Spoilers ahead…
When you ask young actors why they keep making the same kind of movie, they’ll say they want to establish themselves first, with these “safe films” – but here’s the rub. Once you’ve established yourself, once you’ve become the brand ambassador for a certain kind of movie, once you know this is what people like to see you in, then the fear of failure will never let you do anything else. Case in point: the new Sivakarthikeyan starrer, Rajini Murugan, which plays like a party game titled Where Have I Seen This Scene Earlier?. Take the playing-to-the-gallery moment that disses IT folks. The Madurai-based Rajini Murugan (Sivakarthikeyan) mocks them as losers sitting in air-conditioned cabins, whiling away time with Facebook and Twitter. You can understand this contempt if it came from a son of the soil – a farmer, say. But what does Rajini Murugan do? He steals cash from a friend’s father. He sets up a tea stall opposite the house of a girl (Keerthy Suresh) who hates him – because, in Tamil cinema, when she says no, she’s really saying yes, yes, yes, oh baby, yes. This is how you know Sivakarthikeyan is some kind of star. Imagine how you’d have reacted to this character had he been played by, say, SJ Suryah.
Director Ponram banks entirely on his leading man’s likeability. The “story-screenplay-dialogue-direction” credit could have just read “star-star-star-star.” There’s just one standout sequence – the opening credits over images of Madurai rendered with a beautiful pop-up effect. Everything else is so lazily done, the film’s tagline could read: Hey, they’re going to buy tickets anyway. The bit about a white woman falling for a local is just one random scene. And even that one random scene is content to leave it as a sight gag. It ends when we set eyes on the man. Why not develop this as a comedy track? Why not completely remove the toothless conflict (courtesy, the villain played by Samuthirakani, who sets the plot in motion by demanding a share of Rajini Murugan’s ancestral property)? He is one of the least effective villains in memory, because Ponram is afraid to let things get too serious. Why, then, are we subjected to two panchayat scenes, neither of which have any kind of sizzle? And if you’re not going for drama, why not toss a banana peel into the proceedings?
Or maybe they know that the joke is really on us. The people who matter, the ones who make hits of these films, they’re just there for the scene where Sivakarthikeyan lifts his collar as he rides a bike. And they’re there to see yet another aspirant make his bid for Rajinikanth’s throne, which explains not only the first half of the title but also the numerous references to the Superstar’s films. I’m not just talking about the Endhiran banner or the Rajadhi Raja song. I’m talking about two roadside cops, who appear in just one scene, bearing the names Muthuvel and Alex Pandian. The best character in Rajini Murugan is the heroine’s father, a self-styled Rajini fanatic who even tosses his head the way his idol does. Instead of giving his daughter advice, he plays scenes from Annamalai and Padayappa. Why didn’t they make the whole movie a pastiche of much-loved Rajinikanth scenes? If you’re going to take the easy way out, what could be easier?
KEY:
- Rajadhi Raja song = see here
Copyright ©2016 Baradwaj Rangan. This article may not be reproduced in its entirety without permission. A link to this URL, instead, would be appreciated.
lowlylaureate
January 18, 2016
Hello saar, please to see
LikeLike
venkatesh
January 18, 2016
Oh dear , that bad eh.
LikeLike
doctorhari
January 19, 2016
A fabulous and very fitting review for a movie like this. I really wish your reviews get translated in Tamil and reach the people who make these kind of movies a hit.
LikeLike
Ram Murali
January 19, 2016
It’s not a good sign when a movie reminds you of Director Suraaj’s recent work (Maapillai, Alex Pandiyan, Sakalakala Vallavan (aka) Appatakkar). I am referring to the laziness that BR writes about. In “Maapillai” Suraj had Vivek in a Netrikann Rajni getup only to make him talk like Suruli Rajan (!)… in Appatakkar, he had Anjali and Jayam Ravi swim in a lake, with “Pon Ondru Kanden” in the background… it was that level of lazy, careless filmmaking that I felt I was witnessing in Rajni Murugan… you have a lame scene with Siva Karthikeyan (SK) in Muthu Rajni (the older guy in the flashback) makeup only to have him sound like Saratkumar in “Naatamai”… phew! This was the first SK movie that I couldn’t even watch entirely… I walked away after an hour… 😦
LikeLike
chenab35
January 19, 2016
Thanks sir for your honest review. Siva was okay but not as good as Ethir Nechal. Samuthir kani was the only reason for me watching till the end.
LikeLike
mathblogger57
January 19, 2016
I watched this movie with family (my sis,brother in law, brother and his wife). They are in their 30s. Even though i didn’t like the movie, they seemed to love it. Like you pointed out, Tamil movie makers don’t care for serious movie goers. Their target audience is average middle class families and young people. When i said that this was not such a good movie, they were like ‘what do you expect?.. there’s family sentiment, comedy, good punch dialogues, a hit song and a happy ending’.
These directors understand these moviegoers which makes the majority here and they exploit it.
LikeLike
SANJEEV
January 19, 2016
QUESTION: How did SivaKarthikeyan become a huge star in just 2 years overtaking many top stars and sending out some chills to them?
LikeLike
tonks
January 19, 2016
He sets up a tea stall opposite the house of a girl (Keerthy Suresh) who hates him – because, in Tamil cinema, when she says no, she’s really saying yes, yes, yes, oh baby, yes
Absolutely LOVED that.
LikeLike
Raj Balakrishnan
January 20, 2016
Hi Baradwaj, this is off-topic. Will you be reviewing ‘The Revenant’ anytime?
LikeLike
brangan
January 20, 2016
Raj Balakrishnan: Writing a piece about Leo and acting this week. But maybe a more movie-related piece if and when the film gets a theatrical release in these parts?
LikeLike
Honest Raj (formerly 'V'enkatesh)
January 20, 2016
QUESTION: How did SivaKarthikeyan become a huge star in just 2 years overtaking many top stars and sending out some chills to them?
SANJEEV: There are two reasons – neram, thiramai. You decide. 🙂
LikeLike
Raj Balakrishnan
January 20, 2016
Oh! OK didn’t realise that revenant has not yet been released in India. Thanks.
LikeLike
SANJEEV
January 21, 2016
HONEST RAJ AKA VENKAT: I agree with neram but thirimai I dont think so…Ya I ofcourse agree SIVA KARTHIKEYAN has some good comic sense and dancing skills but I HOPE he doesnt end up being RAMARAJAN..
LikeLike
Honest Raj (formerly 'V'enkatesh)
January 21, 2016
SANJEEV: That response of mine was not in particular to Sivakarthikeyan. I was generally speaking!
I heard there’s a ‘map scene’ in the film (meant to spoof Vijay). Salute to the courage of this man! 🙂
LikeLiked by 1 person
Arjun
January 25, 2016
Mr. Bharadwaj.. The heros doing movies in their comfort zone. In the same way you should also write reviews in your comfort zone. Its better write for Airlift. You funny people always give 2 star for any tamil movie and for its same remake in hindi you award 4 stars. Boring reviews
LikeLike