(by Ramamoorthi N, written on his Facebook page a few years ago)
In the small Railway town I grew up, my mother (God bless her soul) would dress in a dotted saree and dark “cooling” glasses whenever she stepped out of home, thus creating the effect of one of the many middle aged heroines the early Kamal romanced in his movies. Earning for herself the sobriquet, “Kamalahasan Mami”. That was the impact Kamalahasan had, 500 km away from where he lived. (To me, he will always be Kamalahasan. Not Kamal Hassan. Just like it will always be Mount Road, not Anna Salai.)
Years ago when I tagged along with my mother to watch his movies, he was this funny and devilishly handsome guy. (God, you wanted to be that guy!) Later of course, I watched with overflowing Tamil pride when the world hailed him as a great actor who did impossible roles and won all those awards.
But today, when I reflect on his completing 57 years in cinema, I think he’s not an actor.
(Spoiler alert, click-bait leading to nothing controversial! )
Great actors bring meaning to their roles from inside. Kamal is so much more. He sees his roles from outside, from his audience’s seat, so he knows exactly the effect he needs to create. And how to get it.
So Kamal is this street smart production manager who somehow seems to have access to hundreds of wigs, props and other things. Much like Imelda Marcos and her shoes, he probably opens his cupboard every morning and goes, “Ah, I’ll look like this today”. Maybe the inspiration is derived from the blockbuster productions of stage masters like RS Manohar.
He is a talent scout who liberally borrows looks and mannerisms from people across the world. Dev Anand/Gregory Peck have appeared in romantic scenes. Al Pacino was in “MMKR”. I know Telugu so I know who GK Rayudu (“Indrudu Chandrudu”) and Balaram Naidu (“Dasavatharam”) are but I won’t tell.
He’s the cinematic equivalent of a cardsharp, secretly exulting in the success of his undiscovered con. For years, he never revealed how they made Appu happen.
To portray violence in a character, Kamal just uses teeth. Yes, teeth. Try the psychopathic Dileep (“Sigappu Rojakkal”), the murderous Michael (“MMKR”) or the mentally unhinged Nandu (“Aalavandhaan”).
He understands language and dialogue writing like no other in this country, or perhaps anywhere in the world. He embarrasses us Tamilians with his deep knowledge and use of the language. If you think his mastery is limited to different dialects of Tamil, watch the “Sharma” scene in “Chachi 420”. By the way, he is also the guy who gave us our first “foreign return” English.
He has an awesome perception of cultural atmosphere. I’m not being racist here, but it is unbelievable that a Brahmin by birth can direct and/or play “Virumandi” and “PKS”.
People who know and watch movies in multiple languages will understand this – I hate remakes because I feel cheated when I go to the theatre to find out I’ve seen the story before.But even here Kamal adds layers to create a new experience. “Papanasam”, the most recent example of such sleight-of-hand, turned out to be a drishyam within a Drishyam.
My wish for Kamalahasan on his 57th year? He keeps calling himself a student of cinema but I think it’s time he also becomes the coach. And not just in a Drona- Ekalavya way which only leads to poor imitations. I’d love to see him direct more, direct other lead actors, give them characters he’d normally play, pass on his tradecraft as unselfishly as the master directors of the past passed them on to him.
Selfishly speaking, Indian cinema needs Kamalahasan to be Akram teaching swing to young bowlers more than it needs for him to be Colin Cowdrey out to take on Lillee and Thommo.
May he be around for 57 years more! May his art live 10 times longer!
Anu Warrier
November 30, 2019
Amen! 🙂 Your reaction to Kamalahasan (yes, he’ll aways be that to me, as well) is the same as mine. Your wishes for his future career in cinema are the same as mine. He’s probably forgotten more about cinema than a lot of people will learn in their lifetimes.
And I absolutely loved the ‘Kamalahasan maami’ touch. It made me smile.
LikeLiked by 2 people
AdhithyaKR
December 1, 2019
Talking about how he acts with his teeth, I remember how he acted with his jaw in Virumandi – In the panchayat scene and the scene where he kills pashupathi
LikeLiked by 2 people
Madan
December 1, 2019
Great write up and tend to agree with the crux. Yes, it’s time for Kamal to become a mentor.
LikeLiked by 1 person
shaviswa
December 1, 2019
I see Virumandi often referred to as one of Kamal’s best. I tried watching that film twice. Each time I failed to get past the 30 min mark. I just could not watch the film at all. I felt that movie was crass and very uninteresting. And every time people bring it up in discussions, it makes me think what did these people see that I missed 🙂
LikeLike
theeversriram
December 1, 2019
@shaviswa, Virumandi was Kamal’s last great movie. After that everything he wrote/directed was a dud or disappointment (Papanasam/VV were movies that he started in). Hope he gets some much needed box office success with Indian 2.
