I hate it when they build statues for great men like Gandhi. This isn’t about the man, really, or what matters about him, what he left behind, what we should imbibe from his life. This is about you, showing that you are awesome enough to have a statue built for Gandhi. This is about a photo-op for millions of tourists who’ll stand in front with a smile and a V-sign and get a lot of likes.
I’m trying to think if I’ve eaten beef. Lamb, I remember very well. It was this dish called Kofta Bel Tahini. The lamb was soft as butter. But beef? Maybe in a hamburger? After all those Archie comics, you don’t classify burgers under “cow.” You classify them under “things cool American kids do.” And at some point, I think we all wanted to drive a jalopy, have a sundae, be a cool American kid.
But no. Despite all the Enid Blytons, I’ve never been tempted to try a tongue sandwich.
The wordplay-loving part of my mind is quite delighted right now with the possibilities offered by a “tongue” sandwich. I’ll have one Hebrew to go please. On rye bread.
That part of my mind is also thinking about how we have a neighbour named Bangladesh and we’ve turned into this Ban-glad Desh.
All this news about rape. I admire the good people who go through these stories and write outraged columns about them, who take these issues up and talk about them and don’t let them die. I’m just a coward. I read a headline about a six-year-old and an iron rod and I can’t bring myself to read anymore.
How is it still possible to remain so interested in cricket despite so much of it, all the time? Somewhere in between all this, Saina Nehwal regained the No. 2 ranking. In the world. Somehow I feel we’re not making the kind of fuss we should be making. Someone should build a statue for her.
Every time I have a sore throat, I’m thinking of swine flu. All this while, apparently, there was this huge hypochondriac inside me just waiting to get out. I’m sorry, but Sonam Kapoor got it. It must really be serious.
I wonder, sometimes, about the people who read something and get all worked up and then decide they’re going to have to vent, get it off their chest, and the best way to do this is on… Twitter. 140 characters at a time.
I like to imagine people talking like this in real life, with an unseen Big Brotherly gadget monitoring their speech via satellite and cutt-
-ing them off after 140 characters.
I find it a little odd that this column is being written for a newspaper and it’s going to be read more on computer monitors and smartphone screens.
It’s not that I dislike social media. I do like Facebook when I get to see really cosmic things. Recently, I saw ultra-HD footage of the Himalayas and Mount Everest. I saw a stunning capture of a glacier melting in Greenland. The Ilulissat glacier was calving and for 75 minutes it retreated a full mile and collapsed an area of ice the size of Manhattan! I suppose some self-flagellating corner of me likes these videos because they remind me of how tiny I really am.
Metaphorically speaking, of course. Looking at me, the last word that’ll come to you is “tiny.”
In the early days of my Internet use, I used to subscribe to this group that would send me a poem a day. Now, of my own volition, I find I’m not seeking out anything that’s not prose. I miss poetry.
It’s scary sometimes, how things come back to you. I haven’t thought about that poetry group in more than a decade.
An edited version of this piece can be found here. Copyright ©2015 The Hindu. This article may not be reproduced in its entirety without permission. A link to this URL, instead, would be appreciated.
sanjana
March 16, 2015
Cricket is about 22 players while badminton is about 2 people. Only football gives competition to cricket mania. Women’s cricket does not get even 1 percent attention that male cricket gets. People watch what they want and advertisers and media exploit this hunger. Atleast Saina gets more eyeballs than women cricketers.
I read in detail only about Nirbhaya’s ordeal and I just cant go through a child’s ordeal.Nirbhaya’s got extraordinary attention which should cover all such crimes.
This Mahatma Gandhi’s statue is really a sculptor’s masterpiece and a viewer’s delight.
LikeLike
Jeeva P
March 16, 2015
Thala, night catcher in the rye paduchingala?? Mild Salinger influence.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Madhu
March 16, 2015
And then we have the “Foreigner” (with the capital F) doing a video on OUR Nirbhaya, so we counter with a video of Britain’s Nirbhayas. I am sure at this rate there would be a video on all countries. In all the mud-slinging, in all this mindless chaos, sometimes we lose perspective. We forget that the problem is the entrenched misogynistic attitude and start concentrating on preventive measures for rape, like pink ricks run by pink wearing female auto drivers. And I usually wonder how many parents shouting for Nirbhaya’s justice, teach their sons to sweep their house when they teach their daughters to cut vegetables.
