THE REEL McCOY
Shahid and Kareena may have split up for real, but they do a smashing imitation of being in love in a beautifully written â if uneven â romance.
OCT 28, 2007 – I WAS SO GOBSMACKED when I saw Imtiaz Aliâs Socha Na Tha â the directorâs first feature â that I lost no time doing pro bono word-of-mouth service for the film. But almost everyone I spoke to came back saying that it was nice and all (that is, in an okayish way), but wondered what I was making such a fuss about. And in hindsight, I realise I may have oversold that modest romance.
What I should have said is: See, the director is new and the leads are new, so, yes, the staging is a bit off and the performances arenât quite there â but notice the writing. Have you seen, in recent times, moments as real-life raw as the ones where the hero finally discovers that heâs in love with the heroine, and that happiness is undercut almost immediately by his awkward breaking of this news to the other girl he thought he was in love with that far?
Iâm going to use that same qualifier when people ask me about Aliâs second film, Jab We Met â except that, this time around, it isnât the performances or the staging that cause the reservations. (How ironic that Shahid Kapur and Kareena Kapoor â as Aditya and Geet â register their finest romantic moments with each other within days after the news that theyâve broken up in real life. And itâs impossible not to draw these off-screen parallels, especially with their characters compounding this irony by claiming to be â at one point â a one-woman man and a one-man woman. Tch, tch!)
Jab We Met suffers â particularly in the post-interval portions â from a storyline that becomes increasingly tedious, especially with the will-they-get-together aspect never being in any kind of doubt. (Itâs what Roger Ebert likes to call the Idiot Plot, where all one had to do to fix things is speak up and clear the confusion.) But Aliâs writing, otherwise, is so wonderful, I doubt youâll care.
His screwball-road-romance is about opposites â Geet, who talks nonstop, and Aditya, who doesnât have a line of dialogue for several minutes into the film, despite being the focus of every frame till then. They meet on a train â sheâs running away from her hostel to her home in Bhatinda; heâs escaping a painful past â and when her confessional chattering becomes really annoying, he yells that he doesnât care if sheâs from Bhatinda or Banaras, whether sheâs fleeing from a hostel or a brothel, so could she please clam up. This outburst â his first spoken words â stuns her, and just as you think sheâs going to up her decibel levels in retaliation, she rebukes him softly: âBrothel wali baat theek nahin thi.â? Heâs ashamed, naturally, and sheâs too cheerfully thick-skinned to let things linger, so they begin a conversation that builds into the rest of the film.
Itâs moments like this that make Jab We Met â because when Ali writes scenes and dialogues, heâs in no hurry to get to the point (which, I guess, may explain my affinity to his work). Where thereâs a possible shortcut, he always chooses the scenic route, veering off on tangents about karate and call-girls and sugarcane and rape and safe-deposit boxes, and these detours add so much flavour and fun to whatâs going on that I didnât have the heart to nitpick about how, for instance, a few of the songs are major speedbreakers. How can a writer this good be so completely clueless about how to write such terrific songs (mostly by Pritam, with one contribution from Sandesh Shandilya) into his screenplay?
As with Socha Na Tha, you care for Jab We Met because you care for the people in it. Geet and Aditya arenât some generic boy-girl constructs, existing solely so that they can be wrung through the machinations of a screenplay. As clichéd as this sounds, they are flesh-and-blood folk â at least to the extent that you could hope to find in a crowd-pleasing romance. Aditya blames his mother for falling out of love with his father. (The scene where they reconcile is an understated beauty.) And Geet has her own display of (what appears to be) borderline-selfishness (when it comes to her mother), when she pretends to have run away from home and doesnât seem to care that her mother is in tears, worried sick.
But Ali makes us see that this isnât a failing as such; itâs just her. My favourite moment in Jab We Met â and possibly the best romantic moment of this year so far â is when Aditya finally gets Geet for what she is (and this is when he begins falling for her). His face lights up in a smile as he observes, âTum apne aap ko bahut pasand karti ho,â? that she likes herself a great deal. And when she nods, agreeing wholeheartedly that sheâs her own favourite individual (perhaps to the point of self-absorption), it all falls into place. So sheâs not perfect, sheâs just a person â and thank heavens for that.
Copyright ©2007 The New Sunday Express
Prashanth
October 27, 2007
I never read ur ‘Socha na Tha’ review (if there was one from u) but i simply loved tht movie. As u pointed out, it was the rawness that appealed most about ‘Socha Na tha’. I guess i’d be on my way to ‘jab we met’ now. Shahi-kareena pair..wow!! life sometimes is so funny!!
LikeLike
S
October 27, 2007
No, No Smoking?
LikeLike
Akshay Shah
October 27, 2007
Any chance of a NO SMOKING review Ranganbhai?
Superb review of JWM as always, my sister calls it “shahids DDLJ moment”! I ‘ll check this one out this week..
A.Shah
LikeLike
brangan
October 27, 2007
Prashanth: I didn’t do a Socha Na Tha review, as it came and went before anyone knew. I caught it much later on DVD.
S/Akshay: I’ll put up No Smoking soon. Only Jab We Met made it to this Sunday’s paper, so I guess in a couple of days?
LikeLiked by 1 person
Charles Foster Kane
October 27, 2007
Baradwaj, did you like NS? Please tell me!
