genres. The first interlude features the kind of full-out symphonic arrangement that recalls Ilayaraja’s phenomenal work in Avatharam and Hey Ram (that feeling when, after a particularly heavy strings section, a lone flute takes off like a dove that’s just been set free – ah!), the second interlude begins with heavy-duty electric guitar chords (and real drums) and moves onto a jazz duet between percussion and trumpet that’s capped off sweetly by a silvery piano run – and none of this baggage prevents the song from being so utterly light on its feet. An instrumental piece played on the saxophone – on a base of what sounds like a strident synth loop – is equally wonderful, the surprise element being the incorporation of a cleverly reworked phrase from En iniya pon nilaave (Moodupani). It’s quite the sprightliest thing Ilayaraja has done in some time.
Then there’s the theme music, a simple tune on the piano that gets augmented with strings and a mini-symphonic movement and the opening riff of Cheeni Kum. The rest of the piece is a beautiful permutation-combination of these elements – and, yes, despite the synthesiser playing such a major part. For all that, this album is undeniably a lesser work from one of our bona fide musical geniuses. (I can’t help linking the lessness of this work to the brilliant title design, where the lettering of the ‘K’ is done with a vertical line and an angle bracket, which, of course, is the less-than sign. Less than… kum… get it?) Perhaps only someone who’s never listened to the older songs – or the older Ilayaraja – can fully get this album the way it’s meant to be got. For the rest of us, an entertaining diversion though this may be, Ilayaraja is too entrenched in our psyche as court composer to make us need him as pop star. And when we feel like a taste of the Ilayaraja magic in the Hindi language (in a Tamil film, though), we can simply replay that magnificent composition sung by Bhupinder and S Janaki all the way back in the early eighties. I’m referring to Kaise kahoon from Nandu, which featured a beauty of a tune backed by real violins (which is why they could be played pizzicato), a real flute, a real Spanish guitar, a real tabla and a real drum kit. Oh, there were synth sounds galore, but just as pickle. The main course that resulted is still a feast for the ears.
Copyright ©2007 The New Sunday Express
Zero
May 15, 2007
>>”We are, after all, talking about a genius of orchestral arrangement – those majestic cascades of real violins, the sharply-etched patterns of real percussion – and to see him move on from the magnificence of those man-made sounds to mere approximations facilitated by machinery is to see a lion grazing on grass.”
Amen to that, sir, amen to that!
Cheeni Kum is quite lovely, nevertheless. Wonderful review. (And, somehow, among all the recent reworks of Raaja, in this album and Shiva, I feel Police Police is the loveliest!)
LikeLike
RaviKrishna
May 15, 2007
Rangan,
Nice review. Somehow this album didn’t work much for me. Why listen to remix when I can listen to original. Plus I felt that the orchestra of the songs was a big let down, except the two instrumental piece. The orchestra was different from the recent Shiva song “badlee yeh hawa” where it was very good (I suspect that YSR did the job for his dad).
for originality, spunky orchestra etc, Mumbai Xpress still rocks for me. That song ” Korangu Kaiyil Malai” should be considered as a course material for jazz music in an indian song.
LikeLike
Vivek
May 16, 2007
cudn ve put it better!!
but u ve nt written anythin abt the stale lyrics…i felt, the lyrics more than anythin else,affected me when i heard the songs..esp the title track..such a letdown…:-(
LikeLike
brangan
May 16, 2007
Zero: Thanks. Actually, I didn’t mind Saara yeh aalam either, just that it sounded a bit “odd” in Hindi. The songs in CK lend themselves much better to the reworkings.
RaviKrishna: But MX was a genuinely pathbreaking soundtrack. This is just a lark – a charming one, but a lark nontheless. I’d just look at it as Ilayaraja having himself some fun. And yes, that Dheemi dheemi number was quite outstanding.
Vivek: I probably should have said something about the lyrics, but they were so banal, I didn’t feel like it. Plus, I think I’ve gotten used to the (bad) quality of lyrics when they’re fitted into pre-existing song structures (especially from other languages).
LikeLike
Zero
May 16, 2007
Baradwaj,
Ah, ‘mind’ is a strong word. I think all the reworks (I’d shudder to call them ‘remixes’ :)) are pretty good. Just that, many a time, I inevitably feel like listening to the original instead!
