(by Aman Basha)
Amidst the hurricane of events completely out of the blue, with unexpected turns and twists seemingly designed to torture the mind (quite surprising how our collective state is so similar to the first day, first show audience of Race 3), it was quite the relief that on Eid, at least something was back to normal. Bhai had kept his commitment, releasing a film on Eid and after the critics pummeling, the main debate online among the fans was whether Radhe was the most watched movie on PPV or not? Ah, some things haven’t changed. For better or worse, is another online debate.
Confused? Don’t be, for I’m only following the template for this film, where anything and everything random happen for a long while and there are more random tangents yet to come. At least one ought to be thankful that this viewer is not as unmindful of time and space. People move randomly from place to place, from day to night and in such a hurried phase that one is often left confused how and why things are happening. The breakneck pace barely allows one to even register characters. For a film that tries to be a pure action film, such mistakes are a killer. And even the action set pieces are quite often laden with bad Vfx or far too unbelievable.
All said and done, this is one of Salman’s better films post Sultan, even after forgetting to mention the worst part of the film, that is the wretched romance track between Radhe and Diya, played by Disha Patani. A romance track so dull, so perfunctory, so devoid of meaning that the dialogue writer of Gully Boy could only come up with a “Diya, Nadiya” joke and this viewer only remembers the number of times Disha was wearing clothing covering her sleeves or her leg. Answer: 2. Disha Patani is supposed to play a ditzy model, and all I could see (amidst a lot that I did see.. of her) was the Calvin Klein ambassador alongside the ambassador of Dixcy Scott, in a shirtless scene with digitized abs that seemed straight out of a Calvin Klein-Dixcy Scott crossover commercial. 25 years after Bandhan, Salman still romances the Jackie Shroff character’s sister, only this actress was probably born when Badhan released.
My mind was constantly distracted looking at Radhe pretend to be a struggling model to woo his heroine, wondering where I’d seen this before. Oh yes, Ghajini! A south remake where the hero loses his hair, goes nuts after being bashed in the head and the heroine is dead. Which was another Hindi movie like this, with another iconic haircut? Tere Naam. Who was the hero there? Salman Khan. What was his character’s name? Radhe!! (I’m putting more thought in this than Prabhu Deva did, but then he got his paycheck, and I need to justify my choices).
Otherwise, this is a better film than some of Salman’s recent work, perhaps except Bharat, only here it’s more about Swachh Bharat and also has a Jai Hind. However, even the most mediocre film can, in comparison with two Salman Khan scripted films, seem like a Salim Khan scripted film. In fact, the similarities between this film and Akayla are quite fascinating. A lead actor who’s no longer able to pull off what he used to, said lead actor’s past co-star playing a much older senior as the lead is paired with an actress with whom he looks too old, the hero not being the all powerful savior he once was, quite brutal and violent fights, psychotic villains, almost the same climax. In fact, the potential in this film (ripped off from a terrific South Korean thriller) is quite frankly greater than the potential that was in Akayla, yet it is just as wasted.
The comparison with Akayla ends with the villain, as Randeep Hooda nearly steals whatever is of the show with his braids, moonwalk and style. After Nawazuddin in Kick and the late great Irrfan in Jazbaa, one is left to wonder how our arthouse actors in today’s masala seem more a throwback to the golden days of yore than stars in the mainstream. The songs are thankfully acceptable, but Prabhu Deva ought to take a break from torturing actresses with bizarre and painful steps in the name of choreographing item songs.
That leaves us with the star of whatever solar system Radhe is set in, Salman. Although delayed from a Eid 2020 release, one cannot help but feel looking at scenes shot in empty Mumbai streets, with Being Human cycles and in front of Galaxy Apartments, that Bhai simply got bored of staying in the farmhouse and called up everyone on his phone, from Bigg Boss contestants to old friends, and quickly shot his movie during the lockdown (The music is by Sajid-Wajid and Himesh, while sung mostly by Kamaal Khan and Iulia Vantur. Go figure). This kunwara-bada dilwala is too bulky and no longer sprightly enough to pull off a Chulbul Pandey as he once did. Does it matter though, as the film already breaks through the 100 crore barrier? At a scene where he parks a car next to an empty footpath, I could only envy the luck, following, devotion and goodwill the man enjoys. In a year where the world seems to have turned upside down, some things haven’t changed, and I feel thankful. And all I could say in return was, Eid Mubarak Bhai!!
brangan
May 15, 2021
Aman Basha: Superb read.
