Spoilers ahead…
Read the full review on Film Companion, here: http://www.filmcompanion.in/naachiyaar-review-baradwaj-rangan-bala-jyothika/
Bala’s new film, Naachiyaar, opens on acres of a trash-strewn landfill. As the credits flash by, the camera keeps moving, but there’s only garbage… and more garbage. Finally, we cross this sea of filth, and in the distance, we glimpse buildings, the big city. This visual can open any of Bala’s films, which focus lovingly on the castaways from society, the fringe dwellers, the people generally regarded (not by Bala, though) as “trash.” Now consider this line that appears much later: If an elephant moves, a few ants will be ground down. That’s destiny. This line, again, can fit into any of Bala’s films, which often portray the plight of helpless ants as powerful elephants go on a rampage. All of which is to say that one could make a case that Naachiyaar, in the context of the Bala oeuvre, is business as usual. But you’d be wrong.
This is Bala’s most positive movie. I don’t mean to suggest he’s turned into Sooraj Barjatya — at least, not unless a Sooraj Barjatya film has a scene where a suspect is interrogated with clamps holding her mouth open as a dental drill threatens to uproot all her teeth. But for the first time in this director’s career, we sense… hope. Bala’s dialogues are often very funny, and here, we get an exchange between two men where one says God likes to torment the poor. The other man replies, “Then let’s make a fresh God.” Recall Paradesi, where God was a silent observer, almost cruel in His refusal to raise a little finger to help people in pain. In Naachiyaar, Bala does a 180 — he presents the possibility of another God, not one that does His own thing but one that we can mould according to our desires.
Continued at the link above.
Copyright ©2018 Film Companion.
Pavan
February 27, 2018
Irrelevant here, but any chance of catching the Telugu film Awe! in theatres? Felt like asking after reading this line from the review: “In Naachiyaar, Bala does a 180 — he presents the possibility of another God, not one that does His own thing but one that we can mould according to our desires.”
Awe! trailer:
My review (also inspired by your writing somehow): https://letterboxd.com/pavan_j/film/awe/
Coming to Naachiyar, I think Bala surely wanted to step out of his comfort zone for once at least. And even in this film, his optimism actually looks like a satire. A satire on the larger than life overpowering his grounded characters? (at the BO as well…)
LikeLike
Jayram
February 27, 2018
Well written, Pavan! Please keep it up!
That said, I am eagerly anticipating BR’s review of Awe.
LikeLike
Siva
February 28, 2018
Take Away: It’s like watching a Pomeranian doing its best impression of a German Shepherd.
😀 #ClapClap
LikeLiked by 1 person
Nivaz
February 28, 2018
That grandmother character is done by Kulappulli Leela, veteran actress from Malayalam industry.. You think the writing was best on her character or her performance that stands out? coz u mentioned like an actor doing what a director wants but not the character in a particular scene… just wanna hear the difference 🙂
LikeLiked by 1 person
MANK
February 28, 2018
Would you call on Jyothika to embody this badass cop who acts first and thinks later? .
no no no, this sounds like pachaikili muthucharam revisited. horrible miscasting
pavan’s review of awe is good. i have not seen the film and i am not a great fan of films with multiple plots , i have been hearing good things about the film, so if the right opportunity presents , ill like to watch this. Post Arjun Reddy, i see the beginning of an indie wave in telugu film industry
LikeLiked by 1 person
Rajesh
February 28, 2018
Did anyone notice that Arasi’s father is the guy who is the brahmin agent selling sundal in the Bhagyaraj movie Idhu Namma Aalu ??
LikeLike
Jay
March 1, 2018
Began well, romantic angle gradual climb, a song was needed to pour out that emotion, but maestro’s tune… well… butterflies in fast forward mode..
I wish the love story develops into a full movie, maybe next time Bala Sir..
And someone refused biriyani to someone, and it made quiet an impact on him.
Good couple of scenes depicting the infiltration of hard core elements.
Jo madam gave her best, but Bala couldn’t resist the ‘kadari kadri’ cry scenes.