LikeLiked by 4 people
Honest Raj
December 1, 2019
Frankly, I came here to say good things about AS, but …
… but it is unbelievable that a Brahmin by birth can direct and/or play “Virumandi” and “PKS”
Kamal, the actor, seemed just an odd man out in the film. He was no match for Napoleon, Pasupathy and the rest. Even the casting of Abhirami was very convincing.
His “innate ability” to switch between dialects is way overrated. May be, his Madras and Madurai Tamil sound good because he was born and brought up in those places. The rest – like the pretentious one in Papanasam – are mediocre to above average a best.
LikeLiked by 4 people
Honest Raj
December 1, 2019
In terms of physical comedy, his GK Rayudu in Indrudu Chandrudu is one of the great performances by a lead actor.
LikeLike
(Original) venkatesh
December 1, 2019
So , the difference between Kamal and the other “actors” of today is his innate ability to understand, predict and in some ways direct the audience reaction.
He is not trying to be real, he is actively trying to manipulate the audience. He will pull out all the tricks required to do that and what tricks they are ., its scarcely believable that its the same actor who can do Charlie Chaplin, Peter Sellers and Marlon Brando.
Folks, who refer to him as the successor of Sivaji miss that Kamal’s bag of tricks are a lot more refined, polished and he is just naturally more talented.
LikeLiked by 3 people
Ramn
December 2, 2019
@Honestraj – I don’t agree that he was not good in Virumandi, but yes Pashupathy and Napoleon brought in as much as he did. ( in retrospect he was probably a casting oddity for that story – vellai thol and all) – explained away as “Singapore machchaan)
LikeLiked by 1 person
RAMESH
December 2, 2019
Hi.. very well researched and penned..i saw sollathan ninaikkiren at blore in September 1973 when i was 9 yrs.. where in he played a very slick handsome pencil lined moustache and tights slim fit pants…i fell for him. And since then no looking back as i was born and brought up in blore and made sure i saw all his movies including his earlier malayalam ones from where his bounty of awards started accumulating and still continuing.we used to rush to Hosur or Krishnagiri for fist day morning show as then Tamil films were released in blore 2/3 months after the initial release in TN. am happy and proud to say that we have sailed together for 46 years.. and more to come.. vaazha aandavar
LikeLiked by 3 people
Honest Raj
December 2, 2019
@Ramn: What exactly is Singapore machchaan? A Singapore return? Can you elaborate a bit more on that?
It’s not the ‘vella thol’ factor per se. Take the cases of Karthi (in Paruthiveeran) and Aadhi Pinisetty (in Mirugam). Both are fair-skinned heroes, at least by Tamil cinema standards, but they brilliantly portrayed their roles as a village ruffian in both films.
LikeLiked by 2 people
V
December 2, 2019
“Kamal’s ability to switch between dialects is overrated” – As a non-native speaker, there is only so much he can achieve, while at the same time not sounding alien to the rest of the audience. For eg, Im from Madras – in Virumandi, which I watched in a theater, Kamal’s was the only dialect that I could “get” in the first watch. Not Napolean”s not Pasupathy’s. Even now, even with my headphones on, I still miss the nuances which my Madurai-kkara husband (who infact speaks a different Tamizh) could pick up right away.
Similarly, in Kizhakku Cheemayile – Vadivelu’s dialogues sounded gibberish to me, with the poor audio system of the 90s in theaters. Whereas what Vijayakumar or Radhika spoke, came through clearly. Even someone like Bharathiraja who is part of that milieu, had to tone down the language for the sake of reachability.
Now, Kamal is a star-actor and for the budget of his films, he needs to make his films accessible. That too, back then, when there was no other source (www) for the audience to explore unknown stuff.
Regarding, “looks” – the Virumandi character is by large a Murattu Muttaal from those parts of TN and I felt, Kamal got the cue correctly. (Note the difference in his body language between Vasool Raja Muradan and Virumandi Muradan).
Like how Dhanush in Asuran or Maari is unlikely to be the actual character in reality and yet, more than makes up for it with his performance, I feel, Kamal too gets the overall vibe right (like Manorama, another actor who has tried her hand at various dialects)
LikeLiked by 1 person
H Syed Abdul Qadir
December 2, 2019
Bulls Eye
LikeLike
Mary Masolica
December 2, 2019
Kamal, Anna is a great man he will put is effect more, Anna you are the great hero I am very proud to be your fancy Anna
LikeLike
brangan
December 3, 2019
LikeLiked by 3 people
Honest Raj
December 3, 2019
As a non-native speaker, there is only so much he can achieve, while at the same time not sounding alien to the rest of the audience.
I don’t disagree – all I’m saying is that he’s being overrated. But then, it’s understandable because the bar is pretty low as far as Tamil cinema is concerned.
About Virumandi, the point isn’t really about his performance – I believe he’s the most flexible actor in India – but about his choice to cast himself in the lead role. Of course, this is very much subjective and we can agree to disagree.
LikeLike
krishikari
December 4, 2019
+1 for Kamalahasan and your cool mom.
LikeLike