Spoilers ahead…
I’d heard that Knight and Day was really bad, and then, long after its release, I caught it on TV and found that it was quite fun. Sidhdharth Anand’s Hindi remake, titled Bang Bang!, could be something similar. It’s way too long for this kind of movie, but at least on TV you can change channels during the boring bits. But TV won’t give you what the screen does, the billboard-sized impact of one of Hrithik Roshan’s purest performances. I don’t mean “performance” in the “acting” sense – heaven knows the actor has been trying to do a lot of that recently, huffing and puffing his way through dramas like Agneepath and Guzaarish. But that’s not his forte. He seems to suffer from the curse that afflicts the spectacularly good-looking – they spend all their energy trying to convince us that there’s more to them than just those looks. But just as we go to an Irrfan Khan movie to see the embodiment of everymen, we go to a Hrithik Roshan film wanting to be blinded by star wattage. Both types of performers are important, and in Bang Bang! Roshan does what he does best. In scene after scene he sells his brand, treating the camera like a mirror, letting bloom that self-aware smile and saying, “Hey there, handsome.” This narcissism has always been his signature quality, and it works horribly against him when he’s trying embody quadriplegics and underworld dons. But here, it goes with his character, Rajvir – he’s a dashing spy, James Bond reincarnated as a Gucci parfum model.
Unfortunately, he’s paired with Katrina Kaif. She’s supposed to be playing a ditz, but asking for sparkling comic sass from an actress who can barely emote or enunciate is asking for the moon. There’s zero chemistry between the leads, though in the interest of fairness it must be said that Tom Cruise and Cameron Diaz, in the original, didn’t exactly set the screen on fire either. Kaif plays a mousy nobody named Harleen, who works as a receptionist in a bank in Shimla. At home, she takes long showers while conversing with her grandmother, who likes to sit on the pot, in front of strategically displayed Garnier Fructis® products. One day, she decides to upend her boring life by going on a blind date. Who should turn up at the restaurant but Rajvir, who’s so smitten that he begins to dance for her amidst signboards for Johnson Tiles®. She joins him, and in that golden lighting they look like Greek gods. If they did what the film’s title suggested, Mount Olympus would be littered with the handsomest tykes ever.
Then, she discovers that he’s a thief. He’s stolen the Kohinoor. They’re on the run. You think the opportunities for product placements would rapidly diminish, but do not discount the creativity of a Bollywood filmmaker who’s after the big bucks. Rajvir and Harleen stop at a Pizza Hut® and order Mountain Dew®. They steal cars – and also talk about them, Scorpio® and Volvo® and Honda®. They are shot at by gunmen who have the worst aim ever in the history of the movies. They stop by a beautiful island. She wakes up in a bikini and walks out and sees him bronzed and shirtless, chopping wood. Later, he barbecues fish for her. Even later, he teaches her how to kiss, first swallowing her upper lip, then the lower. Somewhere, Barbara Cartland’s estate is gearing up for a lawsuit.
Knight and Day, really, is the perfect film to remake in Bollywood, and the reworking comes with solid masala echoes at the start and finish. The action is also pretty good. I particularly enjoyed a stretch in the ocean, where Rajvir and Harleen come off like cavorting dolphins. But the film needed better location photography. It needed better writing. (Some lines are really bizarre, as when the Pizza Hut® -chomping villain, played by Danny Denzongpa, accuses Indian bureaucracy of doing “corruption ke bazaar mein nagna naach”; not even nanga, but the purer form, nagna!). It needed better songs. And it needed a better director, someone with attitude and style. But the audience around me wasn’t complaining. They were devotees cheering for their gods. Or maybe they were just uncomplaining consumers, gorging themselves on Hrithik Roshan®. At this point, it’s become tough to separate performer from product.
KEY:
* Knight and Day = see here
* Agneepath = see here
* Guzaarish = see here
* Gucci parfum = see here
* Kohinoor = see here
* Barbara Cartland = see here
* “corruption ke bazaar mein nagna naach” = dancing naked in the bazaar of corruption
Copyright ©2014 Baradwaj Rangan. This article may not be reproduced in its entirety without permission. A link to this URL, instead, would be appreciated.
Rahul
October 3, 2014
Hoping for a constructive dialog between Hrithik fans and detractors on this board.
LikeLike
Vani Mohan P
October 3, 2014
‘If they did what the film’s title suggested, Mount Olympus would be littered with the handsomest tykes ever’
….the line that made my day…. 😀
LikeLike
dostoev
October 3, 2014
bharadwaj rangan, arent you just jealous of Hritik Roshan?
LikeLiked by 1 person
badri
October 3, 2014
u missed to mention Macroman !!
and was it just me, or Katrina looked like Zarine in some of the scenes; yeah, shes turning into a fat cow !!
LikeLike
DramaMama
October 3, 2014
What about Haider? I have been checking the blog every hour since yesterday!
LikeLiked by 1 person
ramitbajaj01
October 3, 2014
It’s nice to note that the puns are back. Mirror, Mirror, On the Wall..
