Given the ‘heavy’ subject, you see why there’s so much emphasis on folksy colour, folksier humor. But the folksiness comes at a cost.
Spoilers ahead…
In recent years, Akshay Kumar has won a gold medal in hockey, made the country a safer place to shit in, ensured menstruation hygiene, warned us about the dangers of cell-phone radiation, scared off Brits with a navel-length beard… There isn’t much more he could do on earth, so in his new film, he wisely sets course for Mars. Still, in Mission Mangal, directed by Jagan Shakti, he plays less of an Akshay Kumar character than usual. In other words, he doesn’t jump into a spacecraft stocked with spray-paint cans, aiming to colour the red planet in shades of saffron, white and green. As an ISRO scientist named Rakesh Dhawan (is the first name a tribute to Rakesh Sharma?), he remains earthbound, literally and otherwise. He’s always the doer in his tricolour-themed films — but here, he’s the face of a team of doers. He’s like an IT team lead who hogs the limelight but also knows he’s nothing without the team. I was reminded of Aamir Khan in Rang De Basanti, who was the big star anchoring the film but also part of an ensemble. It’s good to see male stars in this mode. It’s as though they are saying: Once in a while, I can afford to step back. And Akshay has always been a very pleasant screen presence when he isn’t trying too hard.
The film, though, makes you wish it tried harder — but let’s acknowledge, first, how tough it is to put together such a project. This cannot (and should not) become a reason to overlook a film’s faults, but it’s important to note that we aren’t exactly an audience that throngs to stories about science. You have to tone down the jargon. You have to “entertain”, doing what Super 30 did so marvellously with mathematics. So you see why there’s so much emphasis on folksy colour, folksier humor. But the folksiness comes at a cost. You don’t see these people as brilliant minds tackling a scary mission on a ridiculous budget. Problems are solved almost as soon as they appear. Well, not exactly. But even if the problem and solution are separated by a few scenes, we don’t get a sense of the agonised mental calculations that must have produced the result. The magical aspect of this Mars mission is that it was “Indian” in every way, including the fact that almost everything was achieved through the very Indian technique of jugaad. But on screen, it all comes off like kids building a rocket for a school science project.
There are many characters whom we don’t see as all that valuable, and the screenplay trips over itself trying to give them a semblance of existence outside the ISRO (Bengaluru) office they work in. Sonakshi Sinha wants to get to NASA and “not be in this bloody country”. But is smoking and sleeping around the only way to suggest someone is “Westernised”? By the end, when she decides to stick with ISRO, we see her with a bindi. Taapsee Pannu plays someone who, in a moment of panic, grabs her driving instructor’s crotch instead of the gearshift. Sharman Joshi plays someone who’d love to be that driving instructor. As in Rang De Basanti, he’s a virgin. (In this film’s language, I guess we could say his rocket is yet to blast off.) HG Dattatreya plays a senior citizen, Kirti Kulhari plays a Muslim, and Nithya Menen plays a Malayali — to round off the demographics, I suppose. You cannot fault this film’s intentions — or inclusiveness. It even has a Canadian citizen in the cast.
With the exception of Vidya Balan’s character (more about her later), this motley crew registers neither as interesting people nor as scientific trailblazers. Rakesh has to keep saying things like “Yeh log bahut acche scientists hain” so we don’t forget it. Rakesh is at least a little more fleshed out. He has no hobbies, no life. He is married to his work, where he has two men competing for his attention: a sneering Dalip Tahil with an Indian-American accent (he’s from NASA) and an extraordinarily indulgent boss (Vikram Gokhale). Rakesh’s quirkiest trait is that he sings Hindi film songs that reflect his situation. For instance, after the failure of a launch, he launches into these famous lines from Hum Dono: “barbaadiyon ka sog manana fizool hai…” But a little into the movie, he stops the singing. Did the screenwriters drop the ball? Are there no songs about Mars? Things are random like that.
The screenplay keeps veering away from the science bits (what little there are end up being explained quite well) to events like a mini action scene on a train. You think this is when the big male star gets to flex his muscles in a movie where he’s so far been flexing only his brain. But that’s not what happens. What ends up happening is a nice idea, but it belongs in a different movie. The sentimental parts don’t work, either. When Tara Shinde (Vidya Balan; like the character’s name suggests, she is the star of the group) senses that the team members are losing interest in the mission, she asks them to recall the day they decided to become a scientist. This is followed by a series of sentimental (and embarrassing) flashback-vignettes, Proustian reveries that instantly jump-start their mojos. Far better is the colder scene where the Taapsee character’s husband (Mohammed Zeeshan Ayyub), an army man, reminds her that her job serves the nation as much as his. The scene makes you wonder what the film would have been like if, instead of constant “cutification”, we’d had a soberer version of things.
