Spoilers ahead…
Sanjay Gupta’s Jazbaa is the mature actor’s answer to those star-son launch pads that tell us this boy can dance and ride a horse and isn’t allergic to glycerine. This is about Aishwarya Rai Bachchan announcing she’s back. She’s first seen in a track suit, stretching and running and generally posing against the Mumbai skyline. The message is clear. The post-baby fat that she was cruelly criticised for – it’s all gone. She’s saying: Show me another 41-year-old who looks like THIS! She’s saying she’s worth it. It’s an interesting time we are in. Actresses who are no longer young enough to play arm candy to older heroes are still figuring in leading roles. I’m also thinking of Rani Mukerji and Mardaani. In the 1980s, they may have ended up playing demure wives and doting bhabhis, but those roles no longer exist and these heroines are saying they can be the hero. For a while, Aishwarya’s character – a top lawyer named Anuradha Verma – seems really interesting. She knows that there’s no money in defending the innocent. “Jo beqasoor hain, woh mera fees afford nahin kar sakte.” That’s an amazingly matter-of-fact admission from a leading lady, and Jazbaa is about how this philosophy comes to bite her in the behind. When her daughter (Sara Arjun, last seen in the lovely Tamil film Saivam) is kidnapped, she’s forced to defend a man whose guilt is in little doubt. Not only is he a murderer, he’s a rapist too – he’s every mother’s nightmare, and Anuradha Verma, if she wants her daughter back, has to somehow overlook the fact that she has to free someone who robbed another mother of her daughter.
Jazbaa is based on a South Korean thriller named Seven Days, and I wonder if this subtext was worked in more convincingly in that film – because after this set-up, after hinting at Anuradha’s complicity in a legal system that has come to favour those with money and power, Gupta backs off. I suppose you cannot have a star vehicle that screams, You deserve this, bitch! But in that case, why bother? Why not simply enshrine Anuradha Verma as the epitome of motherhood, as the rest of the film does? In court, we are pointedly shown that Anuradha wears high heels, but look at her replace them with sneakers as she takes part in a sports meet at her daughter’s school. She’s the modern Mother India, which may be why Gupta opens his film with a shot of the tricolour. (Too bad he isn’t as reverent towards other mothers, like the now-ubiquitous gau mata – a character is shown tucking unapologetically into a steak dinner.)
Aishwarya is the perfect actress for a Jodhaa Akbar, where her face does the talking. Here, she’s asked to resort to her voice, and that’s a mistake. She cannot do inflections. Every line seems to have been read off a teleprompter. She’s cold, distant. As if recognising this, Gupta gives her an overblown scene where she catches a glimpse of her daughter in the kidnapper’s car – she runs behind it and screams and falls and pounds the earth and causes sand to rise in little slow-motion clouds. In comparison, Shabana Azmi, who plays the mother of the murdered girl, needs just one look lasting about two seconds to clue us in to her anguish. Having someone like Shabana Azmi share frames with Aishwarya is a little like stumbling into someone’s bookshelf where a Chetan Bhagat rests against a David Foster Wallace – but the film would be unwatchable otherwise. At least this way, we get glimpses of lived-in characters. Jackie Shroff has reached a stage where his mere profile, in a close-up, suggests something. He speaks in a growl that’s pitched a couple of notches below his usual speaking voice, and we instantly know what kind of scum this politician is. And Chandan Roy Sanyal has great fun as the accused, playing the character as nonsensically as the material deserves demands. This isn’t simple hamming. Orwell could have made a farm out of it.