LikeLike
Naveen
May 15, 2021
Good review.
LikeLike
Yajiv
May 15, 2021
This was great, Aman! I’ve always enjoyed your lively comments and this write-up was no exception. We could all use a little normalcy (in the form of a Bhai release) this Eid, during this horrific period. Please write more on this blog (or elsewhere), if possible!
LikeLike
Kush
May 15, 2021
BR, please to review this movie too bec your bad movie reviews are the best!!
LikeLike
AdhithyaKR
May 15, 2021
“Disha Patani is supposed to play a ditzy model, and all I could see (amidst a lot that I did see.. of her) was the Calvin Klein ambassador alongside the ambassador of Dixcy Scott, in a shirtless scene with digitized abs that seemed straight out of a Calvin Klein-Dixcy Scott crossover commercial.”
Had me laughing so hard. Fun review. 🙂
LikeLike
MANK
May 15, 2021
Yup, great read. For a moment there i even mistook it for a Brangan review. That’s the highest honor around these parts 🙂
Kudos Aman
LikeLike
Anu Warrier
May 15, 2021
Aman, thanks. 🙂
I’m hard put to analyse why Salman is so popular and why he enjoys the stardom that he does. Fact remains that he is, and he does. Would much rather not watch his films, though I have a soft corner for the chap.
LikeLike
Aman Basha
May 15, 2021
One theory I’ve had about why Salman has survived despite of much better and talented stars like Sunny Deol, Govinda and Sanjay Dutt disappearing is that he has very intelligently learnt from each of them (as much as it’s shocking to associate the words intelligent and learning with Bhai). Sunny Deol was a great macho presence, a man’s man but a complete zero in comedy or dancing. Same with Dutt, though Sunny couldn’t show the vulnerability that Sanju did. Govinda is possibly the most underrated Hindi actor, a complete package but wasn’t convincing as an action hero. The interesting thing with Salman is he’s a mediocre composite of all these, thanks to his buff presence, he’s believable in fights, thanks to Dhawan, he’s convincing in comedy and has his own weird dancing style and much like Dutt, he has a bad boy image. He enjoys a greater liking with the family audience than the rest due to the Barjatya films. He’s accepted by the multiplexes more than these as well.
Thanks for the compliments, everyone. I also forgot to mention, there’s a song named Zoom Zoom.
Interestingly, Disha Patani seems to drive a yellow Volkswagen here. Seems like the Akayla comparison is deliberate.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Madan
May 15, 2021
“However, even the most mediocre film can, in comparison with two Salman Khan scripted films, seem like a Salim Khan scripted film.”
“Although delayed from a Eid 2020 release, one cannot help but feel looking at scenes shot in empty Mumbai streets, with Being Human cycles and in front of Galaxy Apartments, that Bhai simply got bored of staying in the farmhouse and called up everyone on his phone, from Bigg Boss contestants to old friends, and quickly shot his movie during the lockdown ”
Maaaan, stomach hurts from laughing. Perfect so-bad-it’s-good review, so delightful!
LikeLike
Karthik
May 16, 2021
Had a lot of fun reading this, Aman. I really like your “warts and all” fan style of writing…
LikeLike
Voldemort
May 16, 2021
*At a scene where he parks a car next to an empty footpath, I could only envy the luck, following, devotion and goodwill the man enjoys. In a year where the world seems to have turned upside down, some things haven’t changed, and I feel thankful. And all I could say in return was, Eid Mubarak Bhai!! *
Couldn’t have said it better!
Really funny piece Aman!
As an aside, Anupama Chopra, in her review of the film mentioned something along the lines of – “Who plaited Randeep Hooda’s braids? Was it one of the two sidekicks? I’d really like to know” 😂
LikeLike
Enigma
May 16, 2021
Nice review Aman. Enjoyed reading it.
LikeLike
alapan mukherjee
May 16, 2021
Well written, Aman. Very enjoyable review, just like the film itself. And that’s no sarcasm.
It turned my mind back to this video, and honestly, after watching Radhe, I cannot tell if it is parody or real.
LikeLike
Apu
May 20, 2021
What a read – thanks for this Aman Basha!
I was waiting for BR to review it, and your review was delightful, fun, and I am guessing, much better than the movie itself.
