(by An Jo)
- Major Spoilers/Disappointments
- No intent of comparison to Hollywood or ANY claim of superior intelligence or ‘taste’. I love Suppandi
- No intent of bringing down the morale of the Hindi film industry
- No claim over ‘masala’ and English ‘Grammar’
When Saibal Chatterjee from NDTV, who is utterly unfit to view or understand commercial Hindi cinema, rated it a 3 on 5, I was bowled over! This was like Ray giving ‘Gunda’ a thumbs-up! Then it is decided; this is going to be a full-on blast for me! And 2 shows were immediately added yesterday in DC [there were only 2 decided for the week – ‘Sone pe Suhaaga’; 2 more shows. I decided, if I like the film, I am just going to walk in right on to the next show. Also, I had credits on my account, so I could watch it for free! But then, being the ‘Bada Dilwala’ that I am, I forgo it and paid the 15$.] Alas, finding a parking spot in the mall parking site was a mess, as it is always. To add to the woes, now the theater didn’t have a central ticketing check-in, and the bar-code self-scanner was a mess. So I had to look at the triangular entrances to figure out where the movie was being screened for the 9:15 pm show. So I was like, ‘Idhar Chala Main Udhar Chala’. before I slammed my iPhone 12 max pro [I like showing off] angrily at the checker internally shouting at him as to how he could change the system like this without my knowledge: Don’t you know the state of my industry? Beherhaal, thankfully, the theater was the first one and I rushed to my seat and by that time, Akki was calling Bhide, ‘Yede.’ You see, he has a ‘disease’ of forgetting names; he calls Riya ‘Malaria’, Saraswati ‘Garbhawati’…you get the drift.]: And then there was an ear-blasting rush of ‘Soooorrryavaaanshi!’ Arre wah, full-on masala with tinnitus. And then a superbly shot parkour-laden executed action scene in Jaisalmer, combining ‘ghoomaroing’ women and Akki chasing down Abhimanyu, a sleeper cell agent from Pakistan atop the roof-tops. Finally, however, he is captured when Akki puts on his shades and shoots Abhimanyu’s vehicle’s tire. A promising start, a good interrogation style later, and the drama shifts to Akki’s marital problems, then his history with Katrina and all. In essence, the first half of the film is devoted to showing Akki as an ATS devoted workaholic who is ready to put his kid and his wife’s life in danger for the country, and emphasize it with, ‘Tucha mahila kutrya’—‘Bhai Papa Penguin ko bhi please karna hai na, kitna help kiya theaters open karvane mein; and then Shetty rushed back and shot 30% of the movie in Marathi— and shoot the terrorists point-blank. All good, and from then-on, the film, as a film (??), goes down like a nightmare, and the way Rohit Shetty makes light of terrorism is nerve-wracking, disgusting, and utterly repellant.

Rohit Shetty doesn’t know his chaff from his wheat. For all he knows, he can cook something from chaff and call it ‘Paneer Paratha.’ As Akki and his team; Bhide, Tambe—aah the names, Arre apne ko poora 180 degree jaana hai boss; I will ‘convert’ Ansari to Shastri— begin their search for remaining operatives—lifted straight out of Khakee—you get in on the daily cop-banter, and in-between, the preachy and done-to-death cringe-worthy ‘Hindustani Muslim’ versus the ‘other.’ Shetty over-cooks, and how? Every serious dialogue/scene is inter-cut with comedy; so much so, that even in-between scenes! What the hell? Be it a chase scene, a fight scene, an interrogation scene where an old Gulshan is being beaten black and blue [‘Kya phaayda itna muscle banake; mocks a constable], everything has to have comedy and has to be taken lightly. Like a ‘thuski’, not ‘Laxmi’ bomb, the scene just fizzles out within a second! Akshay meeting Katrina for the first shot is hilarious! He just walks to Katrina and asks, ‘Are you a doctor? I have been shot.’ Arre, are we playing, ‘Doctor Doctor’ game here? I got shot and was strolling around the city finding a Doctor! The climax is a joke! For once, Devgan’s 10 degree perennially slanted look works! In fact, he slants even his ‘chikna kamar’ so effectively; an RPG just whizzes by him and guess what it does? Surprise! It blasts and uproots a van! Ever seen this before? And Ranveer’s constant blabbering when Devgan and Akshay are trying to untie a bomb tied to Katrina’s pretty waist is so laughable, that it wells up your eyes with acid. Arre, yahan bhi? Pehele ‘Doctor Doctor’, abhi ‘Bomb Bomb!’ Bum Buma Bum Bum. I know we lost to Babar Azam, but it doesn’t mean you make-up your own games to win against Pakistan! Every time, every minute 10 bullets whiz by, there’s idiotic banter amongst the three, with so-called, ‘meta’ thrown in. ‘Apna Time Aayega?’ WTF? Also, there’s a discussion of ‘kiska bada hai, entry?’ Are you effing fighting terrorists or Mahatma Gandhi, that they have so much time and are so patient? ‘Bombs ke beech charcha?’