The first half lurches unconvincingly from scene to scene, but slowly, the film settles into a zone that’s as lurid as the neon-green light Gupta drenches his frames in. I especially enjoyed the last half hour – it’s sleazy pulp heaven. After a generally bleak view of courtrooms in films like Court and Talvar, it’s fun to see the place crackling with Perry Mason energy. I wish the film had had more of Irrfan Khan though. He plays Anuradha’s friend Yohan, but on the side, he seems to be auditioning for the lead role in a Salim-Javed script. There were hints of the masala hero inside him in Haider, where he made a smashing entrance. Then Talvar saw him as a starry investigator. Here, he turns full-blown star. He gets superb Kamlesh Pandey lines to chew on, and he spits them out with unbelievable flair. Main khud langar ki line mein khada hoon, tere liye daawat kahaan se laaoonga? Here’s another: Neend mashooqa ki tarah hoti hai. Waqt na do to rooth ke chali jaati hai. At one point, the film morphs into a music video. We just see Irrfan drinking, putting a face to these amazing lyrics: Jaane tere shehar ka kya iraada hai / Aasmaan kum, parindey zyada hain. The world-weariness he channels here, the casual way he tosses off those florid declamations (perfectly walking the prose-poetry tightrope) made me think of Amitabh Bachchan, who was an equally unconventional-looking (and tall) leading man. None of today’s heroes can pull these lines off, and you don’t have to recall Imran Khan in the ill-fated Once Upon Ay Time In Mumbai Dobaara! to underline the point. How strange that the strongest links to our older commercial cinema seem to lie in the “art film” actors of today. I kept imagining Irrfan Khan’s hero here pitted against Nawazuddin Siddiqui’s gloriously entertaining villain in Kick. It would be the masala blockbuster of 1975.
KEY:
- jazbaa = emotion/passion
- Mardaani = see here
- bhabhi = see here
- Jo beqasoor hain, woh mera fees afford nahin kar sakte = the innocent can’t afford my fees
- Saivam = see here
- Seven Days = see here
- gau mata = er, Mother Cow
- Jodhaa Akbar = see here
- Court = see here
- Talvar = see here
- Haider = see here
- Main khud langar ki line mein khada hoon, tere liye daawat kahaan se laaoonga? =
- Neend mashooqa ki tarah hoti hai. Waqt na do to rooth ke chali jaati hai =
- Jaane tere shehar ka kya iraada hai / Aasmaan kum, parindey zyada hain =
- Once Upon Ay Time In Mumbai Dobaara! = see here
- Kick = see here
Copyright ©2015 Baradwaj Rangan. This article may not be reproduced in its entirety without permission. A link to this URL, instead, would be appreciated.
Madan
October 11, 2015
Having someone like Shabana Azmi share frames with Aishwarya is a little like stumbling into someone’s bookshelf where a Chetan Bhagat rests against a David Foster Wallace – but the film would be unwatchable otherwise.
Your description of Irfan’s acting makes it very tempting to watch. If I wasn’t so allergic to Ash in what seems like yet another of her shriek-athons, I may have. Or if the film was at least good, in spite of her.
LikeLiked by 1 person
B-Grader
October 11, 2015
“like the now-ubiquitous gau mata – a character is shown tucking unapologetically into a steak dinner”
Idhekku naduvula kusumbu? 😀
LikeLike
awkshwayrd
October 11, 2015
“It’s an interesting time we are in. Actresses who are no longer young enough to play arm candy to older heroes are still figuring in leading roles.”
Off topic, but it’s practically a golden age for Hindi cinema in terms of the stuff actresses are doing. There have never been so many ‘grown up’ actresses headlining movies and not just playing ‘heroines’. Even the notable ones in the younger lot are actually doing interesting stuff, rather than just play arm candy.
The guys by contrast are all still trying to play ‘hero’ (and failing abysmally at it), rather than growing up.
We have our Meryl Streeps (or the BR approved alternative), now where are our George Clooneys and Matt Damons? Why do all Bollywood actors aspire to Channing Tatum-hood?
LikeLiked by 3 people
Madan
October 11, 2015
The guys by contrast are all still trying to play ‘hero’ (and failing abysmally at it), rather than growing up.
LikeLike
Vanya
October 11, 2015
Liked the write-up, but couldn’t understand what you meant here: “This isn’t simple hamming. Orwell could have made a farm out of it.”