LikeLiked by 1 person
DramaMama
October 3, 2014
“He’s a dashing spy, James Bond reincarnated as a Gucci parfum model.”
Could you be any more cheeky. Love this line. And seriously Hrithik and Katrina is a match made in acting hell. Haven’t seen the film but don’t plan to either. Wasn’t a big fan of the original and seriously don’t know how additions of few songs is going to change the equation. But really curious about Haider.
BTW, did you manage to catch Daawat-e-Ishq? Was interested to know what you thought.
LikeLike
V
October 3, 2014
Haider review?
LikeLiked by 1 person
Harshil
October 3, 2014
please write one on haider soon….im sure there will be a lot to review about on that compared to products!!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Anu Warrier
October 3, 2014
Rangan, this review is littered with the sort of lines that should come with its own statutory warnings – Do not attempt to drink tea while reading.
You owe me a keyboard!
LikeLiked by 1 person
burcidibollyreview
October 3, 2014
The most entertaining review I’ve read recently. I never saw Krrish 3 but people had the same criticism about that film, that there were too many product advertisements.
I had a strange deja vu (or lapse of brain processing as some call it) when reading this line: “corruption ke bazaar mein nagna naach”; not even nanga, but the purer form, nagna!”
So nagna means the same thing as nanga??
I hope you’ll review Haider soon, really looking forward to hear your opinion on it. I haven’t seen it yet. I’m curious about how oedipus complex in Hamlet was portrayed in the film and your reaction to this adaptation.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Shalini
October 3, 2014
“I’d heard that Knight and Day was really bad, and then, long after its release, I caught it on TV and found that it was quite fun.”
Me too! And yet, Tom Cruise himself couldn’t drag me to see “Bang Bang.”
LikeLiked by 1 person
Cinemakkaran
October 4, 2014
Why can’t we make a good slick action film if we are already willing to shell out this much money to make one. I mean what’s this action films need to be more than that and wanting have songs, get married, have family and all. From whatever little I watched of Vidyut Jamwal, Tiger Shroff etc can do action and people like Hrithik Roshan can bring star power by playing to his strength. ***spoiler*** ( 😛 ) Why the need to be more than a thief or criminal arises, why can’t he just be a thief or criminal?, what’s this need to be the army guy, secret agent or the dude with a back story ( Dhoom 3) ***end of spoiler***. Why can’t he be someone like John Abraham from Dhoom 1 (Hardly a great example, but he is just a thief and no back stories). The wait for a good slick action film continues. May be we will achieve that in Dhoom 53 when a young Aazad Rao Khan takes the bollywood by storm.
LikeLiked by 2 people
brangan
October 4, 2014
DramaMama: No. Haven’t caught up with “Khubsoorat” and “Daawat-e-Ishq.”
Shalini: Ah, a rare sighting. Thanks 🙂
LikeLike
Anuj
October 4, 2014
“And seriously Hrithik and Katrina is a match made in acting hell”
~ wonder what u have to say about Koi Mil Gaya,Lakshya and Jodhaa Akbar, films that were praised by audiences and critics alike, including his most ardent one’s like B.Rangan himself!
LikeLike
Anuj
October 4, 2014
This is the kinda role HR fans would love seeing him in a lot more often. Now if only he gets to work with better directors!
LikeLike
DramaMama
October 5, 2014
@anuj: I was referring to the Hrithik and Katrina pairing. I find Katrina to be extremely one dimensional and that pushes Hrithik to turn on his over compensator mode. That’s all. The three movies that you mentioned had different female leads. Though Lakshya is my personal favourite. Didn’t even venture near Jodhaa Akbar.
LikeLike
badri
October 5, 2014
Jodha Akbar should be one of the most bohoring yawwn inducing movies ever made in the history of mankind…and Hrithiks version of Akbar kinda added to it; he looked puzzled throughout the movie; seemed he had some of these thoughts in his mind while acting,
“someone please tell me what the hell am I doing in all these heavy costumes?” ,
“How long should I keep circling for Khwaja? when can I break into a western dance?”,
“I wonder when this fake mustache will fall off?”
“Ashutosh, you sure Akbar had six fingers in his right hand?”,
“Ok, so I am this king and I am worried only about getting Jodha to sleep with me. Thats my character, right? “
LikeLike
Anuj
October 5, 2014
I think he was superb as a young vulnerable Akbar caught between a kingdom and his own personal grieviences. I do not think any modern day actor could have portrayed Akbar’s vulnerability the way he did. Rightly, Jodha Akbar was both a critical and commercial success, something that other historic films of the decade like Asoka and Mangal Pandey failed to achieve.
LikeLike
Anuj
October 5, 2014
Off topic, ZNMD,Jodhaa Akbar,Lakshya,Guzaarish,Koi Mil Gaya & Agneepath are the highest rated films of HR on IMDB with ratings of 7+ and the first 2 trending to almost 8. The interesting thing is that barring Guzaarish and Lakshya(to an extent) the rest of them all have been commercial successes too. I think in the last decade, he’s the only actor apart from Aamir whose managed this feat of commercial success along with critical acclaim. Although the illogical masala potboilers like KNPH,Dhoom-2 and Krrish films have been his biggest hits but that’s bound to happen with any actor.