The worst part is how light Shetty makes of terrorism and the humor’ (???) he uses to lighten us; sorry meant to say, ‘enlighten’ us. After all, the great Charlie Chaplin also did the same, right? Boo Hoo says Shetty, always singling me out, you intelligentsia! And lo, he has the gall, the gall, to show grainy visuals of the Bombay blasts! Bhai, mein bhi reality mein believe karta hoon! Not just in gravity! The most horrendous scene was the one where they bring in Usmani’s daughters to break his morale. Akki slaps the belt on a bench and the plan (???) is 2 women constables would scream in pain: as soon as the first slap hits, one woman moans ‘AAAH’; and Akki retorts, ‘Arre, yahan pe Kamasutra chal raha hai kya?’ WTF was that? Women’s rape and torture are used as instruments and this, this is what you can conjure up as humor? You, Shetty, should have been belted and told the story of that mother who requests rapists to take her daughter one by one, otherwise, she wouldn’t endure it. This is effing humor for you? Any amount of BS of Muslims, sorry, ‘Hindustani’ Muslims removing their footwear and lifting Ganesha’s idol to safety cannot be salvaged by this disgusting scene. Period. [Shetty, I meant Period; not Periods.]
As the film yawned and yawned, and as I planned to leave the theater, I was remembered of the great Javed Jaffrey, who is so-called serious(???) in this film, holding me back by my collar and yelling, ‘Yeh Khatam nahi hua chutiye’! And my numbed brain went, ‘Industry Industry’, ‘Support Support’! And then I sat down. And I seriously wanted a drink, and with a nauseating headache, I headed for the bar, and instead of taking the east ramp, I took the west ramp; and realized I didn’t know where I was driving. ‘Abe, tu ‘King Kong’ hai ya Scorpio, jo tumhe police uthake, aaram se bar tak drop karegi?’ And as I went to the bar, the regular bar-tender asked me, ‘Hey, why so serious? Why such a long face? Your woman dumped you man?’ I wanted to yell, I just effing walked out of a Shetty film that’s supposed to save my industry man! But then again, like Gandhi in LRM, Shetty enshrined himself before me and advised: ‘Industry Industry’, ‘Support Support’? ‘Who knows, this gora might also buy a ticket to this film? And I said yes man, I just had a break-up. And then, miracle of miracles, 2 women came and talked to me about my ‘pain’ and brought me drinks. There, there in lies the genius of Shetty!! I belong to the category of Anu Agarwal in ‘Aashiqui’, i.e., neither ‘akal na shakal.’ And 2 women offered me drinks! I got the recipe now: Before heading to a bar, just watch Shetty handle serious topics! ‘Apna Time aa gaya!’
Maa Kasam Shetty, agli baar, agli baar healthcare, senior citizens, aisa koi sensitive topic handle kiya na, ghar mein ghuske maaronga tujhe.
gnanaozhi
November 9, 2021
Damn it Jo, I am booked in for today @1850 hrs here. The reviews were in general good and a friend wanted to go.