Totally agree with awkshwayrd, these are very interesting times in terms of the acting prowess of the younger generation of actresses and, thankfully, the meaty roles that are accessible to them. Most of the current lot have proven themselves in at least one notable role. (Yes, the irony of discussing acting prowess below a review of an Aishwarya Rai flick has not escaped me.) What warmed my heart was that even as Katti batti was being slaughtered in reviews across the board, critic after critic wondered why Kangna hadn’t been given more to do — clearly SHE was expected to be the “hero” in it.
LikeLike
tonks
October 11, 2015
vanya: Pun on ‘ham’, Animal farm?
(I think) 😀
LikeLiked by 1 person
Kavita
October 11, 2015
My comment disappeared. Here it is again. Raja Sen’s take on Irrfan:
“Jazbaa is a mercifully brief movie, just about two hours long, but that’s about it in terms of the good part, warns Raja Sen.
In many ways, Jazbaa is the Irrfan Khan acid test.
Not that Irrfan needs to be tested, of course.
He is a superlative actor in the middle of an incredible run of form, and as we have seen from his sensational recent outings, he seems to just get better and better and better.
However, those are wonderfully written parts in films helmed by fine directors, but does Irrfan have the bulletproof screen-presence required for blockbuster buffoonery?
Can he commit to a moronic script?
Does he have, I dare ask, the Khanhood?
Sanjay Gupta’s Jazbaa says no. (And for that we should all heave a sigh of relief.) “
LikeLike
Utkal
October 11, 2015
Seeing this just one week after the masterly ‘Talvar’ this could have been underwhelming. But I was totally engrossed and thoroughly enjoyed this thriller with a twist in the end. It was a good story and it was fairly well told. The tension point is brought in early on and the narrative hurtles to the climax at a good speed, with no distractions. It is pretty lean narrative with almost no flab. Thanks to competent performances by Shabana, Irrfan and Aishwarya, the human side of these three main characters also shine through.
The writing is pretty good and I quite liked the rhetorical flourishes of Kamalesh Pandey. ‘Rishteay pe bhoriash aur mobile pe network na ho to log game khelne lag jaatay hain. Tum kauns agane khel rahi ho?’ Irrfan asks Aishwarya. People have said Ash shrieks too much. For god sake people when traumatized do shriek. And Hollwood-style understatement is not the only school of acting that evry actor has to come from. The bottom-line : Ash’s performance touches you and her emoting seems pretty real. She looks exquisitely beautiful, as frail and as perfect as porcelain, but she also brings a certain gravitas to her persona which makes the proceedings quite believable. After Piku and Talvar, this is the third film that Irrfan breathes life into with his breezy, stylish performance. And Shaban Azmi is an inspired piece of casting that takes the film a notch or two higher.
Sanjay Gupta’s direction stays on course throughout, keeping the film practically song-less. The very brief sinppets of two songs used are evocative and effective mood-enhancers. Gupta has the flair for the thriller narrative, though he does simplify things for our audiences used to spoon-feeding, sacrificing subtlety and depth for clarity. But there is enough intrigue still in the narrative to keep you hooked from beginning to end. And I like the calibrated happy ending and the parting line, ‘Mohabbat hai iss liiye jaane diya, zid hota to baahon mein hoti’.
After ‘Dum Laga Ke Haisa’, ‘NH 10’, ‘Piku’, ‘Tanu Weds Manu 2’, this is the fifth film this year with a woman at the centre of the narrative that’s doing well. And there Talvar directed by a woman, More power to the talented ladies of Bollywood, I say!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Utkal
October 11, 2015
BR: I loved your passage on Irrfan Khan… just as I loved his starry turn in the film.
LikeLike
South In North
October 11, 2015
Nothing in this movie worked for me, not the tinted frames, not ARB, not even Shabana Azmi. I thought the plot too contrived, to start with and ARB really does nothing to hold interest. And seeing that she is in the frame most of the time, it really was a bad one overall for me.
A friend on the other hand had an entirely different reading. She liked that the movie showcased strong women, those with careers and able to make choices. She was willing to suspend all plot loopholes for this reason alone.