‘Police Police‘ wasn’t all that obeisant to its original, and yet didn’t turn out to be an unwieldy derivative. A superb fun song. Somehow, not many found it that good.
LikeLike
sureshkumar
May 16, 2007
few drops came out of my eyes, when i read these lines…
“Everything would fall into place with such a satisfying click, you could not imagine a single additional notation on the music sheet.” – what i felt most of the times whie listening to ir’s songs and the quality which we cannot hear in not even a single song coming out these days
“(that feeling when, after a particularly heavy strings section, a lone flute takes off like a dove that’s just been set free – ah!)” – beautiful written, it is a kind of experience which gave me goose-bumps
so many times while listening to IR’s songs
the review of this album couldn’t get any better…
thank you…
LikeLike
brangan
May 16, 2007
Zero: “many a time, I inevitably feel like listening to the original instead!” For me that’s always the case. I found CK charming for a few listens, but other than maybe Baatein hawa and the instrumentals, I don’t see myself returning to the others very much.
sureshkumar: Thank you sir.
LikeLike
Shankar
May 17, 2007
Baddy, that was an awesome review. You hit the right chord, man.
LikeLike
karrvakarela
May 17, 2007
Hi Baradwaj,
This isn’t related to your post but I was wondering if you knew of website to download Indian/Tamil music, like an Indian iTunes. I’m looking for some AR Rahman oldies like En Veetu Thotatill and En Swaasa Katre.
Any ideas?
LikeLike
Ravi K
May 18, 2007
Karrvakarela, a lot of Indian songs are available on iTunes itself. En Veetu Thottathil and En Suvasa Katrae (spelled like that) are available there.
IR is one of those composers whose latest works we always subconsciously compare to his best works. Taken on its own merits, CK is a good album, but I won’t be listening to it for long.
His 90s and 2000s synth-based music is awkward compared to the way newer MDs like ARR and YSR sophisticatedly use synths, loops, etc. Kadhalukku Mariyathai is his best synth-based album in the years after ARR’s arrival. IR’s best works in the past 10 years are acoustic-based works like Azhagi, Hey Ram, and Mumbai Xpress.
LikeLike
Qalandar
May 18, 2007
Wonderful review Baradwaj…I have been out of the loop for quite a while, and yours is one of the voices I have missed the most.
The new site looks awesome, but I can’t seem to navigate around it — did you put a review of Parthiveeran up?
LikeLike
b
May 18, 2007
in response to the previous comment/question, try raaga.com.
LikeLike
brangan
May 18, 2007
Shankar: Thanks man. What’s new with H1B’s? Haven’t heard anything in a while…
karrvakarela: guess the others have told you where to go, but if it’s just to listen to songs, I find musicindiaonline a great resource – especially for the older songs (sixties and earlier).
Ravi K: Actually, I hate KM 🙂 I thought his next album for Fazil – Kannukkul Nilavu – was much better.
Qalandar: Thanks. Long time bro… been on a sabbatical? Review of PV was in the older site…
LikeLike
Qalandar
May 18, 2007
Nahin yaar, no sabbatical, but work has been kinda crazy of late, and the cinema scene relatively dreary, so wasn’t online/blogging much…
LikeLike
RaviKrishna
May 18, 2007
rangan,
I love “oru pattam poochi” of KM. I haven’t heard/recollect any other songs of KM.
I didn’t know it was a 1997 movie. I heard it the first time in Radio Mirchi Chennai in 2004 when I was in India last (when we met). I loved it the very first time I heard it. There are very few songs I love first time itself.
The interlude music is very good, specially the second one.
BTW I saw that song on youtube or some other site and I felt it was picturized badly.
LikeLike
karrvakarela
May 18, 2007
Ravi K, b, Baradwaj: thanks!
What does En Suvasa Katrae mean, incidentally?
LikeLike
Shankar
May 18, 2007
Baddy, I’d like to catch up with you offline from this forum. Please write to me at shankar@h1bees.com. I don’t have your e-mail though I could probably ask Solu, Mickey, Malai or somebody else.
BTW, we released our next album “Padal” in Jan of this year. It’s been received very well over here. I’ll try and send you a copy if possible. I feel that the song concepts and excution have all turned out pretty well and unique. You can check out samples at http://www.h1bees.com
LikeLike
munimma
May 19, 2007
The first feeling on hearing it was disappointment. It is all there, yet it is not. There is a little je ne sais quoi missing, even if you can ignore the originals. My favorite was sooni sooni by VP. Who is he?
