The latest Yash Raj production begins with a breakup, treads cautiously towards an engagement, witnesses that breakup, and ends with the union we were guaranteed the minute the stars were signed on. (When you have Imran Khan and Katrina Kaif in a film, and the triangle is completed by Pakistani pop star Ali Zafar, you know that Katrina Kaif is not going to end up with Pakistani pop star Ali Zafar.) There is pleasure in predictability, no doubt, the sort of feeling that envelops us as we sink into a warm bath or taste a spoonful of vanilla ice cream – but this romcom is an affront in almost every sense. Badly plotted, badly staged and badly performed, Mere Brother Ki Dulhan is almost worth watching for the smouldering train-wreck that is Kaif’s performance. This actress was never known for her acting, true, but in films like Ajab Prem Ki Ghazab Kahani, we sensed a smattering of screwball spirit. Asked to summon that same spirit here, Kaif unleashes a performance that would make Priya Rajvansh, circa Hanste Zakhm, turn green with unconcealed envy (or sickness, or both).
The standard romcom tropes are trotted out with a dull sense of duty, as if to omit such scenes would result in a court martial by a jury headed by Kate Hudson and Sarah Jessica Parker. Rarely has a romcom felt so unrommy and so uncommy, and I say this as someone who thinks 27 Dresses is a blasphemously underrated instance of the genre. The only thing worse is the constant invocation of songs from an older era – mostly by RD Burman, who’s fast becoming a lazy touchstone to announce a filmmaker’s veneration of Hindi film music – under the assumption that the sight of someone in a burqa accompanied on the soundtrack by Parde mein rehne do is automatically amusing. Not a single scene screams “love” – or “affection,” or heck, “like” in a Facebook-y sense – and we have not the slightest investment in anyone’s romantic plight. The second half is marginally better, but it does not have the blood-curdling sight of an inebriated Katrina enacting the “soocide” scene from Sholay – in other words, the wholly meta implication of a bad actress pretending to be a bad actress under the influence of alcohol. By the end, it’s the audience that needs a stiff drink.
Copyright ©2011 Baradwaj Rangan. This article may not be reproduced in its entirety without permission. A link to this URL, instead, would be appreciated.
chhote saab
September 12, 2011
“Asked to summon that same spirit here, Kaif unleashes a performance that would make Priya Rajvansh, circa Hanste Zakhm, turn green with unconcealed envy (or sickness, or both).” – that would take some doing!!! What is amazing is that nowadays these stars and directors do a lot of promotions and interviews before the release and how they can keep on harping that this was the most awesome experience of their lives, and that their co-stars gave the best performance ever, with a straight face.
LikeLike
Nimmi Rangswamy
September 12, 2011
Ouch! No saving grace, eh! That too after Band Baaja Barath!!!
I kept fooling myself that some subversive stuff was unfolding on-screen, these entire blasphemous Bhabhi- Girlfriend slip-slides, you know!!! Seems it didn’t work that way at all !!!
LikeLike
Udhav Naig
September 12, 2011
Well done.
LikeLike
sachita
September 12, 2011
you do know the film is a hit, right? – she is iterally the female super star of today’s era in terms of box office!
Though very thought of seeing her on screen puts me off so didnt want to catch this movie.
LikeLiked by 1 person
rameshram
September 12, 2011
I don’t really understand this katrina kaif hate. (I never understood the mallika sherawat hate either). is this like how people I used to know in school and stuff used to stone mating dogs…out of sheer meanness?
Katrina kaif to me looks like a beautiful statesque woman who knew what she wanted and was confident enough to go and get it. She has it now …so do your worst (feminist) bitches! (as in feminist bitchiness at katrina, and not as a misogynistic attack on gender studies) , She’s here to stay. 🙂
LikeLike
Satyam
September 13, 2011
Someone referenced this piece elsewhere and this was my response:
[LOL, there are few pleasures (if any) in contemporary film criticism whether in India or the US/UK (just the three I am familiar with) to equal Rangan’s pieces and especially so on mediocre/bad films!
What I also like about Rangan (that even some very ‘serious’ film critics in the West often lack) is the ability to be both critic and ‘fan of the movies’ at one and the same time. His writing no matter how serious is never divorced from the ordinary pleasures of watching movies. I have all the respect in the world for academic monographs on cinema but a lot of times critics in the US (for example), and much as I like their work, tend to sound too jaded if not cynical in review after review. Perhaps this is because those in the latter group are watching far too much on a weekly basis to retain any sense of ‘innocence’! And again Rangan wears his knowledge and exposure to the field very lightly in more ways than one.]
LikeLike
vikram
September 13, 2011
BR, that was wicked…esp the bits abt kate hudson, sarah jessica parker and priya rajvansh… 🙂
To all katrina fans, all I have to say is this- is it too much to expect some decent acting along with good looks?
On an unrelated note, what did you think of santosh sivan’s ‘urumi’?
LikeLike
rameshram
September 13, 2011
RIP Gautam RAjadhyaksha
LikeLike
bran1gan
September 13, 2011
Nimmi Rangswamy: That angle would have been blasphemous even ten years ago, but everything is so casual today that there’s no ickiness to this aspect of falling for your brother’s bride-to-be. It could have been a best friend instead of a brother and the film wouldn’t have been any different.
rameshram: To me, Katrina Kaif is like SRK. Whatever your opinion of their acting, they are definitely to be admired for making it so big without insider contacts. In Kaif’s case, it’s even more remarkable. She can’t speak proper Hindi. She looks foreign. Can’t act except when under a really strong director who knows how to use her. And yet, she’s probably the first heroine after Hema Malini to have such a string of hits.
vikram: No, hasn’t been released here.