Now that I am forewarned, am going to get ptsd for sure. And to think this is the first ever Rohit Shetty movie I am watching
LikeLiked by 1 person
An Jo
November 9, 2021
Ha Ha don’t worry about my review gnanaozhi; it is just me and my disappointment. Go for it. You might even like it.. Go with an open mind…
LikeLike
An Jo
November 9, 2021
Thank you BR Saab for publishing this.
LikeLike
Anu Warrier
November 9, 2021
An Jo, hilarious, man. And I’m the person who sat back and enjoyed both Singham and Simmbaa and tried to forget the undercurrents of sexism, misogyny and institutionalised brutality that passes off for masculinity in Shetty’s films. [You can imagine how low I must have felt during the time that I vicariously enjoyed the feeling of vigilante justice!]
Akshay, when he was doing his usual cop routine in films like Main Khiladi Tu Anadi [or is it the other way around?] was pretty decent, until he became full-on jingoistic, sorry, ‘patriotic’. Now, he’s any abysmal pain in the you-know-where.
He’s – in a phrase that only Mallus might understand – ‘unsahikkable’ – these days.
Thanks for the morning laughs. Loved the unapologetic rant. I could feel your disappointment leap off the screen.
LikeLiked by 2 people
Yajiv
November 9, 2021
Oh boy. This is a pretty damning review. Nothing like having a hassle to get to the movie theatre just for an especially shitty movie. I was thinking of watching this this weekend too. Maybe I’ll just wait for OTT release then 😂
LikeLiked by 1 person
Jayram
November 9, 2021
Golmaal 1 is the only Rohit Shetty film I’ve watched in 2006 and I haven’t watched any of his movies since!
Hilarious writeup, An Jo! Please contribute more roasts of terrible Indian movies!
LikeLiked by 1 person
An Jo
November 9, 2021
@Yajiv: ‘Industry Industry’. ‘Support Support’
LikeLiked by 2 people
Madan
November 9, 2021
Hilarious review!
Did you make up “Industry industry support support” yourself or is this a wicked appropriation of something Shetty said? I will never be able to unhear this, lol.
Anu Warrier: I thought unsahikable was a Tanglish expression. So it’s found a home in God’s own country as well?
LikeLike
Aman Basha
November 10, 2021
This was gold 🙂 I wonder An Jo what you make of how Muslims have been represented in this film. There seems to have been a polarizing response over that aspect at least among the intelligentsia.
Also, I’m surprised that there’s little to no mention of any stunt work here. Akshay Kumar in the 90s had already done stunts that Tom Cruise gets a lot of praise for today, only that the camerawork couldn’t do justice to his daredevilry. I was hoping Sooryavanshi would be the right action film for arguably our best action star, but it doesn’t seem to be the case (although the trailer had some impressive shots, eg the helicopter scene et all).
Anyhow, this film and Annaatthe, irrespective of quality, are worth celebrating as they mightily disprove all the discussions around OTT with people writing obituaries to cinema, if anything, all other sectors are down except the theatrical sector around the Globe! Movies are back as they should be.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Anu Warrier
November 10, 2021
@ Madan, hey, that’s a mallu expression and I’m surprised to see it’s found a home in our neighbouring state as well. 🙂 🙂
[We can argue about its etymology and origins until the cows come home. Or not. ;)]
LikeLiked by 1 person
Madan
November 10, 2021
Anu Warrier : Ha! I have a Malayali junior now and I asked him what’s Thalavali in Malayalam. He said it’s Thalavedhanai. Vedhanai is an actual Tamil word so that would actually be a decent substitute for Thalavali.
LikeLike
Anu Warrier
November 11, 2021
Thalavedhana, not ‘vedhanai’… 🙂 Which is what poor An Jo seems to have got after watching this film. But he got a couple of free drinks, and we got this lovely roast, so I, at least, am not complaining. 🙂
LikeLiked by 3 people
An Jo
November 11, 2021
LOL Thanks Anu. However, I would slightly disagree with you in the sense that, it is only this movie that kind of takes a one-way approach to patriotism. I really do not have have any problems with BABY or NAAM SHABANA or BELL BOTTOM; of course, there were hidden hits there like ABKI BAAR UNKI HAAR and such stuff. But still, it was never an out-and-out stuff; and frankly, it was quite bold of him to hit out at the established tradition and norm in movies like TOILET-EK PK where he takes on his own and fights for having a toilet with spit niagara-dropping all over to get some decency to women who are forced to endure humiliation. We can give him credit where it’s due, right?
