Spoilers ahead…
There’s a reason we don’t really need superhero films in Tamil – our leading men are already superheroes. They defy gravity in the action sequences, slip in and out of several costumes during songs, and possess at least enough X-ray vision to peek into the heroine’s mind and realise she’s really saying ‘yes’ even though her mouth forms the word ‘no’. But seriously, why do we need a Kandasamy when we already have a Rajinikanth? That’s the reason Shakti Soundar Rajan’s Miruthan – “Tamil cinema’s first zombie movie” – doesn’t feel all that revolutionary. We’ve seen these vampiric creatures before – as ratha kaatteris, for instance. And because audiences, today, like their horror served with super-sized sides of comedy, we get Sriman, in the middle of a crisis, munching on chips. “Lesa pasichudhu… adhaan Lays saapten.” The film ends with the promise of a sequel. Here’s a free line. “Marundhu kedakkala… adhaan Mirinda kudichen.”
Miruthan, which has Jayam Ravi and Lakshmi Menon as the leads, is plagued with the usual Tamil-cinema problem – a good concept, but let down by bad writing, worse craft and a general lack of resources. The zombies are supposedly allergic to water. Instead of making this a surprise discovery, the film plunges us into the scene where the creatures surround a girl in a swimming pool, making threatening noises but unable to get to her. It’s not enough to just think up “zombies are allergic to water.” You have to follow up with “now, how do I transform this fact into an exciting stretch on screen?” The action has no variety, and the zombies are hilarious – they keep pawing the air, as though scratching the Invisible Man’s back. It’s a good idea to combine a song sequence with an action-sequence – romance plus danger – but compare the music video here to Raabta, from Agent Vinod, and you’ll know the amateurs from the pros. But we do get an outstanding hard-rock soundtrack, from Imman. You close your eyes in horror films because you’re scared, but here, you might want to do so just so the movie doesn’t come in the way of enjoying the music.
KEY:
- Miruthan = half-man, half-animal
- ratha kaatteri = vampire
- Lesa pasichudhu… adhaan Lays saapten = seriously not worth translating.
- Marundhu kedakkala… adhaan Mirinda kudichen = see above
- Raabta, from Agent Vinod = see here
Copyright ©2016 Baradwaj Rangan. This article may not be reproduced in its entirety without permission. A link to this URL, instead, would be appreciated.
sanjay2706
March 2, 2016
Another lousy attempt by a Tamil film director at a concept which so much rich in content.
Quite ironically, watching “Mirudhan” led me to “The Walking Dead”. I have never really been a zombie movie fan, but TWD took this concept and made it into it’s own. What rich subjects to work with! How personal losses change you as a person? How the need to survive changes you? How Darwinism can be almost cruel? How paranoia and suspicion can lead to unnecessary killings. It’s almost as if humans went back to being hunter-gatherers. There are episodes which show us the spring of civilization. Law enforcement is created, miniature governments are formed. You get to understand the importance of a civilized system where we don’t have to grow or hunt our own food, or get our own supplies. You realize individual humans are not islands, but are made by a collective set of people.
Over 6 seasons, the cure for an epidemic isn’t found. In Mirudhan, the cure is almost as easy as passing a Class XII lab exam.
I feel that the TV medium provides time to build story,characters and apocalyptic worlds. A feature film can’t, especially when it’s directed by amateurs like this director.
LikeLiked by 1 person
lakshmi
March 2, 2016
“Lesa pasichudhu… adhaan Lays saapten = seriously not worth translating”
-says someone who subjected us to all those ‘Arre O Sambar’ columns. 😀
LikeLiked by 4 people
brangan
March 2, 2016
lakshmi: Ouch, below the belt 😀
LikeLiked by 2 people
Honest Raj (formerly 'V'enkatesh)
March 2, 2016
BR: Rajinikanth and defiance of gravity are inseparable in your reviews. 🙂 I humbly invite you to see this one:
And don’t miss our Ulaganayagan’s tribute to Jackie Chan. To me, the most entertaining one was Jaishankar’s. 🙂
LikeLike
Meghnath
March 2, 2016
Did you miss out on a paragraph ? You didn’t even get into the plot. 😀
LikeLike
Gradwolf
March 3, 2016
Weren’t there like two readers who immensely enjoyed Arre O Sambar? Who were they? Priti was one I guess. This blog comments space is so much like an evolving band. People graduate, move out, new group comes in and so on…
LikeLiked by 1 person
The Ghost Who Walks
March 3, 2016
@Sanjay
Quite ironically, watching “Mirudhan” led me to “The Walking Dead”
If you like comics, i recommend the TWD comic series on which the series is based on. Almost all the points you mentioned are given even more time and space to breathe it often is much more ruthless than the TV series. It has some excellent art work as well.
LikeLike
vijay
March 3, 2016
This was the only typical Hollywood genre that I thought was left untouched by our peanut-brained directors for a long time and I was happy about it. But looks like they are pushing their boundaries when it comes to lifting. This is what happens when regardless of context/culture you try to drag something as alien as the “zombie” movie out till here and then pour morkozhambu all over it
LikeLiked by 2 people
vijay
March 3, 2016
“People graduate, move out, new group comes in and so on…”
Looks then like I have the highest numbers of arrears among the oldies out here..
Seems like yesterday that I pissed off Gautam Menon here in this comments space.
Pink Floyd’s Time is running through my mind now.
LikeLiked by 3 people
Gradwolf
March 3, 2016
@vijay Hahahahaha I remember that. 2008?
LikeLike
jussomebody
March 3, 2016
I didn’t enjoy Arre O Sambar! I was looking to hunt down the person who wrote those columns until I discovered that he also / later wrote pretty fantastic movie reviews 🙂
LikeLike
Honest Raj (formerly 'V'enkatesh)
March 4, 2016
vijay: I’ve always wanted to ask you that. 🙂 However, I wasn’t very sure because we have more than one Vijay.
LikeLike
Ravi K
March 4, 2016
Vijay wrote: “This is what happens when regardless of context/culture you try to drag something as alien as the “zombie” movie out till here and then pour morkozhambu all over it”
I thought it was interesting to see a zombie film with the Tamil movie tropes, though I agree with Brangan that it could have used more evocative filmmaking craft. Much of the pre-intermission action takes place in the broad daylight outside which is anathema to good horror, unless it’s done particularly well.
Basically it was a mix of Signs (with the water thing), Dawn of the Dead (with the mall setting, sans cultural commentary), generic zombie tropes, and a fairly standard Tamil movie template.
LikeLike
vijay
March 5, 2016
Grad, you have been around here quite a while too. At this rate we’ll never qualify for an alumni meet.
Honest, yeah I don’t use an official account to login, have never used one in the last decade or so I have been here, so difficult to track. Maybe the other Vijay uses a capital V ?
By internet definitions I am “anon” for all practical purposes. Just a consistently named anon.
LikeLike
Varsha
March 12, 2016
Could I get a link to this Arre o Sambar that you seem to refer to very indulgently?
LikeLike
lakshmi
March 12, 2016
Varsha: Here you go
Have a nice day 🙂
LikeLike
Varsha
March 14, 2016
I just can`t believe that brangan is capable of such ultimate mokkais. Thank you, Lakshmi for the links. I spent the better part of an hour laughing about his sheer creativity!
LikeLike