Spoilers ahead…
It’s easy to see why a studio would green-light Casino Royale. It was, after all, the origins story of the world’s most famous secret agent. It’s harder to make a case for Shivam Nair’s Naam Shabana, a sort-of prequel to Neeraj Pandey’s Baby. Not only is this the backstory for a minor character, it’s also about a Muslim who saves the day. We don’t get too many of those films in India. Vishwaroopam was one. A man named Wisam Ahmad Kashmiri prevents New York City from being bombed. (Someone must send Trump a DVD.) Naam Shabana is probably the second.
The opening scenes are as generic as they come. An unseen photographer keeps clicking pictures of a man on a Viennese street. Ranvir Singh (Manoj Bajpayee) keeps barking into a phone about a safe house. The music is what would result if tension and anxiety had a one-night stand in a cheap motel. Standard-issue spy-thriller stuff.
The real opening, however, is in a crowded Mumbai street, as Shabana (Taapsee Pannu) accompanies her mother (Natasha Rastogi), who’s shopping for vegetables. The mother is in a burqa, but she does not mind that Shabana is friends with a boy named Jai (Taher Shabbir Mithaiwala) who wants to be more than friends with her. The film quickly establishes the family’s Muslim-ness as well as secular-ness.
Also kickass-ness. A man brushes against Shabana and apologises. She follows him, beats him up, and then returns the apology. She’s a martial arts student, and Jai says he feels safe with her. Ranvir Singh, who’s been keeping an eye on her, knows she’s a possible recruit for the RAW-type agency he works for. Its mission: national security at any cost.
So let’s recap: Naam Shabana is the story of a Muslim girl who loves a Hindu boy, and she’s being recruited by people whose duty it is to guard the country, and the hero of the earlier film (Akshay Kumar) gets sidelined as a supporting actor. The movie needn’t even be much good, and it’d still be a pop-culture milestone.
It helps that the movie isn’t bad. It would have been better with a shorter running time (it runs some two-and-a-half hours), but it chugs along with a satisfying mechanical efficiency – the usual amalgamation of chases and fights and training sequences and a dangerous mission to capture a weapons supplier wanted by agencies the world over. Small problem: the man keeps changing his appearance via plastic surgery. Like Casino Royale, Naam Shabana is about a first kill. What’s interesting is that this isn’t the first time Shabana has caused someone’s death.
Naam Shabana explores the notion of a woman using violence as catharsis. Not revenge, mind – it’s not about getting even with the people who screwed up your life. It’s more like she’s exorcising something: personal tragedy becomes fuel for public service. Taapsee Pannu plays Shabana as an expressionless automaton, and it’s easy to see why. Whatever she’s channelling, it’s all inside.
The best scene plays on the fact that she’s Muslim. Ranvir tells her that because of her religion, her point of view is different. “Aaj kal ki jo haalat hai, usme tumhare religion ke vajah se hamara access badhta hai – hamare raaste khulte hain kai jagahon pe.” In other words, her religion opens up doors otherwise locked. Shabana is not insulted at being “used” this way. She understands. She leaves. And then Ranvir picks up the phone and says, “Bahut kadi nazar rakho ispe. Zara bhi shak ho to khatam kar do.” (Watch her carefully. If you have the slightest suspicion, finish her off.) We’re left wondering if these instructions are routine, whether they’d have been issued even if the heroine was named Sharmila.
Copyright ©2017 Baradwaj Rangan. This article may not be reproduced in its entirety without permission. A link to this URL, instead, would be appreciated.
Deepa
May 1, 2017
Not a word about Pritiviiraj Sukumaran? Br…
LikeLike
brangan
May 1, 2017
SPOILERS AHEAD
Wasn’t sure how to bring him in without mentioning who he is, and that’s part of the suspense, no? 🙂 Besides, he frankly didn’t have much to do.
LikeLike
Apu
May 1, 2017
Was waiting to read some reviews of Hindi movies, thanks for choosing this. I was not really much interested in “Noor” and “matr” so this is great. Are you reviewing less hindi movies nowadays?
LikeLike
Kaushik Bhattacharya
May 2, 2017
“it’s also about a Muslim who saves the day.”
What about films like A Wednesday, D-Day, Phantom etc then. Do they not fall into this category?