And let’s not begin on sports, really!
LikeLike
Hareesh
March 16, 2015
Great article Mr.Rangan, but you did not clearly state your stance on banning beef. I do think it is true that we all want to be a bit american but what do make of all this outrage?
LikeLike
Anuja
March 16, 2015
I remember beef… Its been ages since I had any, because I was trying to eat healthy and kept opting for grilled chicken or fish instead. Ever since the hullabaloo over the beef ban though, I can think about nothing but beef… the beef roll, I had in Cochin during a school trip, the fillet mignon at this awesome steak place in Bangalore called Millers 46, chilli beef from Tic tac, Chennai and leave us not forget the noble double whopper from Burger King with a side of onion rings. Sigh…
So what were we talking about then? Yes, the news out there… Regarding the rape cases, I agree that it is commendable that there are people out there who whip up outrage and keep the issue alive, but the thing is in all honesty we can’t keep it up. Sooner or later we’ll get sick of the nauseating stuff and just stop reading about it flipping over to the section about Trisha’s wedding trousseau instead. Which is why, instead of getting angry and emotional about rape we need to calm the heck down and think of handling the problem in a proactive and rational manner. I like how Farhan Akhtar went about it with so much positivity.,, Not a bad way to get started and a hell of a lot better than frothing at the mouth and calling for the castration of all men suspected of rape.
The fuss over cricket is something I don’t get because the game has nothing to recommend it save its excellent curative properties for those suffering from insomnia. However, that being said, Dhoni is a legend simply because there are so few leaders like him. Why don’t we just make him the PM and start focusing on politics instead of Cricket?
BR, I think Saina gets plenty of attention and endorsements along with Sania Mirza. The Women’s Hockey team won the FIH World League Title but aside from a congratulatory tweet from Modi, they can expect little attention with cricket fever and all… Now that is unfair!
LikeLike
Durga Dalai
March 16, 2015
The art of our time is noisy with appeals for silence.
A coquettish, even cheerful nihilism. One recognizes the imperative of silence, but goes on speaking anyway. Discovering that one has nothing to say, one seeks a way to say that.
~ Susan Sontag
LikeLike
Bayta
March 17, 2015
The Wondering Minstrels?
LikeLike
sanjana
March 17, 2015
What is your take on Arnab’s hysterical outbursts? He is crying wolf too many times and when there is a real wolf, no one will take him seriously.
LikeLike
Ashutosh
March 17, 2015
@sanjana: I know you only asked for Rangan’s opinion but when I saw your comment, I had to respond. Arnab won’t cry wolf and alert anyone, nor does he want to. At the risk of offering an Ayn Rand reference, he’s pretty much like Gail Wynand and his Banner. He is supposed to be our mobvoice… not some voice looking out for us. Our fears are his fears and our ignorance is his ignorance; so there is never a question of not taking him seriously.
LikeLiked by 4 people
brangan
March 17, 2015
Hareesh: This is not the kind of piece about stating one’s “stance” on things. About the feel of the piece, I think Durga Dalai’s comment/quote captured at least some of it.
That said, I am completely against censorship, bans etc.
Bayta: Absolutely. Miss them 😦
sanjana: Ashutosh’s comments exactly. There’s no question of not taking him seriously. He has become a very important part of the cultural climate, like him or not.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Rahini David
March 17, 2015
Ashutosh: No idea who Arnab is. But I love what you said.
Plenty of Banning is going around, eh? Another post I read about it.
http://seemagoswami.blogspot.fr/2015/03/the-big-ban-theory.html
LikeLike
sanjana
March 17, 2015
But I dont take him seriously and so I stopped watching him too. The way he shouts down others is a big putoff for me. He comes out as a big bully with a lynch mob mindset. Best example of trial by media. Or trial by Arnab.
Thank god for that remote.
I wish somebody ban Arnab from electronic media. Back to some real news.
LikeLike
hari
March 17, 2015
Rahini you don’t know who Arnab is, that is fantastic, good going.
Just FYI, he is the guy who interviewed Rahul G.
LikeLike
Rajeev Hari Kumar
March 17, 2015
“How is it still possible to remain so interested in cricket despite so much of it, all the time?”
