OF SEASON
Sikkil Gurucharan talks about December…
DEC 9, 2007 – AT LEAST ONE FAN OF SIKKIL GURUCHARAN will be paying very careful attention to the singer’s alapanas this month. You know this portion of the concert, of course. It’s when the musician closes his eyes, when he furrows his brow in utmost concentration. It’s when those apparently meaningless syllables pour forth, assuming instant meaning – upon materialisation – in the context of the contour of the raga. And it’s when his hands begin to scramble frantically at the air in front, as if attempting to dislodge his lotus-posed immobility.
These exertions, last year, caused the sleeves of Gurucharan’s kurta to roll back, only to reveal a sturdy wristwatch with an unremarkable strap of dull-brown leather. The fan was dismayed. In that instant, the music ceased to matter. He ran home and poured his anguished heart out in a words-to-this-effect email to his idol: “You should change your watch, because a gold strap will show you in an imposing light when you lift your hand to sing the raga. Oh, and while you’re at it, do go for gold-rimmed spectacles. Better still, switch to contacts.”
Will these fervent entreaties result in a makeover? The fan waits with bated breath – as does Gurucharan’s mother, who has given up trying to convince her young son about the inappropriateness of white kurtas at his age. Her advice: “They make you look older. Why don’t you try new colours?” At least she’s not wondering – as this other fan did – if Gurucharan chooses his kurtas to match the background of the sabha. For the record, he doesn’t – and the question forming shape, at this point, is this: Why is everyone talking about things that would seem to have no bearing on what’s really important – the music?
Oh, but these things are important in December. “All performances lead to the December season,” says Gurucharan. “The year closes in December, and people’s judgment of an artist also comes to a close in December.” Music is everywhere this month, when – at least among a section of the Chennai populace – musicians become as big as movie stars, capable of filling up entire concert halls in advance, capable of inspiring enough dewy-eyed devotion among fans to elicit not only vociferous approvals of sabash and balé, but also fashion-tips e-mails.
“The season is a benchmark,” says Gurucharan, with the hindsight of having made his breakthrough as a junior artist in December 2004. “Even in June or July, if you go to a concert, the rasikas say, ‘Did you hear him last season?’ They want to see how an artist copes with so many concerts, with the different accompanists, with the time constraints.” The media too – heretofore largely silent in matters of this music at the other end of the spectrum from popular – comes alive. “The newspapers say that wherever in the world you are, this is where you have to be for Carnatic music. Radio stations announce who’s going to sing and when and where. TV channels have concerts of their own.”
With such a splendid platform to showcase his wares, it isn’t surprising that Gurucharan begins preparing for the season by taking stock of his inventory. “I’ve started looking at my song lists from last season’s concerts, to avoid repeating the same pieces at the same venues this December,” he says. “You can’t avoid repeating the ragas themselves – you have ten or so big ragas, which are very easy on the ears of the rasikas (when it comes to the main piece of the concert). But the songs must be unique.” The implication is that even with a raga as inevitable as Sankarabharanam, the effort could be to favour the more intricate Dakshinamoorthe over a Mahalakshmi or an Enduku peddala.
“As an artist, people relate to you by the number of new compositions you render. Sometimes, you have to unearth songs of popular composers, so that it amounts to presenting something new – in the sense that even if others have sung it before, rasikas haven’t heard it from you.” Instances of such excavation – which Gurucharan hopes to exhibit this December – include Ramuni maravakave in the raga Pantuvarali, which he chanced upon in a Maharajapuram Santhanam recording, and Ekadantam upasmahe in Begada. And this is only about the rasikas, he insists, not reviews. Most of the rasikas come during the season, “so at that time if you present something new, it gets noticed better.”