LikeLike
Ashim
May 2, 2017
Really good observation. But it lacks simplicity. Sometimes it’s important that we practise simplicity. In the comments, while serious observation done, some where a confused state of Mind is also foreplayed. Her name is Shabana or Sharmila doesn’t matter. It’s secret service agency which do not even exists for the world. So whether the girl is Hindu or a Muslim doesn’t matter…she would have been under observation, if necessary be killed ..That’s the simplest logical reason that could have been drawn, and mind it it’s a very reason. Instead it has been given a religious angle (though I wud agree there certain religious angle drawn in the film itself) , do not give us the reason for the name being Shabana or Sharmila to raise alarm to that.. Statement.. Jaroorat pare to khatam kardo. Now the bigger question is when we comment such things is it and that too on platform where probably millions reading it, was it a deliberate attempt by the writer to take up this religious angle, or was it innocence (which I do not find at all in the writers starement). Or is that the religious hardcore fundamentals has got in to our head so much that we forgot to take things the way it is. And we are not being able to be unbiased when write a statement.
LikeLiked by 1 person
stalkerwoman
May 2, 2017
Yes, we have had many more movies where a Muslim(primary or supporting character) saves the day, and some without hammering the fact that the savior is a Muslim. In fact, the (fabulous) Danny character in Baby was a Muslim, and I don’t remember his religion being made a big deal of at all in that movie. As much as we don’t notice, I think we do have a fair share of secular filmmakers 🙂
But that said, we need more movies like Naam Shabana in India, for all the points you mention in Para 5, though I have a tiny bit of an issue with Akshay Kumar being there only to be her savior. Why can’t she go all out and find her way out without the superstar’s help.
P.S. google adsense is the real hero. On my screen, the ad I see on this page right now is for a “Muslim and Single dating site” for women. haha
LikeLiked by 1 person
brangan
May 2, 2017
Yes. While writing, not many films popped up in mind — so thanks for the reminders. But I think the bigger point I was making is that this film makes a case for how the agency recruits Shabana (ar least in part) for her “Muslim”-ness and is yet watchful. And outside, I really liked how they emphasised her family’s secular credentials.
LikeLike
brangan
May 2, 2017
As an exercise, can we make a list of films where the Muslim protagonist (not the supporting character) saves the day?
LikeLike
GODZ
May 2, 2017
Here I start…Viswaroopam..
LikeLike
ramitbajaj01
May 2, 2017
Chakravyuh
LikeLike
GODZ
May 2, 2017
Sorry BR..I pretty much skimmed the Wikipedia to find Muslim Protagonist who saves the day played by prominent Tamil heroes(From MGR – Excluding his to till date)..And this is all i can find…Alibabavum 40 Thirudargalum – (MGR/Alibaba),Baghdad Thirudan(Ali), Aladdin and aruputha vilakum(Kamalhassan), Insaniyat Ke Devta(Rajnikanth/Anwar) and Chandralekha (Vijay as Rahim)…:)…
It seems In tamil Viswaroopam is the only movie that has a full powerful Muslim Protoganist..I may be wrong..But thats how it is…(Not sure if Manick Baasha counts..:))
LikeLike
Altman
May 2, 2017
Chak De India, Kabir Khan
LikeLiked by 1 person
Shyam Rahul
May 2, 2017
Phantom has Saif Ali Khan playing Daniyal Khan and he too is on a mission and another film is Kurbaan (2009) starring Saif Ali Khan and Vivek Oberoi and the Aamir (2008) where the ending is when he finds what is in the breifcase and clears everyone away.
LikeLike
sanjana
May 2, 2017
Fanaa where Kajol shoots dead her hubby.
LikeLike
Srinivas R
May 2, 2017
Ek Tha Tiger, Phantom, Fanaa?Bobby Jasoos?
LikeLike
Jyoti S Kumar
May 2, 2017
I can’t think of any as saving the day. But I can think of many movies in malayalam, where they r the protagonists
LikeLike
MANK
May 2, 2017
Kallazhagar starring the great gaptun
LikeLike
KP
May 2, 2017
D Day Irfan Khan as Wali Khan why this useless exercise?
LikeLike
sanjana
May 2, 2017
What BR meant maybe a muslim lead who will put country first,
Sadly this is what one should avoid of turning muslim into a good one and a bad one if we consider muslims are part of India and not different from hindus in any way.
Will we ever say good hindu and a bad hindu? At the most we may say a liberal hindu and a conservative hindu who both will fight for the country unlike a bad muslim who may turn against the country or not as loyal as others. But we have hindus who are maoists waging war against the country. Khalistanis wanting separate country. And many others throwing hints that regional loyalties are supreme and other Indians entering and working in their states should be thrown out, which is against the constitution.
LikeLiked by 1 person
sanjana
May 2, 2017
I wish the film should have been Naam Sharmila to do away with stereotypes.
LikeLike
Honest Raj (formerly 'V'enkatesh)
May 2, 2017
Prithiviraj in Anwar (2010).
LikeLike
Vidhya M
May 2, 2017
Kurudhi Punal – Arjun’s was sort of a second hero character right?
