Notes from the opening day’s press conference at the Berlinale, when George Clooney lost his cool.
There are signs in the press-conference room that something big, something international is afoot. On one wall, there are clocks displaying the time in Los Angeles, New York, Buenos Aires, Berlin, Beijing, Tokyo. At the other end are booths, where translators convert sound bites to German, English and French. I’m wondering how hot they must be in that glass cage, for even sitting outside, it’s terribly warm for a city that’s recording 5 degrees C, with icy rain to boot. The heat comes from the packed room, with journalists and TV crews and arc lights. (Well, not exactly arc lights, but this is a film festival after all. Some flourishes must be made.) We were waiting for the cast and crew of Hail, Caesar!, the Coen Brothers comedy that opened the 66th Berlinale.
“Hail Berlinale! Hail Caesar!,” joked the moderator Anatol Weber, as he introduced Channing Tatum, George Clooney, Josh Brolin, Ethan and Joel Coen, Alden Ehrenreich and Tilda Swinton, who got the loudest applause. (Weber called her “the queen of Berlinale,” owing to her many appearances at the festival.) You’d think the questions would be different from the usual press conferences we see during, say, a film’s opening, but international journalists are people too, and a lot of the session played out like friendly banter. The accepted etiquette in these events is that you ask nothing terribly personal or provocative and they, in turn, turn on star wattage and josh around, giving the impression of letting you past that velvet rope, into their private circle of celebrities.
And for a while, this script was faithfully followed. A Canadian journalist said she wanted to make love to the film. A Polish journalist began to ask Clooney about his legendary on-set pranks. “Are you flirting with me?” he interrupted. The journalist took some time phrasing her query, and when she finished, Clooney said, “I was literally an ingénue when the question started.” He then joked about how the Coens thought of him every time they wrote a script about a knucklehead. “If I said anything nice about them, it was because I was drunk at the time.” Someone asked Tatum about his dance routine in the film. “Why don’t you dance for us now?” Someone brought up the Coens’ long-time cinematographer, Roger Deakins. Ethan deadpanned, “We just show up on the set and don’t bother to talk to each other anymore.”
There were a few serious questions too, but nothing too serious. Someone asked if the Coens were nostalgic about the era depicted in the film, which is set in Hollywood of the 1950s. Joel said, “It can’t be nostalgia, for we weren’t there.” He said it was more affection, admiration. “But we’re not sure how we’d have functioned in that environment.” The Coens were asked about Son of Saul, the Hungarian Holocaust drama which won the Grand Prix at the 2015 Cannes Film Festival, where the Coens chaired the jury. “I hope it drew attention to this movie,” Joel said. “That’s what these awards are for.” Then, it was back to Clooney, “Have you ever seen a Russian communist?” He replied, “Am I looking at one right now?” The question had to do with his role in the film, where his character becomes interested in Communist teachings. Clooney even mimicked Joseph Welch’s famous retort during the McCarthy hearings: “At long last, have you left no sense of decency?
By then, everyone was resigned to the fact that this was more or less a Clooney show. The actor was asked if he’d make a sequel to Syriana, the Oscar-winning film on petroleum politics that he produced. He said, “There is a lot wrong with the world, as we all know. But we are in a political period in our country today, and we’re not talking enough about the world. As filmmakers, we react to events. We don’t lead the way. The film happens years after the news story breaks. And you need a good story, good characters.” He spoke of his humanitarian work in Darfur (“it’s very close to me”) and how he’d like to make a film around the conflict. “But we haven’t found the proper script yet.” He said he was meeting Angela Merkel the next day.
Finally, a journalist from Mexico broke through the bonhomie. Referring to the refugee crisis, which she called a “human catastrophe,” she asked what Clooney, as a public figure, intended to do. To everyone’s surprise, he looked at her and said, “What is it specifically that you have done for refugees?” The woman behind me muttered, “Brutal!” But the journalist was unfazed. She went on to explain that she worked with an organisation that made toys for children and helps refugees learn German. Clooney was in no mood to back down. “Those are the people you are working with. I asked what you specifically were doing?” He had a smile on, and yet, for a minute, we got a glimpse of a cracked facade. It was left to Joel Coen to cool things down. “It’s absurd to say that anyone in public life or the creative world should be telling this particular story.” A question about Trump brought the script back on track. “He’s a strange phenomenon,” Joel said. “It’s surreal.”Everyone laughed.
An edited version of this piece can be found here. Copyright ©2016 The Hindu. This article may not be reproduced in its entirety without permission. A link to this URL, instead, would be appreciated.
Bala
February 12, 2016
Ouch, Clooney comes across as a very calm, measured person but that did sound rather…petty/arrogant. Though I guess it’s hard to say without listening to it first-hand.
LikeLike
Ram Murali
February 12, 2016
I wonder if the temperature in Berlin would have risen past the boiling point of water if someone had tried to engage Clooney in the “black and white issue” that got our commentors so passionate!