This eloquence is, of course, all theory. In practice, Gurucharan readily admits, “It may all change once I look at my audience, once I warm up. I may not feel like going with a new song. Something familiar may work out better.” And if not the audience, the performer from the preceding timeslot may necessitate a hasty change-of-plan – the way things turned out a couple of years ago, when Gurucharan had his heart set on centering his performance on Ennalu urake, in the raga Shubhapantuvarali. “It’s a very nice Thyagaraja kriti. I learnt it. I wanted to inaugurate it during the season.”
And wouldn’t you know it, the performer just vacating the stage had singled out for main-piece elaboration a Shubhapantuvarali kriti that went… Ennalu urake! “Eventually I had to change to a ragam-tanam-pallavi in Keeravani,” says Gurucharan, brushing away with bromides the crushing disappointment he must have felt. He talks about how “improvisation makes music dearer to artists,” about how “you enjoy the challenge, because the audience is not aware of it, but you are.” But his true feelings finally bubble through the enforced restraint. “Depending on Shubhapantuvarali, I had planned the rest of the concert, so everything went haywire.”
This is no overstatement, if you take into careful account what Gurucharan means by “planning.” He explains, “Shubhapantuvarali is a prati-madhyamam raga, so if it is to be the main piece, the first half of the concert could have – for variety – a Mohanam, which does not have a madhyamam. You can’t sing a closer raga and then come to Shubhapantuvarali. The ideas may clash. But with Mohanam or a Mohanakalyani, the treatment is entirely different,” and this helps the audience as well as the artist. “The audience will get the difference between the two ragas. And you can project both ragas without beating around the bush to get the right flavour.”
So if the main piece is in a prati-madhyamam raga, Gurucharan tries to incorporate a suddha-madhyamam raga – or, as in his instance of Mohanam, a raga entirely devoid of the madhyamam – in the first half. “Based on that, there’s a varnam. The second piece may be an invocation to Vinayaka, or a medium-paced song that allows scope for swaram or neraval.” And then there could be a piece in a raga like Pantuvarali or (its suddha-madhyamam counterpart) Mayamalavagowla, for “these are ragas that have an immediate effect on the audience. They help you gain control over a concert. After that, it’s up to you to sustain the momentum.”
When it comes to the main piece, Gurucharan admits he finds it “safe and comfortable to sing a very popular raga,” but a little before or after, he may try out a new raga or experiment with a new song. This planning isn’t specific to December, but it is more conscious during the season, “because each concert lasts only two or two-and-a-half hours. You have to get warmed up and get the audience pulse within the first 20-25 minutes. Then you have to launch into a small raga alapana. And around the one-hour mark, you have to get to the main piece.”
Then comes the tail section – the variegated procession of smaller, lighter, instantly catchy pieces, which Gurucharan says, “are gaining immensely in popularity.” In a non-season concert, a typical finish would consist of a Bharathiyar song, a virutham, a bhajan, a thillana (or a Thiruppugazh), and the mangalam. “But you don’t have time for all this during the season. I usually try to include a thillana in my concerts, and it won’t look nice if you launch into a thillana straightaway after the main piece. So after the percussionists wind up their thani avarthanam, I would like to sing a virutham or a Bharathiyar song, then a thillana, and a mangalam.”
If there are other performers doing things differently, Gurucharan wouldn’t be able to find out for himself. “Personally, if I have a concert on a day, I would not like to go out. But after the concert, if there is an artist I like, I may go and listen. Listening is learning, according to me.” But Gurucharan does accept that musicians are rarely seen at the concerts of other musicians, “because of the very tight schedule, and because the concerts are all so far off, and because there’s so much traffic.” And also, he adds, because of the weather – this slightest of nips that makes Chennai dig out its mufflers and monkey caps, much to the vast amusement of the northern parts of the country.
