Picture courtesy: radio19deabril.com
THE LEOPARD’S IMMUTABLE SPOTS
MAR 6, 2010 – THE SHOWBOATING CENTREPIECE OF THIS foreign-film Oscar nominee is a five-minute tracking shot that begins with the camera swooping upon a soccer field where a game is in progress, goes on to single out federal justice agents Benjamín Esposito (Ricardo Darín) and Pablo Sandoval (Guillermo Francella) amongst the thousands of cheering spectators (they are interested in nabbing a rape-murder suspect, also amidst the audience), and ends with a dizzyingly staged chase that results in the apprehension of this suspect. The preceding scene, by contrast, is completely static, with the camera observing people in a bar in quietly animated discussion, mainly Benjamín and Pablo and a notary named Andretta (David Di Napoli) – but the dynamism comes from the way Pablo, with the help of letters stolen from the suspect’s home, painstakingly unearths a key to the puzzle, without which there would be little excuse for the ensuing soccer-field bravura.
Benjamín strides up to Pablo in the bar, irate that the latter has, without proper authorisation, taken the letters (which are evidence in the case) outside the federal office – but Pablo isn’t rattled. He possesses the tranquil demeanor of a seeker who’s seen the sign. He urges his colleague, “Sit down for a second. Sit down and take it easy. Know why we can’t find him, Benjamín? Because we’re stupid.” Benjamín nods in exasperation. Pablo looks down at the letters and continues, “Twelve letters. 31 pages…” Benjamín interrupts impatiently, “Can we go?” Pablo replies, “Hold on a second. My mind exploded, I couldn’t stop. I kept asking myself, ‘Why can’t we find this guy?’ He always vanishes. Where is he? And I started thinking about guys. Guys in general. Not just this guy, but… Guys in general. ‘The’ guy. The guy can do anything to be different. But there’s one thing he can’t change. Not him, not you, not anybody.”
“Take me, for example. I’m young, I have a good job, a wife who loves me… And like you always say, I keep throwing my life away in dives like this. Many times you’ve asked, ‘Why are you here, Pablo? Why?’ You know why, Benjamín? Because it’s my passion. I love coming here, getting drunk, slugging it out with anyone who pisses me off… I love it.” After employing himself as an example, Pablo moves on to his increasingly intrigued colleague. “Just like you, Benjamín. There’s nothing you can do to get Irene out of your head. She’s dying to marry someone else, her desk drawer is full of wedding dress magazines. She got engaged, had a party, everything. But you keep waiting for the miracle, Benjamín.” Wanting to explain why these men keep doing the things that they do, in an apparently helpless (and endless) cycle, Pablo walks up to Andretta and says, “How’s it going, notary? How are you? This is that friend I mentioned, Esposito.”
After introductions, Pablo comes to the point. “Let’s begin with the first letter from our friend…” He reads out a single sentence. “I swear it rained so hard I looked worse than Oleniak that night,” Pablo turns to the notary, who explains, “Juan Carlos Oleniak. First played for Racing Academy in ‘60. In ‘62 he went to Argentinos Juniors, and back to Racing in ‘63. In a classic match with San Lorenzo, he got pushed and fell face-first into the ditch. He was soaked.” And thus, the first steps are taken towards solving the mystery. Like Benjamín and Pablo, we were wondering who the Oleniak mentioned in the letter was and what his connection to rain was, and the notary has cleared the fog with this soccer anecdote. Pablo reads out another portion, “I’ll send for you. We make a great team. Anido by himself isn’t the same as Anido with Mesias.” Again, the notary sheds light on these cryptic allusions, “Anido and Mesias, backs on the club that won it all in ‘61. Negri at goalie, Anido and Mesias. Blanco, Peano and Sacchi. Corbatta, Pizzuti, Mansilla, Sosa and Belen.”
The routine continues. Pablo reads, “Don’t worry about me. I’m like Manfredini, not Bavastro.” The notary explains, “Pedro Waldemar Manfredini. Racing paid peanuts for him and he ended up being an extraordinary player. Incredible. Julio Bavastro, right forward. Played only two matches between ‘62 and ‘63 without scoring.” Pablo reads, “I don’t want to end up like Sanchez.” The notary explains, “He can only mean the goalie, Ataulfo Sanchez. Eternal benchwarmer. He played only 17 matches between ‘57 and ‘61.” Having laid out the grounds on which to construct his hypothesis, Pablo demands, “Notary, what is Racing to you?” The notary replies, “A passion.” Pablo asks, “Even after nine years without a championship?” The notary shrugs, “A passion is a passion.” Pablo turns to Benjamín and explains why there’s only one place to look for their suspect, and that’s the soccer stadium. “You see, Benjamín? A guy can change anything. His face, his home, his family, his girlfriend, his religion, his God. But there’s one thing he can’t change. He can’t change his passion.”