LikeLike
TheManWithTwonames
May 2, 2017
Mank: I have serious jealousy over your appetite for movies. 🙂 I’m a long time lurker here and the other day me and my friends were sort of talking about BR’s reviews and he said he was waiting for your views on bahubali 2, especially cause you didn’t like part 1. Will you ever write a blog?
P.S : How many languages can you speak sir?
LikeLike
stalkerwoman
May 2, 2017
I would agree with Sanjana’s penultimate comment on the hidden dangers of classification into good/bad considering the times we live in, even if as BR says this particular movie might in part hinge on her being a Muslim, a) with a difficult past and b) with seemingly secular credentials. And probably Intel agencies might actually do something like this in reality as well? Who knows. Though it would be interesting to think how the movie would have turned out if it were named Naam Sharmila or even Naam Samantha (why not, that would be one stereotype breaking movie)!
And BR, the exercise is sort of silly as someone says above 🙂
But my two cents, because I am bored:
Karishma Kapoor in Fiza
Shreyas Talpade in Iqbal (he plays cricket for the country and that is ‘saving’ enough)
Shahid Kapur in Rangoon
Kunal Kapoor in Rang De Basanti(I thought he was a main character too like the others)
Honorable mentions
Shahrukh Khan in My name is Khan(saving the world, this)
Boman Irani in Well Done Abba
Consolation prize:
Delhi 6(fabulously secular before Kaala Bandar happened)
LikeLike
brangan
May 2, 2017
Okay, so let me explain again my interest in this. We are not just talking about a Muslim coach who helps India win. We’re talking about a film made in the Akshay Kumar mode of patriotism, and to have a character’s Muslim identity — a lead, not a supporting character — be an explicit part of it seems somewhat new to me. What interested me most was that Bajpai said that thing I mention in the last para.
Irfan Khan in D-Day led a team. Shabana here is a lone operative. That’s interesting to me, and very progressive in this climate.
LikeLike
Honest Raj (formerly 'V'enkatesh)
May 2, 2017
TheManWithTwo: Art has no language, sir. 😛 I’m guessing that MANK probably sees every film (good/bad) with his “Kalaikkann”. 🙂
LikeLike
brangan
May 2, 2017
Apu: No, you can pretty much find reviews of most Hindi films here. It’s just that they aren’t as prompt as they were earlier.
LikeLike
MANK
May 2, 2017
TheManWithTwo
Thanks man. I have rather eclectic taste in movies. I used to be a die hard fan of Captain and Arjun in my school days, because I just love their (honest Raj will vouch for this 😁) winning the battle with just one legfight sequences. So I am quite proficient in their movies from that time
No no blog. Just comment here that’s all. Don’t have it in me to write a full time blog. Who needs the aggravation right. We’ll Leave that to professionals like brangan 😃
Regarding languages, let me just say that I understand more languages than I speak 😉
LikeLike
MANK
May 2, 2017
Oh and I saw bahubali 1 again after watching 2 and I liked it much much more than earlier. Now that all the narrative and character arcs are completed.
LikeLike
GODZ
May 3, 2017
But Forget Muslim protagonist being the savior, But I am a bit surprised that there are only handful of Muslim protagonist out of thousands and thousands of movie all these years..I mean thats quite unbelievable..I am not making this political…But seriously? Bravo to the inclusiveness of our directors and producers..
LikeLike
Jyoti S Kumar
May 3, 2017
Godz: It is in this regards that I have come to admire malayalam films a lot… There is a healthy representation of the three major religions and also the movies are trying to base it out of the different districts to add a native flavour to the narratives… of the top of my head KL 10, Neelaksham pachakadal chuvanna bhumi, ustad hotel, annayum rasoolum, Indian rupee…
See below link on KL 10
http://www.firstpost.com/entertainment/how-kl-pathu-a-new-malayalam-entertainer-broke-islamic-stereotypes-2365582.html
LikeLike
Jyoti S Kumar
May 3, 2017
and of course Take Off… muslim/female protagonist (of course not saving the world, still…)
LikeLike
redhotshazi
May 4, 2017
Hi Brangan
I never cease to be amazed by the questions you ask and leave me wondering why it didn’t occur to me!
You planted a seed of doubt where there was none. So if the name was Sharmila, would they not kill her? My opinion is that they wouldn’t, simply because her being a muslim was not a serious criteria.
I think it was used as an icing on the cake (because he said that her being a muslim would open up avenues), but I really can’t believe that he had doubts because she was a muslim. He doubted her for her humanness, as this was a job requiring top secrecy, anyone leaking secret has to be eliminated.
LikeLike