Spoilers ahead…
It’s surprising to find Reema Kagti in masala mode. Gold stars Manoj Akshay Kumar as Tapan Das, the manager of the Indian hockey team — but the film opens in 1936, at the Berlin Olympics, when it’s still the British Indian hockey team. The team wins, but when the national anthem is played, it’s still not our song. So the film’s ending should be a rouser. Because it’s the 1948 Olympics, in London, and what better revenge on the coloniser than to defeat him on home turf and stuff his ears with the anthem of the newly minted motherland! India wins. The anthem plays. It sounds beautiful, a symphonic version of a tune we usually hear from a brassy band. This is, on paper, a marvellous echo of the scene from the beginning of the film. But the echo stays in the head. It doesn’t resonate in the heart.
Masala movies are warm things, full of heat and spice. Gold is cold. The director makes the mistake in thinking that a masala movie simply means broad-brush filmmaking, which is like defining a raga by its ascending or descending notes. That’s just the framework. The real ras of the raga comes from the detailing, the fresh phrases, the microtones — and Gold never scratches below the surface. What you see is what you get. There are many juicy plot points — say, the team member (Imtiaz, played by Vineet Kumar Singh) who moves to Pakistan, during Partition, and runs into the Indian team again during the London Olympics. These are his friends, his colleagues, his brothers. The way this reunion is handled ensures that there isn’t a wet eye in the house. I recalled the scene from Soorma where the protagonist calls his brother to inform he’s been selected. That’s how it should be done. Gold wants to be classy. It tries to make a croissant out of bhajia batter.
Look at the lame interval point, where names are crossed off a list of team members. Instead of lightning and thunder, you get the rasp of pencil on paper. Unlike Talaash, which was incendiary material that could be handled in Reema Kagti’s tasteful style, Gold needs a director who’s a shameless hustler. There’s so little texture in the screenplay — and so much that’s reminiscent of older, better sports dramas like (the rousing) Lagaan and (the restrained) Chak De India — that in the absence of a forceful vision, the chest-thumping material comes off both overblown and bland. Everything feels perfunctory. Tapan’s fondness for booze results in one show-stopping song sequence, but is he an alcoholic or does he only drink when depressed? He seems to be able to stop very easily. (His big locker-room speech needed more… spirit.) This is a small point, but the bigger one is that there isn’t enough to Tapan that makes us root for him or his team. It all proceeds along preordained lines. Heck, look at the film’s title. There’s not much chance of nail biting about the Indians ending up with a silver medal, is there?
The other main characters are Raghubir Pratap Singh (Amit Sadh) and Himmat Singh (Sunny Kaushal) — the former a pampered princeling, the latter an underprivileged policeman who rubs Raghubir the wrong way. But Reema, who managed to delineate a huge crowd of characters in Honeymoon Travels Pvt. Ltd., is unable to make even these two men interesting. You wonder what she saw in this material. An easy hit, piggybacking on a star? A rah-rah story in tune with the present national sentiment? How did she reconcile herself with hockey scenes where white men are evil and brown men are good and pure? How did she not balk at the script that terms India trouncing England as revenge on the coloniser (on his soil, no less!), and goes on to repeat this point some 3,812 times? Did she not giggle when a senior member of the hockey board turned into exactly the kind of villain we predicted in the second reel? Gold feels like a sequel to Talaash, where we’re left searching for answers to a mystery: Whatever happened to Reema Kagti?
Copyright ©2018 Baradwaj Rangan. This article may not be reproduced in its entirety without permission. A link to this URL, instead, would be appreciated.
rsylviana
August 26, 2018
I watched this film on the Independence Day weekend and had a moral crisis of sorts thinking that the Bhakts had finally done it – played the ‘Who is the most anti-national of all?’ game so much that they had made Patriotism to be some kind of a bad thing. I was thinking maybe that was why I was not able to feel a twinge of euphoria/any emotion after watching this film. My friends found it to be good but I could barely muster back a ‘one-time watch’ while I was thinking what the hell is wrong with me…
LikeLiked by 1 person
Devarsi Ghosh
August 26, 2018
I think they have a research department present in every production house now whose job is to dig out all obscure Indian sports heroes and war heroes and small-town heroes who exemplify the “spirit” of India, etc. Then the master list is narrowed down to see which of these stories can be readily turned into Independence Day and Republic Day releases. And the final step is to see which of the Manoj Kumar me-toos can somehow fit into the role. Voila. 100 crores: theatrical plus streaming/tv/music rights.
LikeLiked by 4 people
vinjk
August 27, 2018
Totally agree with rsylviana. In the current political climate, patriotism has really turned into a bad thing. When the trailer of Gold was shown a month ago in theatre, the first scene was “Stand up for the national anthem”.. Many people did and I didn’t. In my mind I was thinking “oh boy, now some assholes will come up and force me to stand up”.
They played some other anthem (British I think)…
LikeLike
Vivek narain
August 27, 2018
Who cares for Manoj kumar and his famous tag when you’re slumming it out with abundance. Life has become so rich with so little expense,what with quality country liqour at 80/- , chinese phones with awesome audio and big led torch at 900, jio phone with video streaming/calling at 500, vishal pant and shirt for 500 per combo, trinkets that look like the cinderella dream, imitation cosmetics that give a whiff of cologne, fake rado watch for 200, shoes that look like million bucks for 250, quality sleaze that would shame the snooty socialites for 500, bru coffee sachet at re1. Not to talk about maruti 800 in running condition and valid rc for 10,000 not transfered of course to save rs 1800 happily cruising around with fake 3rd party insurance papers,ews house that was paid only 500 at the time of registration 20 yrs back with no care for dues, electricity tapped for free, water tax and house tax a matter of laughter. This is living high with next to nothing expense and this is real independence.
LikeLike
vinjk
August 27, 2018
Hi Vivek, are you ok?
LikeLiked by 1 person
Rocky
August 27, 2018
It has come to such a stage that Comrades think loving your Country and liking patriotic movies makes you a bhakt.
Bahut Krantikari !!!
LikeLiked by 3 people
Vivek narain
August 27, 2018
Hi vinjk, just letting you folks know the kind of independence we have over here, whatever govt,bhakt or any other. With all kinds of spurious goods available and all the drugs and all chinese electronics, we really can live deep and high if we choose to, and that’s the rare kind of independence.
LikeLike
krishna prasad
August 27, 2018
Guess chak de set a benchmark. One of the best sports movies and one of shahrukh s best performances . It still gives me a high after all these years. PS- not a sports movie, but Lakshya too manages to do the same.
LikeLike
Rocky
November 12, 2018
@ BR Review- Gold needs a director who’s a shameless hustler. There’s so little texture in the screenplay
Totally agree, there were so many points that could have been more dramatic and interesting, however overall it was a decent watch and I liked it.
P.S.- Moni Roy is eye candy.
LikeLike
ravenus1
August 10, 2021
Even as a fictional character the story of Tapan Das, a man who surmounted all manner of obstacles, including his own demons of alcoholism, to put together and guide the team that won the medal, might have been worthwhile if it had been invested with more layered characterization and entrusted to a gifted performer (Manoj Bajpayee, Irrfan Khan, Nawzuddin Siddique – any of them could have owned the part). Here it is wasted on Akshay Kumar dropping yet another big smelly deshbhakti turd. He is supposed to portray a Bengali with a drinking problem; neither aspect carries the required conviction. Mouni Roy as the stereotype nagging-but-affectionate wife only draws attention for her lips, injected with so much silicone they resemble baggage handles.
LikeLike