There are two things that Radhe did well for me:
(1) Pointed me to the actual Seeti Maar song which I now watch almost everyday to drool at the choreography and the superb footwork
(2) Gave me comic relief in the weird choreography in the Dil De Diya song….I still do not know what the choreographer was thinking when he made Salman pull up his pants…and…well whatever.
LikeLike
Madan
May 20, 2021
“One theory I’ve had about why Salman has survived despite of much better and talented stars like Sunny Deol, Govinda and Sanjay Dutt disappearing is that he has very intelligently learnt from each of them ” – I wanted to discuss this tangentially and forgot to post so here goes.
I have mentioned this incident before but once when I was waiting at the airport with my driver to pick up my father (this was back in college when I had time on the weekends to go to the airport for fun), I saw Sanjay Dutt come out of the terminal. My driver exclaimed, “Sonjoy Dott” (he was a Bong) and rushed to him for an autograph. So did many other such drivers waiting for their masters. A few minutes back, Bipasha Basu had walked by and was barely recognized.
Sanjay Dutt had tremendous mass appeal. That’s why even the film based on him, even with its recounting of him aiding the underworld in storing AK 56 rifles, was still a massive hit. He is somehow immune to the current polarization (as is Salman).
Had Sanjay not been such an enfant terrible and not been embroiled in TADA (NOT that I think he shouldn’t have because he deserved it), he could have had a very different career. He actually managed comedy well in the Munnabhai films even though it doesn’t come naturally to him. He could well have been a major threat to the Khans had he not been so in-and-out. Even Salman’s own career was pretty chequered until the streak that began in 2009 or so.
Govinda had a huge mass following. He suffered because he got too specialized in comedy and when a type of comedy runs its course, it kills the comedian concerned too. He was also involved only in a brand of vulgar, tapori comedy which was ill suited to the multiplexisation of Bollywood.
Sunny had a mass following in Punjab, I guess, but not generally speaking. Outside Punjab, he wouldn’t inspire people to turn up and watch just for his name. Whatever be his limitations, he was essentially an actor trying to be a star. And an actor lacks that fourth wall effect that is necessary for the audience’s affections to get transferred to the real person behind the reel.
Though I never liked Sanjay Dutt the person, I have seen first hand that he inspired the kind of frenzy that Salman alone does till date in Bolly and which Tamil/Telugu stars do. If you leave aside technical attributes and focus on personality, he was probably the most suitable to take on AB’s mantle. Because he had a towering presence and an uncanny charisma without necessarily looking very handsome and he could convey a lot of power through his gaze without having to mouth ‘dialogue-baazi’. As an ACTOR, of course, AB is miles ahead of him. But Sanjay could have been the Amitabh of the 90s were it not for his indiscipline and the troubles he got into.
LikeLiked by 2 people
Aman Basha
May 20, 2021
@Madan: Have to also add, when it comes to Sanju and Salman, I see a very strong Muslim following. For example, a lot of the autos in Muslim areas of Bangalore have either Baba or Bhai on the windows. Of course, this might be purely because Muslims are mostly single screen audience, but one can’t help but feel if their criminal history somewhere resonates with the Muslim community’s complex en large.
In a sense, the public thinks of both as “bechara, has done some terrible things, but still so kind and good at heart”. Maybe the Muslim community perceives itself that way?
LikeLiked by 1 person
Aman Basha
May 20, 2021
“without necessarily looking very handsome”
I think a great deal of the public, 349 women (roundly) and Madhuri Dixit disagree with you.
About frenzy, I do think SRK did/sort of does evoke frenzy amongst unlikely candidates for frenzy: women and the “class audience”.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Madan
May 20, 2021
” Of course, this might be purely because Muslims are mostly single screen audience, but one can’t help but feel if their criminal history somewhere resonates with the Muslim community’s complex en large.” – Quite possible. Sanjay Dutt was in fact a staunch secularist who at one point professed that he had stored those weapons to teach the Hindutva idiots a lesson (you can’t make this up!). The irony was he ended up forcing his father to seek Bal Thackeray’s intervention to save him. That said, I have definitely seen a lot of following for both in Hindu quarters as well. I mean who else but Bhai could have pulled off acting in the most conservative of Hindi film franchises – the Barjatya ones, that is! Lots of Marwaris and Gujaratis in Bombay still have a joint family concept and even if they no longer live in the same apartment, they are very close knit and help each other a lot. They relate to Salman’s Barjatya films a lot. And many of them probably migrated to the Dabbang-avatar of Salman too.