LikeLike
Deepak
February 12, 2016
I feel Clooney does charity because he feels that it’s the right thing to do – he doesn’t like to talk too much about it. But then it’s like the only thing (now that his marriage is in the past and hence not chat-worthy) that he gets asked everywhere he goes – what have you done for this crisis, and that crisis. He’s not Superman – and even Superman can’t be everywhere at once.
LikeLike
Anu Warrier
February 12, 2016
It was a Clooney show, wasn’t it? I guess I would have stood up and applauded at his answer. I’m rather tired of people asking others what they do for charity, all the while patting themselves on the back for skewering celebrities. Charity is such a personal thing – one does it, and doesn’t ask for rewards – other than a feeling of having done something unselfish for a change.
And I’ll take honest arrogance every day over hypocritical humility.
LikeLiked by 2 people
Nee
February 12, 2016
@RamMurali: we were just doing our arm-chair analysis when some went cyber rage which is so convenient and easy.
“She went on to explain that she worked with an organisation that made toys for children and helps refugees learn German”
But she did do something right? I mean what did Clooney expect? That she herself start an organization? As a celeb you are not supposed to counter question back to journalist like that. The journalist most likely is just doing her/his job. Not sure if an actor/artist is expected to take a stand, become a spokesperson (like Angelina Jolie and Clooney and co). I like bachchan attitude. Focus on art. Never talk about charitable work or publicize it (he has many going including donation to stop farmer suicides). Stay away from making stands in interviews.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Shalini
February 12, 2016
I imagine it’s a no-win situation for these celebrities – expected to do something and then questioned on their sincerity when they do act. I remember Benedict Cumberbatch being crucified in the British press last summer after he maid a plea for helping Syrian refugees at the end of one of his Hamlet performances. Other than politicians, I don’t judge anyone on the “what have you done for world peace lately?” front.
LikeLike
Nee
February 12, 2016
@Deepak: something is fishy.. the whole marraige and his work in Africa, which is good and yet the publicity angle… I think there is larger ambition…like running for office in later years. Watch it. Mark it.
LikeLike
SR
February 12, 2016
In terms of topic sequence, ‘Syriana’ was mentioned (middle east), then ‘humanitarian’ work in Darfur, it makes sense for the Mexican journalist to ask about his ‘humanitarian’ efforts for the ‘Syrian’ Arab Republic. His deflecting it back to her is an ass-wipe move since she’s not the one with a global platform to make changes – he’s just a molly coddled bully who should limit himself to selling coffee and porcelain tiles. Why do people like him – he’s neither good looking nor erudite – and it’s such a cop out for people to focus on this two bit hack! Particularly rich is the irony that the Berlinale has a special section ‘Initiatives for Refugees..’ (even displayed on their webpage) – hats off to the journalist for not letting him shame her.
He’s meeting Angela Merkel – nice name dropping – why do politicians take time out to meet these light weights??!! It’s not like she needs additional coverage – if she did, photobomb Taylor Swift and not some thin lipped old geezer. Who knows, in Clooney world, maybe a Chancellor-ship is good training for global script writing for future gems like ‘The International Ocean’s 14’; can’t wait to see a Darfur movie with him playing a pivotal role (akin to Robert Downey’s in Tropic Thunder ).
LikeLike
Nee
February 12, 2016
“And I’ll take honest arrogance every day over hypocritical humility.”
But if you have to make the (poor little) journo asking question punching bag for all the issues you suffer from or all the problems of the world, then there is some problem with YOU (clooney) and maybe he needs few more sessions with a therapist to work out his angst and improve his world-view/attitude.
LikeLike
SR
February 12, 2016
http://www.msn.com/en-us/movies/celebrity/george-and-amal-clooney-discuss-refugee-crisis-with-angela-merkel/ar-BBpqEt3?ocid=ansmsnent11
Right after my previous rant, this popped up on Bing trend – the picture makes absolute sense: politicians and international lawyers waiting on bated breath hearing a Hollywood product pontificate peace. Other forms of superior intelligence from that geography would be the remaining trinity Sean Penn and Brad Pitt – get them in a room to educate the rest of the world.
FYI, how was Tilda Swinton – her ‘we need to talk about kevin’ was thought provoking. I’m still gobsmacked that in a movie with Ralph Fiennes, Tilda Swinton….the focus is around one clown.
LikeLike
venkatesh
February 12, 2016
What exactly are celebrities supposed to do?
Damned if you do and damned if you don’t.
There is a certain type of journalism at play where every two-penny journalist stands up and attempts to insult, bait a celebrity cause of course thats news.
LikeLike
apex
February 13, 2016
There’s SNAPPING & there’s STRATEGIC & CALIBRATED snapping at reporters..
With ‘hail Caesar’ coming up, guess it’s likely to be the latter here…
Btw George Clooney has done nothin much of note following the “descendants” (besides marrying and making out!)–hope he does something ONscreen of note…
Ps: I loved him in ‘the descendants’ ..guess he should work again with Alex Payne…
LikeLike