But at least one fraternity of musicians sees December as the season when the sun shines, and that’s the army of accompanists scurrying forth from sabha to sabha, concert to concert, fulfilling appointment obligations earmarked as far back as September, when their diaries still had a semblance of scribbling space. (For that matter, Gurucharan was booked for a concert this year as early as February, though he says it’s usually mid-year that the sabhas begin drawing up schedules.) “One difference between December and the rest of the year,” says Gurucharan, “is that the sabha secretaries insist on not repeating the same accompanists.” Sometimes, they appoint accompanists on their own. “At the same time, we feel comfortable with our ‘set,’ our team – so if we insist otherwise, they agree. After all, they want the concert to be a success.”
Of course, the definition of success has changed somewhat over the years. It has taken into account the decreasing attention spans – or, perhaps, the increasing need for rasikas to have their fill of music in an à la carte fashion, sampling an appetiser from this performer here, then moving on to the main course from that performer there. Of this curious phenomenon – referred to as “concert hopping,” which brings to mind nothing so much as a Chennai filled with musically-inclined rabbits – Gurucharan says, “At whatever point they come, you should give a sense of satisfaction – not that we’re going to change what we are presenting.”
And he isn’t about to change how he presents it either. The audience profile in December runs the gamut from the let’s-see-what-the-fuss-is-about first-timer to the autumnal addict whose reason for existence owes at least as much to this music as to filter coffee – and Gurucharan doesn’t even begin thinking about what kind of rasika to cater to. “Some people think that if you sing more ghana ragas, with more alapana, swaram and neraval, then it’s a ‘serious’ concert. And if, after one hour, you sing tukkadas, they may label it a light concert. But if you have a heavy raga in a tukkada – say, in a virutham, you launch into a Yadukulakhamboji – I’d still say it’s a hard-core Carnatic concert. Popular concerts should also be there, but you should ideally have a mix of everything.”
Copyright ©2007 The New Sunday Express. This article may not be reproduced in its entirety without permission. A link to this URL, instead, would be appreciated.
Sagarika
December 11, 2007
brangan: While you are on the topic of classical music and I am in the middle of sifting thru bookmarks-from-half-a-decade-ago (thanks to a side discussion on process some poor soul inadvertently initiated a couple posts back that I’m having trouble letting go of), here’s another one for you. Its premise? Music, drama, circus, the creation of all the performing arts proceeds from researched or intuited understanding of the nature of human perception, thesis-antithesis-synthesis. Ties into what you highlight Sikkil as saying here: “You have to get warmed up and get the audience pulse…” No?
Read up!http://query.nytimes.com/gst/fullpage.html?res=9A00E5DF1639F936A25754C0A9649C8B63&sec=&spon=&pagewanted=1#
LikeLike
Vivek
December 11, 2007
I have nothing specific to comment upon in this article but here is a video I think you would appreciate
Mokshamu Galada in Saaramathi by VS. Narasimhan. He has formed the Madras String quartet arranging a solo Carnatic violin in a Western set-up. Absolutely amazing music.
VS narasimhan of course was the famous violin solo in both “How to name it” and “Nothing but wind”. Would be great if you could catch up with him, one of those truly rare forgotten gems of Indian music
LikeLiked by 1 person
brangan
December 11, 2007
Sagarika: thanks for yet another great link 🙂
Vivek: I’ve heard this. It’s from the album Resonance, which VSN arranged for the Madras String quartet. And you do know that he’s been playing for Ilayaraja for a long time, right?
LikeLike
RP
December 11, 2007
Nice article. I especially enjoyed noting how different the styles of musicians are on stage. While T.M.Krishna decides what to sing only when he’s on stage, Gurucharan carefully plans his pieces and the presentation so as to give each raga its due. Musicians are as varied in their styles as night and day.
LikeLike
Vivek
December 12, 2007
Damn, I knew you would have heard this 🙂 , just my little effort in popularizing this barely known album. Resonance is available in Landmark.
And hey “taking stock of inventory”? Do u have an MBA as well :D. You do practise the Harvard patented “thinking by analogy” a lot too.