LikeLike
Satya
May 20, 2021
There’s a scene where Radhe pretends to be a struggling model and gets a lift from Diya. He successfully manages to make her buy his facade, and drops it just right before the gate of the Galaxy apartments. Was Prabhu sir going meta? And then there was the cross-dressed Jackie Shroff dancing with Salman Khan which was not funny at all. What did these guys make in the name of masala?
LikeLiked by 1 person
Madan
May 21, 2021
Aman Basha: Like I said in the other thread, SRK was somewhat like the Kamal of Hindi cinema. Short and not a highly impressive personality but has a certain lovability. And an effervescence that even Kamal didn’t quite have. So, yeah, he too had a strong following among women and class audience. The problem is the class audience is the most fickle in the sense they do want the films to be at least decent to remain invested. So such actors get punished a lot more for their most missteps. Rajesh Khanna and Mohan are the most extreme examples of this kind of star. They were almost unbeatable at the BO at their peak and then, boom! Overnight they were no longer hot property.
LikeLike
anonymousviolin20
May 21, 2021
I think another similarity between Kamal and SRK is this sort of revisionism in their filmography.
Nowadays, if you check imdb, social media, and YouTube comments, you’ll see people praising movies like Anbe Sivam that were definite flops in their time.
I’ve seen a similar thing with regard to SRK’s non Rahul/Raj films. Films like Dil Se or Swades. People praise these films and lament that they let down the “actor” SRK by not making them huge hits.
Kamal and SRK also both share a film with this fate (Hey Ram)
LikeLiked by 1 person
Aman Basha
May 22, 2021
@Madan: I’d say Aamir is Kamal with the box office success that Kamal had in the 90s. I’ve read articles where Kamal post Indian was supposed to be as popular as Rajni post Endhiran. However, the failure of Thugs of Hindostan is still baffling to say the least. Underperformer would have been fine, but being a disaster of this level is unimaginable. It’s almost as though audiences were punishing Aamir for Dhoom 3 with this film.
Me thinks we shall never agree on SRK vis-à-vis Salman.
LikeLike
Madan
May 22, 2021
” I’ve read articles where Kamal post Indian was supposed to be as popular as Rajni post Endhiran.” – Trust me, as someone who did live through that time, he wasn’t. He never was. At least post Baasha, there’s never been a time when Kamal equalled Rajni’s popularity, let alone matching Rajni’s pan India popularity post Endhiran. Kamal is way too whimsical to have had a noughties-Aamir like career. Kamal keeps experimenting, keeps slipping and then bounces back…or at least used to until the last few years. Given his range, you cannot make an exact parallel between Kamal and SRK but the core strengths are similar – a softness that is particularly attractive to women and great comic timing. Kamal is MUCH better at comedy than SRK but SRK OTOH can project more intensity. Except when he’s doing comedy, Kamal makes you very much aware that he’s acting. It’s like he wants you to acknowledge his labours. Maybe there is some transference there from how the respective actors speak. SRK is very fast and spontaneous even in interviews while Kamal is very deliberate and prefers a low pitched mumble. 😛
LikeLike
Aman Basha
May 22, 2021
@Madan: My, my, you’re way overrating SRK here. Comparing him to Kamal, sacrilege. SRK is basically a star with some actor in him, for me, he was playing both Chak De and Dear Zindagi in the same mode, you could mix up scenes from both films and there’d be problem of continuity. Even Suri from RNBDJ is the same Kishanlal from Paheli. Josh is Don as a street goon. Dil Se was the ultimate SRK romantic film, where you see shades of Darr and Anjaam, shades of DDLJ, essentially the romantic persona clicks with the film in a perfect way. Sadly, his performances in films post Fan are actually the ones which are some of his best.
In a sense, SRK can be compared to Rajni, both have limited range but incredible screen presence, started out as negative characters and got trapped in a star image. SRK seems too instinctive, maybe with the right choices, he could have evolved into a Jim Carrey, but then instincts can often derail a performance like Duplicate (WTF). Aamir was also a chocolate boy like Kamal who acquired the rep of a great actor, and Kamal’s showoff phase was probably post-Nayagan/Appu Raja. One of the best things SRK ever did was act in Hey Ram for free, that’s an instant classic. SRK, Rajni are star actors while Kamal and Aamir are actor stars.
