Rajkumar Hirani or one of his acolytes (say, Rajesh Mapuskar, who directed the recent Ferrari ki Sawaari) would have given their eyeteeth to make Shirin Farhad Ki Toh Nikal Padi, a comedy about a couple of fortysomethings who fall in love. The Hirani touch isn’t there in just the quirkiness of the plot but also in situations that float freely between slapstick, sentiment and slightly surreal whimsy. No film, to my mind, has attempted a cross-cutting stretch of comedy as audacious as the one here, where an elderly Parsi gent is admitted to the hospital because he cannot pass gas, while, nearby, Farhad (Boman Irani) examines the contents of his girlfriend’s post-enema bowl to locate the engagement ring she accidentally swallowed. Did I mention that this Parsi gent is in love with Indira Gandhi, and writes letters to her proclaiming his undying devotion? Or that Farhad is a salesman in a women’s undergarments store, where he peddles fluorescent bras?
This sort of material, to be pulled off, needs a certain kind of director – Bela Bhansali Sehgal isn’t that director. About the only thing she can be commended for is the subject, which inflicts on a middle-aged twosome the kind of problems that befall twentysomethings in our cinema (including an overbearing parent screeching “Yeh shaadi nahin ho sakti”). Otherwise, the film is an amateur play at best, with constant cutaways to exaggerated reaction shots from the silent-movie era. The songs are worse – the low point may be when Shirin (Farah Khan) bounds about her room, chirping, “I want to touch the sunlight / I want to chase the rainbow.” (Or maybe the low point is the number where Shirin and Farhad dress up like the young couples in Kuch Kuch Hota Hai and Dilwale Dulhaniya Le Jayenge.) In the middle of this mess, it’s heartbreaking to see Boman Irani attempt an actual performance, inflecting his character with the subtlest of nuances. Someone should tell him that there’s a time to lay bare your soul and a time to grab the cheque and run for your life.
Copyright ©2012 Baradwaj Rangan. This article may not be reproduced in its entirety without permission. A link to this URL, instead, would be appreciated.
rameshram
August 25, 2012
Cosmopolis
dude what tha fuck was that?!
LikeLike
rameshram
August 25, 2012
Ok.. revisiting in the morning,
Cosmopolis : like most Cronenberg films, a verbose poetry of unadultrated hate.
LikeLike
Utkal Mohanty
August 27, 2012
“Someone should tell him that there’s a time to lay bare your soul and a time to grab the cheque and run for your life.”
Hey, you are getting really good at these epigrammatic concluding one-liners!
Must say a very eloquent, succinct review. The subject sounds interesting. Very. But I will wait for the Hirani version.
LikeLike
Alpesh Patel
August 28, 2012
did you write this? it doesn’t feel like its been written by you, you are more eloquent in your writing. This seems a little trashy, Using the phrase “Someone should tell him” is not your style, its more the style of someone who is pompous yet trashy….like someone from rediff.com
LikeLike
Anu Warrier
August 30, 2012
Aww, I liked the movie, though I agree with you about the Farah Khan song and dance number. It fits into my ‘Could have been better, though still watchable’ list.
LikeLike
Apu
August 31, 2012
I actually liked the movie. Sure it has flaws, a couple of which you mentioned, and the songs could have been absent mostly, but maybe because I watched it a week after I watched ‘Ek Tha Tiger’, this relationship between 40 plus people seemed a lot more real than the romance in the other movie. And though Farah Khan is not an actress, she fitted the role.
LikeLike
rameshram
September 1, 2012
” I watched ‘Ek Tha Tiger’, this relationship between 40 plus people seemed a lot more real than the romance in the other movie.”
Oh come on Kat is not 40! ..for a couple of years anyway!
But I think the point of shirin farhad was more that the two were OUT OF SHAPE…ok so were the other two…I dunno maybe you’re right… 😀
LikeLike
Apu
September 5, 2012
‘But I think the point of shirin farhad was more that the two were OUT OF SHAPE…ok so were the other two…I dunno maybe you’re right… ‘
Shape is a relative word…and round IS a shape!
LikeLike
rameshram
September 5, 2012
depends on what you do with the shape no? round cannot fit in a….uh square peg? can you imagine round doing this?
LikeLike
rameshram
September 5, 2012
grr time =104 secs(1 m 46 s)
LikeLike