LikeLike
brangan
December 12, 2007
RP: Actually, TM’s is the only case I’ve heard so far where a musician has said he *never* prepares. Most others have at lest an idea of what they want to present, though voice constraints, audience reactions and other factors may bring in elements of “winging it”
Vivek: Resonance is quite old. I’m sure many have heard about it. And “taking stock of his inventory” came simply from the previous part of the sentence: “showcase his wares”. It just felt like an interesting way to phrase what he does. No MBA and all, boss 🙂 What’s that Harvard patented thingee, BTW?
LikeLike
s
December 12, 2007
From your previous page comment, ” I always jot down points first, then group them …” no magic wand, ah?
LikeLike
brangan
December 12, 2007
s: Nope — no magic wand, at least with reviews, and especially these interviews, where you have to transcribe the whole damn thing from your Dictaphone first (which is easily the most boring part of a writer’s life ever). By the time you’re done with that tedium, it’s already become an unmagical process.
LikeLike
Vivek
December 12, 2007
http://harvardbusinessonline.hbsp.harvard.edu/hbsp/hbo/articles/article.jsp?articleID=9661&ml_action=get-article&print=true
Couldn’t find the actual article. But this summary works nicely. In fact the whole HBS case study methodology is an extension of the thinking through analogies concept. There have been inevitable comparisons of course on how the Panchatantra fables themselves were lessons in life/management through analogy.
LikeLike
Sagarika
December 12, 2007
brangan: Jesus Christ, I can’t believe how much — in humoring us on that (seemingly) innocent side discussion on process — you’re letting yourself be drawn out. 🙂 Wow! Yay! What else? Rest assured that such lowering of defenses (if it can be called that)is definitely received with heavy doses of empathy and gratitude. There’s enough of us here who share some of the same writerly angst (whether we write half as well or half as often as you do being suspect and all that) and even among the non-writing types, there’s a good enough number here of folks with fine-tuned palates for excellent concoctions — the kind you so regularly serve up — who too are occasionally given to wondering how does Mr.Literary Chef does it, every single time? Now would it be preposterous to presume that you’re actually having as much fun with these “side discussions” as we are? That you view such exchanges as mutually rewarding experiences vs. customary Q&A?
Oh, a nice segue here into your “..where you have to transcribe the whole damn thing from your Dictaphone first.” Reminded me of a long-forgotten work-related nightmare (are there any other kind?): the thirty odd customer case studies I wrote three years back — my first ever tryst with such transcriptions. And there wasn’t even a damn dictaphone then (maybe there was, but I was stepping in for a writer on maternity leave and was automatically handed her practically-falling-apart tape recorder whose volume, I “gleefully” realized post- customer Q&A, I could only turn up so much. Talk about the “magic” of weaving “compelling stories” from listening to customers whispering sweet nothings in your ear, courtesy a cold, clammy, crackling tape recorder “Ooo…I loved that product implementation, except for ..whoosh, crackle…” Heaven.
LikeLike
Sagarika
December 12, 2007
Vivek: Thanks for the Harvard link. It was a good read although I’m having a hard time digesting the fact that Harvard actually went on to patent something (can it even be called a concept? i would think it’s a normal part of creative thinking across disciplines/walks-of-life) as ubiquitous as “thinking by analogy” – the lengths these management magnates go thru to complexify life in a bid to oversimplify it. Nothing personal against Harvard though. HBR especially has some good writing that I skim thru every now and then.
On a lighter note, “Panchatantra fables”? Now you’ve lost our man brangan right there, didn’t you know “stories with morals drive [him] nuts”? And hey, maybe Harvard is planning to patent those as well (I remember hearing about, and balking at, how the U.S patented “basmati rice” a long time back — see I’m already prepared for such idiocies). 🙂
LikeLike
Padawan
December 12, 2007
I haven’t read this article but I assure you that I will. But will you review Evano Oruvan?
I am just quoting what you wrote in that review of Thambi – “There’s a part where Thambi is thrown into barbed wire by the bad guys, and it’s exactly like in Sathya, when the bad guys toss Kamal Haasan into barbed wire. Now that’s the kind of hero I was hoping Madhavan would want to become – not Vijayakanth.”