LikeLike
George
May 19, 2007
aah lovely; the album couldn’t deserve a better review; bonus flute trills for mentioning Simhendramadhyamam and a extra drum roll for Nandu’s kaise kahuu.N. If you can tell me how I can find IR’s best mastered diligently on CD, I could dedicate some syncopated bass runs to you 🙂
LikeLike
Ravi K
May 20, 2007
George, orientalrecords.com has a lot of IR classics from the 80s on well-mastered CDs.
LikeLike
brangan
May 20, 2007
karrvakarela: “En Suvasa Katrae” (approximately) = my life-breath; the hero says the heroine is like the air he breathes. Kinda like that phenomenal song by The Hollies: Sometime, all I need is the air that I breathe and to love you…
Shankar: Have sent you a mail…
munimma: “It is all there, yet it is not” is a good way of putting it.
George: Thank you (rim shot). As Ravi K says, orientalrecords.com would be a source, but I don’t know if they’re “diligently” mastered, as you put it. Some of the recordings I’ve heard show their age.
LikeLike
Hari E
May 20, 2007
Nice review. This album is probably the best attempt in translating Illayaraja’s classics from south to north audience. R.Balki, you had already attempted that in his ads, might have helped in picking up the songs for his first movie.
I think Jane Do Naa sounded very differnt from the tamil original. But I second with Ravi saying that Mumbai express is probably the best album from IR in recent times by a long shot.Kadaliku mariyadillia is a ok album. It was just a luck that that album became a big winner.
LikeLike
Ravi K
May 21, 2007
George and Brangan, I do not know if every Oriental Records CD is well-mastered but the four that I own sound excellent.
LikeLike
Anand
May 21, 2007
I think I like this review more for the way you talk about really and truly appreciating classic IR! ‘Satisfying click’ just about sums it up! And I for one find it difficult to entirely go crazy about (like I usually do on IR’s works) the re-made songs in this soundtrack – I have heard the songs only a few times now, but none of the interludes in the songs have captured my imagination so far the way only Raaja’s music writing can. Shreya Ghoshal is fantastic, as usual. I think a lot of these tracks work because of her, too.
And honestly, there are very few works of IR that I like where he has reverted to the use of synth sounds (in the majority) rather than real instruments. From the late nineties (Kaadhalukku Mariyaadhai, Nilave Mugam Kaattu), he does not seem to have come very far in the use of ‘sound’, as against musical composition. The one exception I can think of is the brilliant ‘Meetaadha Our Veenai’ from this movie called ‘Poonthottam’ – predominantly synth sounds (i think that was a real bass though), but the song works again because of excellent writing/composition, and not the use of sound. IR has a long way to go to reach where ARR and Shankar-Ehsan-Loy are today.
It does look like Raaja was just tooling around in this movie, cranking up the reverb, throwing in some basic clean sounds and the odd minor-9th floating around in the background – not really rolling up his sleeves and do what he does best. And I’m going to take this album in that spirit and not get worked up anymore! 🙂
LikeLike
Anand
May 22, 2007
Addendum – Jaane Do Naa is based on ‘Vizhiyile mani Vizhiyile’, and also on the song ‘Jotheyali’ from the Kannada movie ‘Geetha’. The melody lines in all the three songs are the same note for note. The Kannada song was and is hugely popular, is from the same time period as ‘Vizhiyile’, and is played in Kannada FM channels in Bangalore even today as an SPB/Raaja classic.
LikeLike
RaviKrishna
May 22, 2007
Anand,
You are right that IR is way behind ARR and SEL in sound engineering. However you forgot to add Harris Jeyaraj. He is as good as ARR in sound engineering.
LikeLike
k.arunprakash
May 23, 2007
excellent review.
LikeLike
brangan
May 23, 2007
Hari E, arunprakash: Thanks.
Anand: Would you know if the kannada song came before the Tamil one, or was it the other way around? As regards “sound”, I don’t know if that’s a big problem, because the MSV songs – for instance – we listen to even today because the melodies and the arrangements are so good. I’m not saying sound isn’t important, but aren’t these the more important things we look for in a song?