Because it’s World Cup season! 😛 But this WC is interesting largely because of the performance of the associate nations, and the problems those performances present for the powers that be. I do, however, understand the fatigue one experiences wrt the amount of cricket being played. Way too many meaningless contests whose sole purpose is to keep the money flowing into coffers that are already full.
LikeLike
Ashutosh
March 17, 2015
@Rahini: You don’t know Arnab? But how? But what do you do when you want to be intellectual and care about society late at night after dinner before falling asleep? Read Wittgenstein? (Well, anyway with Arnab nothing passes over in silence.)
LikeLike
Iswarya
March 17, 2015
@Rahini:
I hope you were really serious when you said you didn’t know Arnab!! (Hyperbolic, am I?) Anyway, this is a good chance to read this article:
https://wearethebest.wordpress.com/2013/11/19/an-editor-explains-arnab-goswami-to-an-nri/
Hope you are enlightened by this! 🙂 😀
LikeLike
Krishna
March 17, 2015
Take the worst of American TV news and (somehow) make it even worse and you have your daily fix of Arnab’s Khap Panchayat hour.
In short, he has the humility of Bill O’Reilly and the patience of Sean Hannity.
LikeLike
vijay
March 17, 2015
I think sanjana’s point is that Arnab’s artificially loud style along with his sensationalist issue coverage might have desensitized some viewers already. I am not sure how many of you here have read that Caravan cover story on Arnab. It unveils him as some sort of a jerk who trampled on quite a few feet to get to where he is today.Not surprising.
What is really depressing to me is that this is supposedly the best India has to offer as far as prime time media/news coverage is concerned.Really?
LikeLike
bumblebee
March 18, 2015
why should it be depressing and who said he’s the best? Genuinely curious – is it now a widely accepted fact that this Arnab guy is indeed the best? From what I read and hear he has that remarkable TRP increasing charm of being someone everyone ‘loves to hate’ ?
LikeLike
Rahini David
March 18, 2015
People:
I was completely serious. Well, not everyone watches Inglees TV you know? I googled his name and some stuff (to put it mildly) came up. But I replied to Ashutosh’s comment even before that.
There is some similar Tamil program that goes on in some similar Tamil channel. I don’t know what they talk about but whenever I try to listen somebody is saying “I let you speak, now you let me speak” or variations thereof.
Again I am no expert on the subject, but isn’t a self-important insufferable smug demeanour a requirement for that guy’s job profile anyway? I thought all of them were like that.
BR:
Well it is a nice statue. All statues and architectural marvels are always about humans showing off to other humans, right? In which way is this different?
Beef tastes good. Bacon does too.
Shall we bring the wordplay-loving part of your mind to the front again, please? I mean, I love going though the archives and see the puns on the title of each article. Sigh.
My thoughts on people who write about rape is long and complicated. I will do it some other day.
How is it possible to be interested in Cricket? Well, you watch about 10 movies in a week and you seriously ask this?
Watching cricket and watching Mega-serials are not very different. You don’t have to necessailty start at the beginning and go till the end like in other forms of entertainment.
LikeLike
MANK
March 18, 2015
I wonder why the same panelists keep on returning to Arnab’s show repeatedly even after being bullied,shouted down, ignored, humiliated etc etc…? his newshour seems to be a version of reality TV or Live theater – where the actors return again and again to reprise the same roles.
LikeLike
Prasad
March 18, 2015
Sadly the ORDER of the day is ONLY Sensationalism sells! Probably People go and watch to see how other’s get bashed. And it has gone to such an extent that even Rahul G and PM gave Airtime ONLY to him…(referring the interviews).
In Retrospective , this is not only in Media this is true in Cricket, Politics, Movies.
Just to quote an example, the Sensationalism and HYPE (and of course Corruption) of IPL killed the Spirit of Game.
LikeLike
hari
March 18, 2015
Rahini by comparing mega-serials with cricket you have got some brownie points from my wife. Kudos 🙂
LikeLiked by 1 person
Ashutosh
March 18, 2015
@Rahini: I totally second BR bringing back the puns!!!