LikeLike
Abhirup
October 6, 2014
I saw this against my better judgment, and was bored out of my mind. I do agree, though, that this is the sort of all-surface-and-no-depth kind of roles that hrithik roshan is best at. Look pretty, break into a dance now and then, throw a punch or two. Beyond that, he can’t do much.
I concur entirely with badri’s description of his performance in ‘jodhaa-akbar’. He was a bore, so was the movie. With a character like Akbar, I think I have a right to expect something more than a suave dude. But I got little else.
He was fine in ‘Lakshya’, though. May well be his only fine performance.
LikeLike
Sharath
October 6, 2014
Hritik overacts a lot. He was the only one acting artificially in ZNMD. His performance in Agneepath too was over the top.
What a macho movie the first agneepath was and they ended up making the second agneepath such a feminine movie with everybody just crying n crying
LikeLike
Gargi Mehra
October 6, 2014
Looks like most of the Hrithik-bashers are frustrated males 🙂
My mini-review:
Jimmy Shergill wearing aviators in the first five minutes. That did it for me. What better way to start the movie? But after they set him on fire I was kind of hoping JS would emerge from the flames like The Terminator, but that didn’t happen unfortunately.
KK – expressionless but beautiful doll.
HR – good comic timing and not just great looks.
Verdict: Loved the original, loved the remake. Will be seeing it again. If Kick/Ready/Rowdy Rathore can make 100s of crores, why not Bang Bang?
LikeLike
Anuj
October 6, 2014
I think his portrayal of a self obsessed workoholic was perfect in ZNMD. I did not see any amount of over acting in that performance. In fact, if at all anything, he underplayed his role very well. As for Agneepath, it was a good intense performance reminiscent of Fiza and Mission Kashmir. Who says that men don’t cry? Anyways, opinions will remain opinions! I still prefer watching him in a Dhoom2/Bang Bang avatar than an Agneepath/Mission Kashmir avatar though.
LikeLike
Abhirup
October 6, 2014
“expressionless but beautiful doll”
What a succinct description of both hrithik and kaif.
LikeLike
Sharath
October 7, 2014
Anuj
Just see the last scene in ZNMD where all the three characters are being chased by the bull. Compare the expressions on Farhan and Abhay deol’s face and Hrithik. The overacting is obvious.
But i got to admit that i did like him in ZNMD. Agneepath was disappointing since the movie did not improve upon the original.
I think he was really good in Fiza and Mission kashmir but I feel that with time, Hrithik is more conscious about looking good than acting.
LikeLike
Sharath
October 7, 2014
Gargi,
Seriously, anybody who doesn’t like Hrithik is a frustrated male? You are very very funny 🙂
LikeLiked by 1 person
Mambazha Manidhan
October 7, 2014
Nailed the review with “Hrithik Roshan ®” there. I dig the closers of your articles right from the Richard Corliss/polyster mention in the Guru review if I recall correctly. I think that’s one reason your reviews are a bang apart from the others. OF course, the Mount Olympus line is hilarious.
____________
Hrithik Roshan – what a star! And presence. Btw, isn’t the purpose of doing an official Hollywood remake is to have the freedom to replicate the elements that worked exactly in the first place?
The score was atrocious. These guys have no clue how to score Hollywood action film template. The film is full of Bhai cues.
With all the ubiquitous product placement, I am surprised they missed out on having another gem. Check this. In a Post-Credits scene, Katrina Kaif asks Hrithik about his plans for the day. Hrithik presses a button on his Rubik’s Cube. And, out comes Kohinoor ®. Bang Bang!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Sharath
October 8, 2014
The product placements seem to be very obvious in Hrithik movies for some strange reason
I still remember Pass Pass being advertised in Yaadein. Bournvita and some washing powder advertised in Krish 🙂
LikeLike
Anuj
October 8, 2014
Ashutosh Gowarikar himself went on record saying how he waited for 3 years for Hrithik to sign Mohen-jo-daro. Its testimony to how highly he regards his performance in Jodhaa Akbar.
@Sharath : Yes I think he was a sort of a misfit in Agneepath but perhaps playing an emotionally weak underdog required him to emote the way he did. Indeed a stark contrast from AB’s version of VDC which I think in today’s times would be best suited for someone like an Ajay Devgan. If there is one AB role that HR would be perfectly suited for in today’s scenario, it would have to be Don, with all that style and swagger which SRK unfortunately did not perform too convincingly.
LikeLike
Sharath
October 8, 2014
I don’t think anybody should even try to emulate any of Amitabh’s performances. Having seen Don in multiple languages, I doubt if anybody can bring any newness to the story irrespective of who acts in it.
The problem i had in jodhaa akbar was hrithik’s voice. I have always imagined an emperor to have a commanding voice and i found hrithik’s voice over there too distracting. However, i do agree that the mistake lies in my assumption. Who can say for sure that every emperor had a commanding voice
LikeLike