I can’t find the article about Kamal post Indian, but I do remember reading that the Hindi dubbed version did as well as other Hindi stars’ films and the National Award was the cherry on the cake, with Queen Elizabeth II coming to inaugurate his next film, which took too long to shoot and was ultimately shelved. To make up for the time, he ended up doing Hey Ram.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Madan
May 23, 2021
“My, my, you’re way overrating SRK here. Comparing him to Kamal, sacrilege” – I am not. You didn’t read this part: “Given his range, you cannot make an exact parallel between Kamal and SRK”. This is similar to how I compared Sanjay Dutt with AB WITHOUT equating their acting skills. As an actor, Kamal is in a totally different league compared to SRK. I am talking about what are their strengths in terms of what makes them popular. In those regards they are quite similar.
” I do remember reading that the Hindi dubbed version did as well as other Hindi stars’ films and the National Award was the cherry on the cake” – It did well in the prestige sweepstakes, as usual. But the highest grosser in 1996 was Raja Hindustani with a whopping Rs.48 crore.
https://boxofficeindia.com/years.php?year=1996&pageId=4
Indian made Rs.25 crore in Tamil but I don’t think even Telugu plus Hindi combined would have made up the difference with Raja Hindustani. And no chance of the Hindi version alone grossing as much as Raja Hindustani. Chachi 420 was a bigger hit for Kamal in Hindi (than Hindustani). He got a Filmfare nomination for it too. And even that was no. 12 in the list of 1997 top hits.
https://boxofficeindia.com/years.php?year=1997&pageId=4
Don’t ask why more people watched Dil Toh Pagal Hai, Ishq, Judaai, Gupt or Hero No.1. That’s how it was back then. The one 97 film that I liked more than Chachi 420 – Yes Boss – finished below it.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Aman Basha
May 25, 2021
@Madan: Endhiran in 2010 barely did 20 crore net. Indian in 1996, dubbed as Hindustani made almost 10 crore. It was definitely big in Hindi. This is from Box Office India’s Archive, which makes more sense than current collections due to the figures matching the perception.
https://web.archive.org/web/20110708090252/http://boxofficeindia.com/showProd.php?itemCat=318&catName=MjAxMA==
http://web.archive.org/web/20120505192812/http://boxofficeindia.com/showProd.php?itemCat=203&catName=MTk5Nw==
I’m sure that Indian could have done quite well in Andhra, Karnataka and Kerala, at least to the tune of 10 crore from these territories. The film was certainly huge and if not, Kamal could never started Marudhanayagam, which was supposed to be the most expensive Indian film, nor could he have got Queen Elizabeth of all people to open it.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Madan
May 25, 2021
Aman Basha: Wow. That’s a surprise to me. I will have to bow to the data, I guess. Because there was zero buzz about Hindustani where I lived and I lived in a downmarket suburb so it was a fairly reliable indicator of which films did well pan India. And also, the buzz for Enthiran Hindi by comparison was incredible. That Hindustani would have done half of Enthiran Hindi in 96 rupees sounds unbelievable to me. But I guess I will have to accept what boxofficeindia says as there is no other source of box office collection data anyway.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Aman Basha
May 26, 2021
@Madan: I have it on good authority that Hindustani had housefull theatres in Kanpur. Also, pre Padayappa, Kamal was a much bigger star than Rajni in the Telugu States. He’s made some iconic films in Telugu, Maro Charitra, Sagara Sangamam and Swati Mutyam are easily some of the greatest films made there. A great deal of his films did well as Telugu dubbed.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Madan
May 28, 2021
Not directly related to the topic but the same era and an interesting look into how dominant the music industry was at the time. It’s funny that both in Hindi and in the US, the dividend of this dominance (in the 90s) was mostly wasted in producing mediocre products that were assured of selling well but lacked the memorability that hits used to have earlier. Remember this was still before widespread internet usage and just forget about smartphones. They HAD the audience’s attention span and COULD have taken risks but greed completely took over.
https://www.indiatoday.in/magazine/cover-story/story/19941115-bollywood-hinges-on-hindi-film-music-industry-fans-soak-up-wacky-new-sounds-809899-1994-10-31
LikeLike