@MANK: stockholm syndrome.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Iswarya
March 18, 2015
@Rahini/Ashutosh: Good to know the kindred soul pangs about the missing puns, especially because they were lip smackingly good! If I could give your comment multiple up-votes, I’ll do that.
LikeLike
MANK
March 18, 2015
Ashutosh, Stockholm syndrome, man i was ROFLing on that. 🙂
And loved your Gail Wynand analogy, wonder who probably would qualify as his Howard Roark?, The uncompromising Anna Hazare, His disciple Kejriwal or (help!) Rahul G-In his own way, he did try to present his case you know. 🙂
LikeLike
Krishna
March 18, 2015
MANK and Ashutosh:
Nope. They keep returning to get humiliated because they are paid:
http://www.newslaundry.com/2015/03/09/the-making-of-the-great-indian-news-panel/
LikeLiked by 1 person
Ashutosh
March 18, 2015
@Iswarya: It’s sad… I was really dreaming of the day I would go on torrent and download for my grandson a booklet containing all the puns. I even created a book cover for it 😦 http://postimg.org/image/en9m8pgil/
@MANK: No Roark… It’s Gail Wynands all the way down 🙂
LikeLiked by 2 people
Ram Murali
March 18, 2015
Ashutosh…thalaivarey…kalakiteenge! Unge post padikarthuku aana I always need urban + rural dictionary!
LikeLiked by 1 person
MANK
March 18, 2015
Krishnan, thats very very interesting. Shobha dey- the founder editor of Stardust- i can understand her demanding her pay, But Suhel Seth – I thought he was a social servant :). and no mention of Arnab’s chief punching bag- Sanjay Jha’s payday , Jha would be a millionaire by now..But the article got one thing right-Arnab definitely runs a popcorn show. He is the Rohit shetty of Television
Ashutosh, Great cover dude. :). But why Kant and feyman ?Are indian philosophers too narrow to understand Brangan.
LikeLike
Rahul
March 18, 2015
Arnab Goswami’s strategy is to think of a theme for his theater of outrage and chest beat around it. It is disingenuous to conflate it with vox populi. He is to broadcast journalism what Ekta Kapoor is to soap operas – feeding on our visceral instincts. Its like dangling a toy in front of a child and then say nation wants to know why this child is crying.
That said, he is a terrific businessman , just like Ekta Kapoor – and he can be credited with changing the face of TV journalism. I also think he is an equal opportunity outragist and bully – he is pretty agnostic when it comes to ideology or political affiliation.
LikeLike
Rahul
March 18, 2015
As an example, his outrage against the movie Indias daughter was nincompoopery of the highest order. This is not to say that some or many of us do not have objections to that movie, but there was no effort to frame a cogent argument against it, just chest beating .
LikeLike
Lakshmi
March 19, 2015
Here you go – http://wonderingminstrels.blogspot.com/.
LikeLiked by 1 person
brangan
March 19, 2015
Lakshmi: Oh yeah, but they’re not still active, are they?
Ashutosh: Well, about that cover, I guess there’s nothing you Kant do, eh? 🙂
Thank you. I’m over the moon.
Reminds me of the old MGR song: “Oru pun-ai paarthu nilavai paarthen…” 🙂
LikeLiked by 1 person
brangan
March 19, 2015
BTW, did readers get this particular line?
I like to imagine people talking like this in real life, with an unseen Big Brotherly gadget monitoring your speech via satellite and cutting you off after 140 charact-
-ers.
LikeLike
cl
March 19, 2015
BTW, did readers get this particular line?
140 characters count ends at ‘t’ 🙂
LikeLiked by 2 people
brangan
March 19, 2015
cl: thanks. a lot of people thought it was a typo, like I’d accidentally pressed the ENTER key or something and I was wondering.
LikeLike
Ashutosh
March 19, 2015
@brangan: ROFL. epic 🙂
I got the Twitter thingy too… but I had second thoughts because it was cut off at 168 chars, not 140… 27 chars extra.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Ashutosh
March 19, 2015
@MANK: I wouldn’t dare to mock august and sacred Indian philosophers in the current climate. Though, you do have a point: misattribution and making up quotes of ancient Indian philosophers is quite the in-thing now.
LikeLike
brangan
March 19, 2015
Ashutosh: Oh shit. My bad. It is 168 – with spaces. In my haste I must have looked at the count without spaces, which is 140.