GVP and Ivana nice.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Anu Warrier
March 1, 2018
Just read that Jyothika has signed on to play the lead in the Tamil version of Tumhari Sulu. I wonder if they will keep the unabashed sexiness intact in the remake.
LikeLike
praneshp
March 1, 2018
@Anu Warrier: “I wonder if they will keep the unabashed sexiness intact in the remake.”
Well Jyothika cannot act to save her life. I’m super excited to see what her take on sexiness comes out like.
LikeLiked by 2 people
Jeyashree
March 1, 2018
Seriously ! Jyothika’s as naachiyar??? We have run that dry?
@anu: a shiver ran down my spine imagining jyothika as sulu…but then not to worry we will transform her into a one note self sacrificing mom and paint her black and white, sprinkle some pengal liberation moments…paint her what you want, she will do the jyo act only…
Unabashed sexiness…..you were kidding right? come on! people are going to be rooting for jyothika there….it’s suriya’s wife for heaven’s sake…and thanks to jyo’s acting skills we wouldn’t get a glimpse of sulu…. My bet is they will change the nature of the job offered to sulu. If they don’t, gear up for sulu in eight yards sari or double side dupatta giving late night lectures on fidelity to men over fm…
Also wondering who they will pair opposite her…what a performance it was in the original..the husband who was perplexed and annoyed by his wife’s dreamy, sometimes childish inconsistencies but also deeply in love with her….
LikeLike
Anu Warrier
March 1, 2018
Pranesh, ouch! 🙂
Jeyashree, now you made a shiver run down my spine with your script scenarios! I can’t think of a single Tamil actor today who would play that thankless role as her husband. What works for the Hindi version is Vidya Balan’s totally uninhibited performance in that role. Also I like that she has no inhibiitions about turning into a frumpy housewife with loud tastes.
I wish Manju Warrier would play this in Malayalam if they ever do a remake.
LikeLiked by 1 person
rsylviana
March 2, 2018
@Anu,Pranesh and Jeyashree
In case you guys missed, the film is supposed to be directed by Mozhi-fame Radha Mohan. Getting nightmares yet ?! 😉
LikeLiked by 1 person
Kannagi
March 4, 2018
Things are positively changing for female actors on Indian cinema to a certain extent. I am still not sure how far Jyotika will succeed on justifying Vidya Balan’s portrayal of Sulu keeping in mind her performances in earlier remakes. Now that Sridevi is gone and considering her aloofness to media, one can be sure that your attempt to interview her would have been futile. Will it be possible for you or Film Companion South to interview women actors like Sowcar Janaki, Kanchana? They are eloquent in English and regional languages of the south and it would make a good watch to know about their experiences. Cynically, with time and age catching up, do not want a “could have”, “would have” later. Even a write up as done for lyricist Thamari would be fine. This would have been a nice edition to International Women’s Day Special on Cinema.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Anu Warrier
March 4, 2018
rsylvania – I must be one of the few people who actually liked Mozhi, at least parts of it, but I’ll take your word for it that it should give me nightmares. 🙂
LikeLike
Jeyashree
March 5, 2018
@rsylviana: nightmares no….because Radha mohan is capable of pulling off something intelligent on and off… anxious –yes, because this guy, despite showing some promise in his earlier films, isn’t having good times recently with his films..
. I enjoyed mozhi,though not as much as azhagiya theeyae.. ..I find radha mohan’s characters sensible and interesting , though not fully explored.. he did the one intelligent thing that no else had, with jyothika (though why he chose her for that role is a more fundamental question to ask) – make her play the role that need not speak…but then it is there for us to see how she played that too..replay scene where she fights prithvi for imagining a voice over for her in his mind…
also, i wonder how better some of his films would have looked with a better budget..maybe that’s why you want jyothika- to scale up the budget of the movie..
ps:
gvm was the other guy who tried making her mouth maniratnam like scanty dialogues and used his semi montage songs in kaakha kaakha and VV to spare us the agony of watching her mouth dialogues and lyrics….
LikeLike
rsylviana
March 5, 2018
@Anu Oops!! No disrespect to Mozhi intended, but I seriously don’t think Radha Mohan can do any justice to Tumhari Sulu since he is one director who strictly makes films for what we call ‘the family audience’.