El Secreto de Sus Ojos (2009, Spanish; aka The Secret in their Eyes). Directed by Juan José Campanella. Starring Ricardo Darín, Soledad Villamil, Pablo Rago.
Copyright ©2010 The New Indian Express. This article may not be reproduced in its entirety without permission. A link to this URL, instead, would be appreciated.
Just Another Film Buff
March 5, 2010
BR, You have fittingly summed up the key sequence of the film that precedes the bravura chase sequence, which is not entirely meaningless. The script, not considering its foray into Hollywoodland now and then, attains a remarkable density and complexity comparable to those of Almodovar or even Hitchcock, wherein the killer, the bereaved husband and the friend seem to be projections of the same person – the lead – in ways he wants to see himself as, to be seen as, fears himself to be. Somehow, I want to compare this one with Waltz with Bashir, where, too, the complacence of memory when it concerns a personal tragedy was dealt with effectively.
My money is on this one for the Oscar, considering its immense marketability.
LikeLike
Adithya
March 5, 2010
Very interesting, and I loved the title. Will watch this one before Monday morning!
LikeLike
Vivek
March 6, 2010
Is there a reason why these wonderful short pieces are only for foreign language movies. Would love to see a piece like this on a Maniratnam or a Bharathiraja scene. I am sure your global audience will react to it just as well as they do to obscure European movies.
Right now these articles are exquisite pieces of writing rendered a little irrelevant since a good majority cannot relate to the scene but of course appreciate it is a write up.
LikeLike
KPV balaji
March 6, 2010
Jsut watched the movie two days back. Loved this, fantastic write up BR.
LikeLike
brangan
March 6, 2010
JAFB: There you strike again, leaving no stone unturned in the quest for world domination when it comes to foreign films 😉
Vivek: The brief from the paper is to cover foreign films. But tell me, don’t you get an idea of just the block of the scene from what I write (like reading a random stanza from a long poem)? Because if that’s not happening, then this column is a failure.
LikeLike
Just Another Film Buff
March 7, 2010
Hehe. BTW, BR, any inside news on Bala’s Avan-Ivan? In an interview, he used dangerous words like “family entertainment”, “action and comedy” etc. He seemed repentant about his spats with the producers of his films… Does that mean one more goes down?
LikeLike
brangan
March 7, 2010
JAFB: Yes, it does look that way. Apparently, the non-performance of Naan Kadavul forced some drastic rethinking (from what I hear).
LikeLike
Aravindan
March 7, 2010
I am yet to watch “Ajami” among the nominated films, but still I guess this might win. I would call this as a crowd pleaser compared to others – straight to the point, affecting and a great screenplay. And liked all the performances – the “aged” make up look a bit comical though 😀
LikeLike
Ajay
March 7, 2010
Somewhat off topic… but I managed to catch a screening of ‘Man on Wire’ as part of the ‘From Blighty with Love’ film festival. The film gave me goosebumps.
Wondering if you had the chance to catch it or do a piece on it…
LikeLike
arijit
March 8, 2010
JAFB seems to be spot on with his Oscar predictions…
LikeLike
Aravindan
March 8, 2010
It’s a great film, alright, but somehow i dont like the fact that it won over “The White Ribbon” / “A Prophet”. 😐
LikeLike
Zero
March 9, 2010
Baradwaj/JAFB,
I think Bala is on to something with avan ivan. (The title is hilariously frivolous though.) What kind of “drastic rethinking” do you exactly mean?
LikeLike
brangan
March 12, 2010
Zero: Just what I heard from random industry sources, that the megaflop of Naan Kadavul forced him to forgo all darkness and go commercial with a vengeance. Of course, none of this is based in fact, so for all we know, “avan” and “ivan” could be fraternal twins turned psycho-killers 🙂
LikeLike
Zero
March 12, 2010
Thanks! Actually I didn’t know Naan Kadavul was a big flop. But yeah, his reconciliations with his past producers does indicate something along these lines. And Bala himself did say in a few interviews/press meets that his next film will not be a dark film proper. But I for one like the idea of Bala doing a comedy. And I believe Bala will attempt to have an authentic setting for the film. (The film is set in Thirunelveli, right?)
LikeLike
Damn Quilty
May 14, 2010
Thanks a lot for posting this. I actually liked this scene a lot-maybe because after it comes the stadium one-shot scene -, but still the “passion” speech is simple flawless. Thanks again
LikeLike
sameoldnewbie
October 24, 2016
Delighted to find a note on this movie here! Just finished watching it. Totally gripping from start to end. I couldn’t find a clip of the excellent stadium scene online with english subtitles but here is the original Spanish version for anyone interested. I think a Tamil remake of this movie would translate well…(different view on the stalking issue too)
LikeLike