Cinematically, BABY and NAAM SHABANA are ‘ground-centered’ movies; i.e., there’s no pontificating on the part of Daggubati or Akki as to what is the common culture and BS between India and Pak; he just plays a ‘servant’ who’s given a job: The problem with this movie, I found, cinematically of course, is that it tries to merge the both and fails badly at that as it is lop-sided.
So you have all the ATS squad and heroes acting like clowns and the terrorists dead serious, be it Kumud, Gulshan, Jackie, or Dheer. Every terrorist has a fantastic back-story, but Akki just storms into Kumud Mishra’s room and utters; ‘Chahe toh mein bhi Bandook utha sakta tha’ or whatever…
LikeLike
An Jo
November 11, 2021
@Aman yes I totally agree; Akki was terrific at stunts within the frame-work offered to him in the ’90s. But again, Tom did the stunts knowing quite well that he could use duplicates or harnesses and with green-screen and tech at top-notch level. I would call Tom’s fascination for stunts as OCD versus Akki’s limitations at that time.
LikeLiked by 1 person
An Jo
November 11, 2021
@Madan no I didn’t appropriate it at all from any Shetty-isms … Just something from a crazy mind …
LikeLiked by 1 person
gnanaozhi
November 12, 2021
@Jo, yeah I hated it.
Good Gods as an auto aficionado does that man have no respect for cars and automobiles in general?
And what crass, moronlike writing and this from a guy who thinks Katakali is a nice movie so I definitely like my masala actioners.
Rubbish film rate it 0/10
LikeLiked by 1 person
An Jo
November 12, 2021
LOL @gnana: Hope my frustration didn’t influence you!!
Disappointment for me sums up the word; only thing going for me being a mard ko hamesha dard hota hai was katz … https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=l9u8Zb4fY1c
There’s a side-ishstory to that as well…
LikeLike
Aman Basha
November 12, 2021
@An Jo; I never know you were of such poor taste, Raveena’s Tip Tip oozed charisma, sensuality, and other complicated words that fully fail to describe all that is arising out of my mind afterwards.
But this, sir let me say Rohit Shetty’s idea of romance and sensuality is Raju Hirani’s idea of comedy 🙂
LikeLiked by 1 person
sanjay
November 12, 2021
I guess the disappointment stems from the balancing act the movie may have been trying to do. In last one year India has unraveled into a lawless odds and end type of situation and policing has been at the forefront of that expose. This movie would have been different had it been released in March 2020 and its clear Rohit and team have ended using the last 20 odd months diluting the message and the jingoistic flight of fancy tapered here.
In the recent past Hindi cinema has exceeded the levels of falsifying what is truly there for public consumption, so time is nearing for some sort of levelling up . Ground report on Indian policing is what a Sameer Wankhede types represent these days where institutions are being used as dug out for illegal activities.
Its ironical what a Jai Bhim and a Sooryavanshi represent…..this of course till the OTT comes under the scanners of power players.
LikeLike
Satya
November 12, 2021
I would be lying if I said this did not make me laugh. Watching the film, I recollected everything you said. And when I wanted to leave midway, I heard something else in my head: “Should’ve tried Eternals. Now repent for your sins and watch.”
LikeLike
An Jo
November 13, 2021
I am afraid you are wrong there Sanjay: when you watch a RS movie; you know pretty well what he’s going to show. I had no doubts whatsoever when I walked into the movie; what I was shocked at the idiotic level displayed. RS is film-maker who has a box created and shoves his writing (???) and screen-play in that box. He is not willing to jump out of the box.
All that Wankhede stuff and all is not for RS. It is not even for rabid leftists like Kashyap and the No-Anubhavs. I would prefer a centrist like a Neeraj Pandey to go and yank the street-level police-giri of Bombay…
LikeLiked by 1 person
sanjay
November 13, 2021
Well, I clearly know what a Rohit Shetty is capable of plus a lot has been written on Akshay’s compulsion to advance the distorted and sometime deviant agendas of the establishment. It surely has gotten to comical level in literal sense and your review attests the fact. Add AD the other poster boy along with Simbaa to the mix in this fanaticism cocktail that it’s not even funny anymore.