Anybody else thought this movie was pro-feminism in anyway? (It also reminds of the discussion on Cocktail. Although that was a better film, IMO).
LikeLiked by 1 person
olemisstarana
October 12, 2015
Hah, BR this entire column is the very definition of qualified but enthusiastic praise. It’s a very elusive note, but you play it pitch perfect. Notwithstanding the movie, this is why I come back to read your reviews (that and the batshit, but awesome debates in the comments.)
LikeLiked by 1 person
A
October 12, 2015
Liked reading this. Times have changed so much in terms of what is happening in Hindi cinema today, Irrfan Khan, however much a starry turn he has given in Jazba simply cannot be compared to Amitabh Bachchan. I am surprising myself writing this, seeming like AB Snr’s fan but am no fan. It is just, heroes of those times simply towered over the audiences, offscreen. Their presence was sort of mythical. I’m not talking about just Amitabh, but even some other stars like Rajesh Khanna and Dharmendra shone, even if it were for a much lesser period. Amitabh till today is that looming figure, will always be.
The Sunday ritual at his place in Bombay, when he greets people, standing on those steps, evokes this. He is up there, some luminous figure, out of reach, a sea of hands reaching out to him, but grasping only his giant presence.
This is not about Irrfan’s inadequacy as an actor or star. Infact, in a certain sense it is because the ‘absurdity’ that a masala film demands from its star, an actor like Irrfan [as you put it, an art film actor] will not be able to own it. Amitabh does it and makes to be the best ever.
LikeLike
Sreedhar
October 12, 2015
“Jo beqasoor hain, woh mera fees afford nahin kar sakte.”
That is just a straight out rip-off from The Judge
LikeLike
Shreyasi Ghosh (@gshreyasi)
October 12, 2015
I found the movie rather unwatchable. Aishwarya Rai Bachchan got an extremely meaty role but couldn’t do any justice to it. I always find her ‘acting’ and Jazbaa was no different either. The logical loopholes in the plot aside, even Irrfan couldn’t save the movie for me. That scene where he learns about Shanaya’s abduction, takes off his jacket in frustration & throws it is downright comical. The plot is quite dark actually; we were supposed to feel it and despair, like we did in Talvar or Ugly or even No One Killed Jessica (at least in my case). The film failed to translate that on screen; even the dark tinted Mumbai skyline didn’t quite make me feel the ubiquitous gloom.
LikeLike
Vanya
October 12, 2015
@tonks: Thanks; I was overthinking it.
LikeLiked by 1 person
JPhil
October 12, 2015
Saw it. Watching Aishwarya act is the exact reverse of eating a gooseberry. Period.
LikeLike
ntnnew
October 15, 2015
Having someone like Shabana Azmi share frames with Aishwarya is a little like stumbling into someone’s bookshelf where a Chetan Bhagat rests against a David Foster Wallace – but the film would be unwatchable otherwise
Woww!! Was it aimed at chetan bhagat or at aishwarya rai!! Either way works 🙂 awesome 🙂
LikeLike
Rahul
October 16, 2015
BR, you been going easy on the puns lately. Here is one to put you in the mood –
What do you call a gujarati grandmother who likes Louis Armstrong?
Jazzba!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Shah Shahid
January 31, 2016
Wow. You’ve articulated ever so eloquently everything I butchered in my own Review of the film. Also validates my own opinions to see I’m not the only one who thought so.
I loved Irrfan in the movie, and definitely felt like he was playing a different role in a different movie altogether. My theory also is that Irrfan Khan essentially plays Sanjay Gupta’s proxy in the film, as he spouts pop culture references and is uber cool through out; a Gupta staple really.
I actually go over almost all of the same things you mention in a recent episode of my Podcast, comparing the film to its source material, Seven Days. Give it a listen if you’re into that kind of thing.
http://www.blankpagebeatdown.com/split-screen-podcast-episode-10-aishwarya-rai-bachchan-remakes-south-korean-thriller/
LikeLike