Spoilers ahead…
So get this. A top-ranking government official in Telangana – Praveen Kumar (Rahul Bose), formerly in the police, now in the education department – hears that some government schools in villages are going to be closed because there simply aren’t enough students. Praveen needs a plan to increase enrolment. You think he’d improve the quality of the noonday meals, or maybe he’d hire better teachers who’d spark the children’s interest. But no. He decides he’ll make some of these kids climb Mount Everest. The words “based on a true story” are redundant. No screenplay writer would put forth such a mind-boggling scenario.
One of Praveen’s superiors scoffs that he’s trying to make slumdog mountaineers, and darned if he isn’t: this is the story of an impoverished, 13-year-old tribal (Poorna, played by Aditi Inamdar) who became the youngest to scale the world’s highest peak. The film begins mid-ascent. There’s an avalanche. Many climbers are killed. The question, now, is whether Poorna will get the clearance to trek to the summit. Plus, she’s running a temperature of 104. In her tent, delirious, she starts dreaming about her… one would say ‘childhood,’ but she is herself a child. There’s hardly a back to flash to.
This scene is remarkable because it’s the only scene of high drama. And it’s not that there aren’t other crisis points. Poorna’s cousin is married off young, and she faces the same fate. The government-school food is terrible. Another film might have manufactured a crisis by cutting to Poorna’s family: they’d perhaps confront Praveen about the big dreams he’s tempting the little girl with. And what about the climb itself? It’s one potential crisis after another. There are crevasses to be crossed. There’s the low oxygen level. There’s the chattering cold, surely something new for someone from the sun-baked south. And did I mention the girl’s age?
We get a low-key crisis in an early scene where Poorna is taken rock-climbing along with other kids from her school. She climbs a bit, looks down, and freezes. The coach has to come and get her. Why did Bose, who also directed, not think to stage this scene on the grand stage of the Himalayas, where its impact would be thousandfold? One reason is perhaps the budget – suggesting is cheaper than showing.
But this could also be a reflection of Bose’s decision to restrict the story to Poorna’s point of view. The actual climb that brought Poorna fame – and made this movie possible – is a mere few minutes towards the end, and even there, Bose keeps his camera close. A couple of mandatory vista shots apart, we just see the patch of ice in front of Poorna, illuminated by her headlamp. A small girl from a small village taking small steps.
The film is focused. It doesn’t invite us to wonder, as Budhia Singh: Born to Run did, whether this is exploitation, whether an adult is pursuing fame through a child. (Bose is his typically inscrutable self.) Neither do we get, like in Dangal, strains of resentment and rebellion. Without these offshoots, Poorna becomes a straightforward story, made with a quiet kind of proficiency, and anchored by a charming Aditi Inamdar. Whether playing with her cousin in the film’s most affecting scenes or setting out on the adventure of a lifetime, she makes us care. They should make these films a compulsory watch during history class in schools. Otherwise, students might end up thinking that the only kind of heroine is Rani Laxmibai.
Copyright ©2017 Baradwaj Rangan. This article may not be reproduced in its entirety without permission. A link to this URL, instead, would be appreciated.
Aran
April 30, 2017
That was a joy to read.
What made me think were these couple of lines: “Bose is his typically inscrutable self” and “Poorna becomes a straightforward story, made with a quiet kind of proficiency.” Interesting to think about whether Rahul Bose is more of a technically correct actor (and now director) than an ‘engaging your emotions’ kind.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Anu Warrier
April 30, 2017
Your last two lines.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Radhika
April 30, 2017
It’s interesting that Rahul Bose was attracted to this Readers’ Digesty “drama in real life” story. I somehow thought he would choose films that waved a more sophisticated, “conceptual” flag. The trailer pretty much tells you the whole story, doesn’t it? Why are most Indian film trailers so linear and spoilery?
LikeLike
Ratish Ravindran
April 30, 2017
I agree that the story was conveyed in straightforward manner. The makers did not fully explore the discrimination which the IPS officer and Poorna faced because of their caste.
LikeLike
Jyoti S Kumar
May 1, 2017
Ooo caste… Who wants to touch that hot potato and get the film dropped!
LikeLike
Sai
May 1, 2017
“Why are most Indian film trailers so linear and spoilery?” – Risk management, I assume. Show all the interesting pieces so a larger audience is hooked? Speaking of spoilers, Rangan himself has “spoilt” most of the movie. I have a morbid fear of spoilers and Rangan’s reviews that start with those words make me not read the review at all.
LikeLike
Sai
May 1, 2017
Edit to my comment above: I took a chance on this review and was suitably “spoilt”. A good reminder to stick to my original plan.
LikeLike
Destination Infinity
May 1, 2017
I want to watch this movie.. but is any theater in Chennai willing to show a movie that is not bahubali?
LikeLike
Vivek
May 1, 2017
Like Anu Warrier has stated, your last 2 lines. This is why we come here.
LikeLiked by 1 person
brangan
May 1, 2017
Sai: Which lines here would you consider spoilery? Curious.
Because without a certain amount of detail, it’s impossible to write a review…
LikeLike
Aditya (Gradwolf)
May 1, 2017
@destination infinity: Poorna released on March 31st in Chennai. Along with Naam Shabana. Tough for a small Hindi film to hold on this long. There was Kaatru Veliyidai/P. Paandi/Kavan, all in between. Same holds for Anaarkali of Aarah the week before Poorna.
LikeLike
Honest Raj (formerly 'V'enkatesh)
May 1, 2017
They should make these films a compulsory watch during history class in schools. Otherwise, students might end up thinking that the only kind of heroine is Rani Laxmibai.
Perfect. But there’s a flip side as well. I often come across people who think this way – the north-easterners are no longer discriminated against in the mainstream society because we are living in an age where biopics are being made on people like Mary Kom. I’m guessing that this “thinking” might as well extend to text books.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Sai
May 1, 2017
@brangan I re-read your review and my apologies. Clearly my fear of spoilers is making me go a little soft in the head 🙂
I conflated the trailer and your review and between the two I felt like I saw the whole movie since all the key plot points seem to be present between the two.
I’m curious too: If you feel yourself that there are no spoilers, why do you start the review with “spoilers ahead”. I skip so many reviews when I see those words.
FWIW, I like your reviews.
LikeLike