As to Neeraj Panday portraying street level Indian policing he was there to push certain buttons which sadly for even him are outdated now – replaced with in-your-face xenophobia. The complexities of a Wankhede or Kiran Gosavi or that of Parambir Singh and Sachin Vaze is beyond his realms of reality or none in Hindi cinema are ballsy enough to put it out there. It was not there earlier but now more when Hindi language movies are shying away and trying to outdo each other in buffoonery to please the power corridors or worse may be funded to do so.
Unfortunately, I ended up watching a hard-hitting honest Indian film Jai Bhim at the same time as this and found out that it is outranking Shawshank Redemption on IMDb. It’s time we forego the notion that Hindi cinema is is better than south Indian languages. Thanks to Netflix and Amazons of the world we can devour such superior products coming out from that stable which questions our silence as to why we as educated Indians choose to remain mute spectators in spite of knowing what transpires around us in everyday life.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Madan
November 13, 2021
” It’s time we forego the notion that Hindi cinema is is better than south Indian languages. ” – Yes, well, that is long overdue. I would argue that there have been very few periods when Hindi cinema was consistently better than South as a whole.
LikeLike
Aman Basha
November 13, 2021
@Madan: Till Bahubali you could have argued that the average quality of a Hindi film is better than the South, but even in technical values the most routine Telugu and Tamil film can give competition to a big budget Hindi film. Although compared to the early noughties, the box office difference between Hindi and Tamil/Telugu is greater.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Madan
November 13, 2021
” Till Bahubali you could have argued that the average quality of a Hindi film is better than the South” – I am not so sure about that. In 80s and 90s as well, Tamil films were better and more ambitious technically than Hindi. Hindi had amazing outliers like the Nihalani films or Satya but the average Hindi film, especially in the 90s, was super tacky. It was in the 00s that Hindi cinema had a renaissance of sorts at the same time as massilamani poosilamani nonsense ruined Tamil cinema. In the 2010s, the gap has narrowed (and a gap opened in the opposite direction between South and Hindi) as multiplex cinema wave of Hindi has somewhat plateaued and the nepot brigade has run roughshod (where 00s brought a lot of new talent to the fore). And at the same time, you have new, daring directors in Tamil. And of course Malayalam has had a revival too in the decade gone by and ongoing.
LikeLiked by 3 people
Yajiv
November 14, 2021
@Madan: I had a hearty laugh at “maasilamani poosilamani” 😂
LikeLiked by 1 person
Rishikesh
November 21, 2021
I liked it a lot more than Shetty’s previous features. It was steady till intermission, at least. I agree that the humour in third act was kinda misplaced.I think towards the end Shetty fell prey to his own overambition. I don’t buy any bit of this copverse thing. It sort of ruins the momentum the film had till that point. But there are marginal improvements in certain segments, The Akshay-Katrina is fairly understated. At least she is not a dumb heroine who runs behind the hero and infuriates you with her silly gags, as Kareena did in Singham Returns. Here it is more neatly done. The director is also unafraid of showing the vulnerable side of Soornavanshi. Although, he is a competent officer, he is struggling to keep his family with him. These small things might be a given in a Neeraj Pandey film. But for someone like Shetty, this is definitely a step forward. I think Veer is the best of the three cop characters he has created so far, precisely for these reasons. Actually I was reminded of Rangan’s review of Master, while I was typing this. I think this movie worked for me the way in which Master might have worked for Rangan. Atleast there are small attempts to deviate from the formula and an effort to improve from one’s previous work. I believe it has to be acknowledged. Am sure columnists might have been irked by many aspects in the movie. But I watched it from lens of a viewer who exactly knew what to expect from a masala potboiler.I wish to say the same thing to those who pounced on Rangan for thrashing Jai Bheem. There is a clear difference between a columnist and a critic/ movie lover. Both type of writings are valid and should coexist.
LikeLike