LikeLike
rameshram
September 13, 2011
Branigan,
so wrong.
She does have contacts. she blew salman khan when noone else seemed to want to. She can act. (by bollywood “heroine” standards- she acts as well as….preity zinta or kareena kapoor. they dont attract so much hate). She’s just lucky, which is a desirable quality in bollywood.
LikeLike
Anu
September 14, 2011
Rangan, it seems funny, then, to have every other critic lambast Imran Khan and praise Katrina Kaif to the skies. While I admire her guts and her determination, I do not think you can compare her to SRK who really did not have *any* contacts whatsoever. (And he is a darn sight more talented than K.Kaif, even if he is bent on proving otherwise these days!) K.Kaif used Salman Khan and his contacts, and whatever else one may say about the man, one must admit that he goes the whole hog for his friends (and girlfriends).
LikeLike
Gradwolf
September 14, 2011
Will there be a report of sorts on the Conversation yesterday? Couldn’t make it due to work related stuff.
LikeLike
bran1gan
September 14, 2011
Gradwolf: No report boss. A few pics in the paper tomorrow. Maybe the reader who made it there and who I know only by his alias can say a few things 🙂
LikeLike
lowlylaureate
September 15, 2011
Sad that there is no report. Yet to watch Meri Brother ki Dulhan though.
LikeLike
Niranjan
September 15, 2011
‘Blew’?! Perhaps she did…
LikeLike
Mambazha Manidhan
September 15, 2011
LOL. At the end of this short conversation, on realizing that the event had not much to with ‘Namma Chennai’ and had turned out to be an almost-felicitation function for the Phalke Award winner, K.Balachander ‘thittified’ Brangan and made a flippant hand-raising gesture towards him that got a few laughs from the crowd. And, all I could think was “‘BR, You lucky fucker!”, fortunate enough to get a ‘thittu’ from none other the K.Balachander, automatically qualifying him for the membership of THAT club, whose other members are Kamal and Rajini. 🙂
LikeLike
Anurag
September 15, 2011
Brangan, first of ll i didnt expect that u wud go and watch this film. second, I must appreciate the amount of time u spent on writing this review cause the film doesnt even deserve this much. Its a disaster all over and no – even if katrina is ….’tolerable’ in this film to say the least (sorry fans !) , she still doesnt work for me but thats just me.
I wud like to add that the solution btw i think is pretty simple- if she cud get that accent right, it wud solve most of her problems as far as i am concerned. I seriously fail to understand why even after so many years of accent training (ie. if any i assume) why o why she still has that nut/round stone/pinball placed below her tounge if u know what i mean(ask call center employees if u dont). Everytime i see her in a film, its all gorgeous and beautiful feeling until …..she opens her mouth, spoils everything and reminds me that the hindi dialogue she is speaking was actually written by the translator in english who either failed to teach her how to pronounce the words or cud be that she cud never get it in her lifespan how to pronounce it- God I wish i cud hate her more for any reason but this. All i am saying is when Aamir can spend months in Gym developing an outstanding physique with the strong belief that its worth even for the remake of a south film (Ghajini) and is ultimately sucessful in starting a wildfire trend of 6-8 packs in bolywood in this regard, similarly when a leading lady of bollywood with ….as u said a ‘string of hits’ is getting paid for it and the luxuries of life are free for her, why cant she get the tiniest sense of responsibility to respect the language and put some effort in getting the sound of words right?? Why o Why!!
Got carried away i know but still thats me. Oh btw, the only scene which i might remember for another week or so from this film wud be when she asks the brother if the NRI is feeling music in ears when he arrives in India the way SRK (Oh May be thats why u compared Kaif with SRK Rangan is it? hmm…) felt in swades and to the shock of my life, she gets the tune of the song right “Pe Pe Pe PenSSSS”; the fact that it reminded me of Sunil Shetty in Hera pheri asking the guys while signing the bond if they can hear a song just made it slightly more funny.
Man i think i even I wrote in this context more than it deserved- i get it now- its the frustration of watching a film that is so bad that makes u write so much. Good learning there.
LikeLike
Gradwolf
September 15, 2011
MM saar, pliss to give more info about this “thittu”
LikeLike
AM
September 16, 2011
At the end of the movie, my little one wanted to know if Imran was playing Katrina’s brother. So much for their scorching chemistry.
LikeLike
Manreet Sodhi Someshwar
September 16, 2011
That bit about Priya Rajvansh I can relate to but hey, why pin the bad actress label on only Ms Kaif, when most actresses nowadays are nothing more than walkie-talkie mannequins? I am not a Kaif fan but you’ve to admit, at least she makes a fine clotheshorse!
LikeLike
MF
September 21, 2011
I felt insects crawling under my skin when Katrina, with her well coiffed hair and bubble-gum pop-star clothes, tried to act like a rock-star ..Imran Khan did nothing but raise and drop his eyebrows (face twitch?) … and Ali Zafar… who for a brief minute I thought was mimicking SRK only for the hamming to continue throughout the movie…YRF Studios is back to creating banalities after the aberration that was BBB.
PS: big fan of the blog…I normally wait for your Bollywood reviews before wasting my 300 bucks but didn’t think you would head out for this.
LikeLike
Deboshree
September 26, 2011
Super fun review!
LikeLike