The one thing Mission Mangal gets right is Tara. I liked her innate Indianness. She doesn’t see a contradiction in being a scientist and a believer. Getting a pandit to perform a puja before a launch is part of the “cutification” we could have done without — but Tara’s belief is explained in very practical terms. This is where we really see creative producer R Balki’s touch, like the bit where Tara squeezes out the last remnants of toothpaste from a tube using a rolling pin. She is the Indian superwoman, superwife, supermom, who balances work and home like magic. And with attitude and spunk. She tells her whiny husband (Sanjay Kapoor) not to guilt-trip her when their college-going daughter doesn’t return home on time. I didn’t entirely buy the nightclub scene that follows, but I totally bought Vidya Balan downing Jägerbombs in a sari. Whether it’s her little frown of concentration while listening to Rakesh talk to a colleague or the gurgle of joy when she hears the mission is back on, every little thing she does is heartfelt in a way the film never is. Mission Mangal is watchable, sure, but the great achievement at its centre deserved a far greater movie.
Copyright ©2019 Baradwaj Rangan. This article may not be reproduced in its entirety without permission. A link to this URL, instead, would be appreciated.
Rohit Sathish Nair
August 25, 2019
“As an ISRO scientist named Rakesh Dhawan (is the first name a tribute to Rakesh Sharma?)…”
Rakesh Sharma AND Satish Dhawan. Imagination MAX.
Though to give them credit, Vikram Sharma or Vikram Chawla would’ve been boring names
LikeLiked by 1 person
jewelsofsayuri
August 26, 2019
I agree that the film has its flaws. I would have liked to see how Nithya Menon manages both her children – her kid and the mission. I would like to know more about Rakesh’s life and yes I would like to know more about the technical details of the mission. Still, I like the movie for its portrayal of a Govt organisation without resorting to the usual stereotypes. Making do with what resources that are available, women holding up the fort, people working double shifts just because you want to get the work done, helping out a colleague in a delicate personal situation , jokes being centred around food – this are some snippets of a real Govt. office in India. I think that Sonakshi Sinha is in a saree and bindi in the last scene as the makers were trying to recreate a photo that made the rounds when Mangalyaan was launched – the one with five saree clad scientists showing thumbs up.
LikeLike
Rishikesh
August 26, 2019
With the exception of Vidya Balan’s character (more about her later), this motley crew registers neither as interesting people nor as scientific trailblazers.
Is this asking for a bit too much especially in a 2 hour long film like Mission Mangal which is more plot centric than character centric. If the makers had dwelled more on the personal lives of the supporting characters, the pacing of the film on the whole would have been affected and that would have resulted in a bigger problem.
Lack of strong emotional moments (BY THAT i DON’T MEAN JINGOISM) was the major issue for me with the film, especially since the subject had the tremendous potential for it. But Balki & Co. have never been good with heavy drama, probably Gauri Shinde could have offered some advice, I still love English Vinglish and Dear Zindagi.
LikeLike
Vishal
August 26, 2019
It even has a Canadian Citizen in its cast. Hahah – that was a zinger BRangan.
LikeLiked by 3 people
meera
August 27, 2019
Is there anybody who can really harness Nithya Menons talent? She almost eclipsed Vijay in Mersal… she is flawless…
LikeLike
KK
August 27, 2019
There is a similar, yet far better and more powerful, movie in Hollywood. It’s called Hidden Figures. The similarity doesn’t end in just an abundance of female characters. The mission is almost the same. If here India tries to achieve what other countries could not in the first attempt (even though the mission was a demonstration of technology and not exactly as sophisticated as say MAVEN), there it was the USA trying to outrace the Soviet Union in the space race. What that film had is that there the issues of racism, segregation that loomed largely over the scientific discussions the three women had with their peers made us aware of the need for the success of the mission. In a way, the pride of the nation was sidestepped for the pride of the community as a whole. Here it’s the opposite. The personal stories are just fillers and not exactly moving. Another big win for that movie over this one is that despite being targeted at a general audience, science is never dumbed down. No self-respecting scientist talks to another the way AK talks to Dilip Tahil(that puri and oil saving scene is just embarrassing).
LikeLike
httpweavemagic
August 27, 2019
Half the time, I think I want to watch a film is because of your reviews about it, Sir 🙂
LikeLiked by 1 person