LikeLike
Anand
May 23, 2007
The Kannada movie ‘Geetha’ came out in 1980, and ‘Nooravadhu naal’ in 1984. Hail IMDB! 🙂
To a large extent, I’ll agree that “sound” is not the number one criterion. However, there are composers today who write basic tunes and riffs, but ‘kill’ on sound engineering. I bring it up here bcos it looks like IR has down-played his usual interlude-scoring prowess a bit, and I therefore wonder if the intention was to emphasize sound.
In any case – keyboard bass?? Sacrilege! 🙂
LikeLike
Zero
May 23, 2007
I actually much prefer the “old sound” — the vintage audio quality, the “coarser” choruses etc. — to the “new sound.” That’s where I want to belong. And, this is not nostalgia.
LikeLike
ARVINDH
May 23, 2007
Thank you for this great review!
LikeLike
Sekhar
May 23, 2007
Yes, Why listen to remix when we can pleasantly enjoy the beautiful originals.
LikeLike
Shankar
May 24, 2007
As much as I detest Raaja’s obsession with synth sound nowadays, I still feel he does come up with strong melodies if he is suitably motivated. For example, “Yaaro Thodatha” from the recent Ajantha was a throwback to (g)olden days in terms of the melody. Though mellow, the synth instrumentation wouldn’t terribly excite even die-hard Raaja fans. Similarly, some of the tracks from recent malayalam movies like Vinodayathra, Pachakuthira etc have all of Raaja’s flourishes. But I do agree, the “satisfying clicks” and “signatures” are far and few in between nowadays!! That’s a pity…for fans like me.
LikeLike
Nagaraj
June 11, 2007
Baradwaj:
I read your review on the music of Cheeni kum about a week back.
As usual, my curiosity was excited, after reading your review and I bought the CD.
Man, it was disappointing. But that did me one favour: I went out and bought the music of Mouna Raagam and Mella Thiranthathu Kathavu, and am having a great time.
I hope my neighbours don’t come and tell me if I don’t own any other music at all. But I am sure that they are as captivated as I am about the lovely original music, and am waiting to see if one of them wants to borrow the music.
Let’s see!
Nagaraj
LikeLike
Shiva
July 14, 2007
Hello, fellow IR fans , I like to share the news that the old tunes were made in CK on request of the movie director balki.Also the CK songs are for to suit the movie while watching not to hear alone.The music director has to work according to the screenplay and to the taste of north.If you add more preludes of flute,violen, trumpet — is this will flourish in north I guess?—- Again give IR a good story and a stunning screnplay, you will get a stunning rocking songs. for example check the pithamagan,most of the songs are background songs, yet it is worth hearing for years.Give IR a break by giving a brilliant script you will hit the world cinema.Examples are Nayagan, virumandi,devar magan, hey ram and pitha magan. A reply for all the disappointed in coming “Nan kadavul”.For the frustrated hearts just hear malayalam– manasinakara,pachkuthira,Rasathanthiram and achuventa amma.– U will cherish. Bye
LikeLike
Hemant Kowshik
July 31, 2007
While I cant comment on the “then and now” aspect of ilaiyaraja, I must say the saxophone theme on cheeni kum is fantastically brilliant. Great syncopation all over the piece and thumping bass make for a good listen. Its filled with themes from Ilaiyaraja through the years.
LikeLike
S. ILANGOVAN
July 4, 2009
Hats off! What a wonderful review of Ilayaraja’s music style itself. Can’t be betted worded than this:
“MIDI interfaces separated by the space roughly occupied by the erstwhile USSR.” “We are, after all, talking about a genius of orchestral arrangement – those majestic cascades of real violins, the sharply-etched patterns of real percussion – and to see him move on from the magnificence of those man-made sounds to mere approximations facilitated by machinery is to see a lion grazing on grass.” “He’s structured it would seem the only way for it to be structured.”
Exactly my thoughts- only that I did not have the words. You did! Who’s the person? Have you written anything elsewhere about Ilayaraja’s music? I would be interested in reading. You may reply directly to ilanadvice@gmail.com.
I too had felt that Ilayaraja has lost his fire power- just making one great song in a full album- particularly after 2000. Now I think it has changed. Ilayaraja is back in full form in his original orchestral style. In the latest albums – Naan Kadavul, Nandalala and reasonably in Vaalmiki, Ilayaraja has done amazing work, reminiscent of the glorious 70s’ and 80s’. Any opinion on these?
– S. Ilangovan.
LikeLike