LikeLike
Santanu
October 27, 2007
A great review as always.. Looking forward to your take on No Smoking.. Watched it in a half-empty theatre in Bangalore with cat calls from the exasperated audience in the second half of the movie :-).. Personally feel that Anurag Kashyap has taken the Censor board for a ride here as there can’t be a more pro-smoking movie.. If you lose your soul by quitting smoking then I don’t see too many people trying that.. Will wait for your take on that…
LikeLike
Nitin
October 28, 2007
Eagerly waiting for your take on No Smoking …
LikeLike
Sheetal
October 28, 2007
Wasn’t Socha na tha terrific? I did quite the same, urging as many people I possibly could to watch it. Really glad it wasn’t a one-off thing because Imtiaz Ali’s follow up Jab We Met simply sparkles.
LikeLike
ABF
October 28, 2007
hav u written reviews fr “kanda nal mudhal” or “alagiya theeye”? Wud lik to read it if u have.
LikeLike
brangan
October 28, 2007
ABF: Nope, never got around to reviewing either.
LikeLike
Mumbai Ramki
October 29, 2007
It would be interesting to see the review for No SMoking. I saw this movie On anight show and came out ..well , let me wait for ur review ./…I have pounds and punds to say about that movie 🙂
LikeLike
d-day
October 29, 2007
this is a nice film..like others,no smoking?
LikeLike
Silk Smitha
October 29, 2007
Hi,
Coupla suggestions
1) Can you put hyperlinks when you refer to what you said in another review so we can get to the pearls dropped earlier without having to google
2) many of us read your old reviews and go DVD hunting, so can’t you write reviews of movies which “came and went before anyone knew” and you caught on DVD
LikeLiked by 1 person
Gurudev
October 30, 2007
Hi Rangan,
Don’t know if you have seen ‘Ahista Ahista’ by Sivam Nair. The story and screenplay is by Imtiaz Ali and I am sure you would appreciate his ability to sketch heartwarming characters in this movie as well. Though I must warn you about the slow pace of the movie and the music which is quite distasteful.
LikeLike
Ava
November 1, 2007
awesome.. now i am going to watch the movie this sat.. if i can get a ticket that is.. 🙂
tum apne aap ko bahut pasand karti ho.. wow .. whatta line
LikeLike
Meenakshi
November 2, 2007
I saw part of this movie and found Kareena to be shrill and terrible at comedy. She screams and when she misses the second train her look of shock is less surprise and frustration and more like she just saw Freddie and Jason getting ready to kill her with a chainsaw and a machete. I couldn’t watch the whole thing…Socha Na Tha was definitely a winner in my book, but this, looked more like an ad film, a bad one at that.
LikeLike
Lakshmi
November 6, 2007
To begin with, I agree with Meenakshi. Initially, to me Kareena’s shrill was annoying. But we have to give it to th girl. She simply suited the role of a loud sikhni girl. She was perfect for the role. Her shrill voice kind of did well for the role.
Lovely movie. I just feel if it was release a couple of weeks, it would not have suffered the om shanti om syndrome.
Nevertheless, soft and sweet movie.
Gurudev: Even I liked Ahista Ahista. 🙂
All this apart, I loved the song mauja hi mauja. What a disco number by very own Mikka. I strongly feel he is a very under utilised singer in Bollywood.
Baradwaj: Have you got the time to see Sattam Podathey? Please let me know. I have been trying to grab the DVD here in Delhi, but have not been too successful. Tell me about the movie, if you have watched it. Thanks.
LikeLike
Deepak Jeswal
November 8, 2007
No, you weren’t the only one who went overboard in recommending Socha Na Tha. Me too was there 😀 And another friend…who was , a bit later, somewhat apologetic … you know he went ‘ it cud be my mood at the time of watching the film’ … but the point is that there are quite a bunch I know who really loved that movie, including, of course, myself.
Ditto for Jab We Met … luved the film… and agree to everything u said, in fact it s uncanny, u almost echo my own thoughts.
LikeLike
Gopi
November 9, 2007
anyone got an idea who the actor is who played the hotel receptionist? that scene apart from the oft discussed ones made this movie for me. the whole dynamics of that scene was just too good. from shahids initial frustration, then to his giving in to kareena’s pearls of wisdom and then to his playing along with receptionist. i was laughing out loud like a loon.
LikeLike
Sagarika
November 14, 2007
brangan: I’d dodged this one with the hopes of catching the movie first and relishing your review later but looks like I’ll have to leave the viewing to chance. Just ain’t happening.
Now, your review takes “vicarious pleasure” to a whole new level. I’m sure I’m echoing collective sentiments when I say that ever since I started reading your reviews, I can’t seem to pinpoint which I enjoy more…my own movie moments or being an avid listener as you relate yours.
And for some reason, aspects of “Jab We Met” as you describe it, brought forth buried “Rayil Sneham” memories (so much so I’m willing to take back my rant in your KB post from last week). 🙂 Maybe it’s the effect of: “They meet on a train – she’s running away from her hostel…. he’s escaping a painful past…they begin a conversation that builds into the rest of the film.” Made my day!
LikeLike
sarah
January 28, 2010
WONDERFUL film all over the years.Best of luck for shahid kapoor
LikeLike