I believe he has played that kind of a role. I am watching it this weekend. Will come back hoping for a review…..
LikeLike
brangan
December 12, 2007
sagarika: ‘jesus christ’ is right. it’s like a dam has opened and i just can’t stop blabbing. someone stop me before i spill the rest of my secrets 🙂
padawan: I’m not going to do a review, but I thought the film was merely okay. Madhavan was sincere (and heartrendingly good in the last scene), but he was let down by a character whose “snapping” made very little sense, and I found it very hard to get a grip on his “personal” to “society at large” transformation. At the end, I was left recalling Sathya again, where Kamal snapped only at the end, and we had a whole film’s duration to be convinced that that could be a possible outcome of what was happening around him. In fact, Sangeetha’s character (she’s terrible as Maddy’s wife) is a variant on Vadivukkarasi’s disgruntled nag of a Chitti from Sathya. And the sequence where he stumbles upon the druggies is so embarrassingly done, I didn’t know where to look.
On those lines, Kalloori was a much bigger disappointment. Just about nothing worked for me. The actors may have been chosen because they “look” the parts, but the performances are all terrible, as is the writing. Can’t believe Balaji Sakthivel did this. One scene stood out though: when that little girl tells tamanna that she had to drop out of school so that her brother could continue. This kid is so natural, so accepting of life, I wished they’d built a movie around her instead.
The recent movie that rocked my world, though, was Oram Po — simply the best Tamil film I’ve seen since Chennai 28. It’s so fun, so vividly electric — and so full of loopholes that you’ll barely stop to notice, since you’re too busy enjoying yourself. And the dialgoues are bliss, pure scatalogical heaven. People around me kept complaining that it’s vulgar, but it’s just profane — the way we’d use profanity in our conversation. And John ‘Son of Gun’ Vijay is my new hero 🙂
LikeLike
brangan
December 12, 2007
brangan: Since we’re all in link-sharing mode, here’s an interview where Coppola talks about his new film (which sounds damn intriguing), and about critics: “Pity the reviewer who has to make a fast judgment call that night and come out with a review of something that took maybe three years to make. understandable.”
LikeLike
Priti
December 12, 2007
detailed review of oram po?? coming or not? and billa? can that be expected??
LikeLike
Padawan
December 12, 2007
Alright, yet another tamizh movie missed. But yes Oram Po is the best since Chennai 28! I watched it too, but was skeptical as to whether you would review it.
LikeLike
s
December 13, 2007
1/16 comments actually on the article. When is the world waking upto SGC?
When is brangan going to do a soulfish bombay jayashreeish interview with SGC?
********
“..before i spill the rest of my secrets ” – If it was the processs you employ or some secrets, we should have been able to spot atleast one more reviewer of your standard. But sadly no. The Magic comes into play in those thoughts that you jot down, in the sentences that you form um… Magician, alright!
LikeLike
Sagarika
December 13, 2007
brangan: Stop you? Well some of us have better things on our minds, like make hay while the sun shines. 🙂 OK if you hate mixing metaphors, put it another way: We’d be more inclined to knock off a couple bricks from the already open floodgate and let it all out!:-) Here’s my contribution to “let’s continue to deconstruct the deconstructionist”: Kurt Vonnegut mentioned reading a psychiatrist study that said every writer actually writes for one person. Do you? And whozzatt?
LikeLike
Bala
December 13, 2007
Btw , did you know that your blog needs a college education to comprehend ? Atleast according to this site 🙂
http://www.criticsrant.com/bb/reading_level.aspx
LikeLike
brangan
December 13, 2007
Priti: “Billa”? Isn’t that an old Rajini movie? 😉
Sagarika: “one person”? er, ahem, now who could that be? 🙂
Bala: Hey, it’s just an undergraduate level. Phew! 🙂
LikeLike
munimma
December 13, 2007
He sounds a bit like my veena teacher, about detailed planning and arranging raagas in a specific pattern. Does he do listener requests at the end? Would that bother his organized mind?