I’m going to change it now. Thanks.
LikeLike
Ashutosh
March 19, 2015
@brangan: As for people who thought it was a typo, they’re evidence that humans have finally become as smart as algorithms… theologically speaking, they’re reincarnations of discarded copies of MS word.
LikeLike
sanjana
March 19, 2015
As for beef ban, anything which reduces cruelty towards animals is welcome. As a vegan, I am fine with the ban. Now dont start telling me that tomatoes cry and brinjals weep! Then I will counter it by supporting cannibalism!
If I had been a n v, I would have been singing a different tune.
LikeLike
Iswarya V
March 19, 2015
@Ashutosh: BR-a ippadi total-a cover panneettengale! And yeah, it was seriously hilarious, especially the Schrodinger bit. 🙂
@BR: Resorting now to visual puns and cutt-
-ing off words, are we? What next, e e cummings eh? 😀
LikeLike
Iswarya V
March 19, 2015
@Lakshmi:
Thanks for the link. I knew the site hadn’t been active for a long time and went there just for nostalgia’s sake. But then I stumbled on this gem in the comments section:
department of education says. . .
So informative things are provided here, I real prosperous to read this communicating, I was vindicatory ideate roughly it and you provided me the straight info I really bookmark it, for encourage city, So thanks for sharing the entropy.
🙂
LikeLike
M.R. Sharan (@sharanidli)
March 19, 2015
Rummaging through old newspapers – for a modern Indian historian – on the last 200 days of Gandhi, I found a report of a speech by the Mayor of Bombay from September 1947. As he unveiled a Gandhi statue, the Mayor revealed that Gandhiji had written to him asking for the money (collected from the people specifically for this purpose) to be spent on public toilets instead. The Mayor felt that while the Mahatma was a wise man, in this particular instance he was wrong – the people themselves would appreciate a towering statue over a few toilets. As a representative of the people, it was incumbent on him to bow down to their wishes.
I do not know if the statue still remains – but toilets continue to be problematic. For all his flaws, the Mahatma was a remarkably prescient man and often got things more right than wrong.
LikeLike
vijay
March 19, 2015
20K for a Shobha De sighting? Desperate assholes.
LikeLike
vijay
March 20, 2015
I sometimes wish we had a George Carlin-like stud to rip these media a-holes a newer one. Now that would be worth 20K a minute
LikeLike
Madan
March 22, 2015
I tend to agree with Sanjana on the subject of Orknob. I am not, ahem, much of an intellectual, more like a working professional who seeks to be informed rather than entertained (or is the real purpose to be rendered deaf?) by the news. Arnab doesn’t fulfil that purpose for me. I would much rather watch Boom Bust on Russia Today; at least it provokes thought even if some of their editors seem to live in libertarian utopia. That way, there are also about a zillion programmes devoted to astrology and superstition on the Hindi news channels. Why should I keep up with them? As I said, I am not a philosopher, just a middle class dude baffled but amused by the resurgence of andh wishwash in India. You may accuse me of living in a bubble for not taking those things seriously that India seems to and I shall happily plead guilty to that.
LikeLike
Rahul
March 26, 2015
An example of how professional outragiya Arnab operates:
http://www.opindia.com/2015/03/times-now-creates-stupid-hastag-shamedinsydney-social-media-slaps-it-by-trending-shameontimesnow/
This time he was outdone by professional counter outragiyes.
LikeLike
sanjana
March 27, 2015
There was media trial about the IAS officer’s death recently. Now the skeletons have started tumbling down, media is living in denial.The media portrayed the said officer as demi god who could do no wrong.
De screamed that its murder. Now she is keeping quiet.
LikeLike
madhunaga
April 10, 2015
Huge fan of minstrels mailing group. Sigh. Shed many a tear, then decided to do something similar. Also defunct now, but this makes me very nostalgic. As soon as you said poetry mailing list, knew it had to be The Wondering Minstrels. Was such a joy, no? I still come across people who love poetry who happen to have been on that mailing list.
LikeLike
Dhapa
October 29, 2015
Relevant blog for present times. Glad to have read it.
If you have beef with the beefbans, which award are you planning to return (desperately trying wordplay here.. be patient with me)
LikeLike