LikeLike
MANK
March 5, 2018
GVM Knows how to use heroines like her.Jyotika was a wonderful presence in both Kaakha kaakha and Vettayadu., ditto trisha in YA.
LikeLike
Jeyashree
March 5, 2018
@MANK that is true..he knows to shadow out their weaknesses if not highlight their strengths… He has a certain sensibility about portraying women..but don’t you feel they are all very similar – beautiful, with an impeccable sense of dressing, intelligent, uncertain about what they want out of a relationship, all with their ebbs and flows. Hemanika and aradhana are barely one shade apart… but he sure makes them very relatable, respectable and lovely to look at….
LikeLike
MANK
March 5, 2018
yes, there is a GVM type when it comes to women characters.Not all good perhaps. some of the things he make them say like ‘i want to make love to you’ and stuff like that looks rather trying too hard to make them modern and bold. and you are absolutely right about shading their weaknesses than highlighting the strengths – btw what is Jyothika’s strength ?.
And for a director who works predominantly in that upper middle class, upper class city milieu, he creates very relatable characters and that too in big star films, which is a rarity in tamil cinema. you just dont get to see a trisha like character – divorced, single mother with whom the hero is madly in love with- in an Ajith film ever
LikeLike
Jeyashree
March 5, 2018
Gvm type….true….just like there was and is a maniratnam type…
Jyothika’s strength…omg.. the kal ho Na ho like endless errhhhhhhh….errhhhhhhh.ehhhhhmmmm…there has to be something…errrhhhhhb…hmmmmm
Let’s just say she got lucky and bagged all those good films but still couldn’t make anything out of them….tamannah had a similar luck working in some good films with good directors but still made nothing out of them
LikeLike
Anu Warrier
March 5, 2018
@rsylvania – I didn’t think you meant any. Quite a few people didn’t like the movie. And I don’t like some movies that others have fallen in love with (DDLJ comes to mind). 🙂
LikeLike
Naveen
March 7, 2018
i liked Jo in Dum Dum Dum…and also Maddy and Kalpana and the fathers and the music
LikeLike
Siva
March 8, 2018
SingamPuli and Bala. Mayavi and Naachiyaar. Two different directors who decided to use Mrs.Saravanan Sivakumar’s own voice to dub her movie. The end result(s) sounded awkward to me on both occasions. I think it does, more so when your lead (female, at that, on the first occasion) is overzealous to hit a home run playing a bad-ass rowdy cop.
But hey, hasn’t our leading lady been that way on most occasions? 😀 One now recalls that Bernadette Wolowitz kind of shrill noise her dubbing artist so aptly squeaked when our artiste-par-excellence jumps up and down with that handwritten letter in her hand (a letter originally from ‘Swapna/Reema Sen’ to ‘Arumugam/Vikram’ that eventually ends up with ‘Naren/Vivek’ — courtesy our ‘Dhimsu Easwari’), yelling ‘Naren! Nareeeeeiiinnn!’. Yep. Dhooll. Unforgettable, stupendous enthusiasm it was from our ‘professional rowdy’ slash cop that is ‘Naachiyaa’ (rrrr).
You know, I am one of those ‘what ifs’ day dreamers. I have wondered more than a few times, on what could have been if the originally cast Ms.Simran Bagga had not opted out of Chandramukhi due to her physical limitations at the time (I believe she was pregnant with her first child). I was wondering the same thing today, even while I was inside the dark auditorium of Palazzo Screen 1, awing at the innumerable ‘Jyoisms’ on display. What if it were Ms.Rishibala Naval that Bala had chosen to cast as Naachiyaar the penis-cutter (with the absolute precision of a neurosurgeon, who is super skilled enough to not kill a person even after severing off, you know, arguably a male’s male-est organ).
Could those — couple of alternate scenarios — have been for the worse, or better? You know, the what ifs ….
LikeLike
Purple Sky
April 14, 2018
Iniya Tamil puthaandu nalvazhthukkal. Is this the first time in Tamil film industry that there is no releases for Tamil New Year?
LikeLike