Would be interesting to read about accompanying artists. Just that segue there made me wonder.
LikeLike
Shankar
December 14, 2007
My blog http://arbitz.blogspot.com/ rated as post-grad!! That itself blows the credibility of that blog reading index!! 🙂
LikeLike
Bala
December 14, 2007
you know..you are lucky..mine got rated high school 🙂 maybe I should sprinkle my blog liberally with tamil ….
LikeLike
Balaji
December 14, 2007
3 Tamil movies and no reviews? thats a li’l disappointing 😦 But based on ur comments about ‘oram po’ and ‘evano oruvan’, it looks like my thots echo yours. btw, was that you reminiscing about watching ‘maappillai’ in alankar? 🙂
LikeLike
brangan
December 14, 2007
munimma: I think he likes to go prepared with a structure. But — as with the example of Ennalu urake here — if there is a problem, he knows how to wing it. About accompnaying artists, I did a piece on Vikku Vinayakaram and family a while ago. I’ll dig it up soon.
Shankar: Boss. Engeyo poyitteenga 🙂
Bala: Where’s your blog, BTW? You always keep it such a mystery…
Balaji: Yeah, that was me. Do you know another BR? 🙂
LikeLike
APALA
December 15, 2007
BRangan:
I always thought that the singers do (and strongly believe that they should) practice before their concert. TMK surprised me and I am not sure whether I should believe him or even if I do, I do not think he is right in doing so!
Even I thought Evano Oruvan was OK (at least decent enough to sit through) But Kalloori was a total dud. Why Balaji Sakthivel thinks that a movie has to have a “negative ending” to become a class/hit movie?? And also in order to drive to that point, the movie suddenly turned to look gloomier as soon as the second half started. Big Disspointment.
Oram Po was hilarious and pure fun! Just like you mentioned, I even read some of the reviews calling it “vulgar”! Shows our double-standard hypocrisy! (Poetic liberty!!)
LikeLike
brangan
December 17, 2007
APALA: But have you seen the reviews Kalloori has been getting in the Tamil press? Kumudham, Kungumam, AV — all of them had reservations about the end, but gave the film a big thumbs up to everything else, including tamanna’s performance 🙂
LikeLike
APALA
December 18, 2007
BRangan:
That’s what I do not understand!! These people (AV, Kumudam, Kungumam …) talk about “world cinema” (they even have them featured on their magazines regularly!), but want every movie to be nice and neat which can viewed with the “whole family”!!! (AV gave one word – you read it right – just one word review for “BOYS” and that was “chchchiiiii”!! Why can’t we have an adult comedy like “Knocked Up” or “super bad”??!! – THIS IS WHY!!!!) But the same guys are FINE (even shamelessly drool) on Hip and Pelvic shakes of the glamour girls called Heroines!! That’s not pervertion to them!
(During a party in my house my American friends saw some tamil songs – and they were all shocked asked me why the actors are “doing it” with their clothes on!!! (Get a room – they shouted!!) But we watch them without any shame and even laugh when out little ones shake their legs watching that!! But, oh no, we can’t speak vulgar – even though that’s what mostly you hear, as soon as you step out of your house in chennai!!
I never understood our social value system!!
BTW, do you read VSV in “Kumudam” and Kameshwari in “Kungumam” reviewing these december mela?!!! (Don’t you think we really miss Subbudu!!!)
LikeLike
M.S.L. Narasimhan
December 19, 2007
Charan’s planningm is excellent and he has correctly judged the preferences of the rasikas and his intention is to satisfy rasikas at any cost and at the same time happy over his performances. He may be in his twenties but his knowledge (on everym thing relating to Carnatic Music) is better than so many old generation singers. God will always bless him and every Rasika prays for his excellent future in the music world.
LikeLike